Green = Red: Life As a Real ‘No Impact Man’
by Yervand KocharWhen the second plane flew into the World Trade Center, our family friend, Albert, who was watching the attack on TV in Armenia, had a major heart attack. His sister was working in the second tower. Three hours later, she called him. Her voice was trembling; she had a nervous breakdown but she was uninjured. My friend heard the good news in the emergency room. He died two weeks later at the age of 54.

Albert was the last casualty of 9/11 that I know of. Although, I am sure there are more people who were indirectly impacted by the attack to some serious and even fatal degree.
Albert was also famous for his devastating sense of humor, so when I read about the highly heralded eco-melodramatic documentary “No Impact Man,” I vividly imagined Albert ripping this self-righteous excretion of bored urban utopians a new one.
Here’s the premise from the “No Impact Man” film website:
Colin Beavan decides to completely eliminate his personal impact on the environment for the next year. It means eating vegetarian, buying only local food, and turning off the refrigerator. It also means no elevators, no television, no cars, buses, or airplanes, no toxic cleaning products, no electricity, no material consumption, and no garbage. No problem – at least for Colin – but he and his family live in Manhattan. So when his espresso-guzzling, retail-worshipping wife Michelle and their two-year-old daughter are dragged into the fray, the No Impact Project has an unforeseen impact of its own.
This is so cute; I am going to melt now. This kind of eco-experimentation is cute when it is acted out in Manhattan of 2009 and it is tragic when it is experienced in Armenia of 1992 where Albert lived in the center of the capital, Yerevan, in a neo-classically influenced apartment building with massive wooden doors.
Those doors ignited my imagination; as a kid, I even wrote a poem in which I visualized the doors as a portal to a different dimension. Years later, in the cover of a pitch-black winter night of 1992, my friends and I dismantled and stole those century-old doors, chopped them into many pieces and shared them among ourselves for wood to heat our homes. We had to because we had no electricity and it was incredibly cold.
After the collapse of the Soviet Union, Armenia found itself engaged in full-scale war with Azerbaijan. As a consequence of the deliberately interdependent Soviet infrastructure, Armenian’s economic and energy routes lay through Azerbaijani territory. The Azerbaijani blockade that followed (and is still in place) cast the unprepared and newly formed Republic of Armenia into a horrible economic and energy crisis.
Not only there was a scarcity of supplies in every arena, but there was virtually no gas or electricity to heat our homes. For two years, we would have electricity for a total of two hours a day.
Those winters—which, of course, happened to be some of the coldest in the modern history of Armenia—caused many deaths of unprepared people in their own homes.
The daily two hours of electricity were anticipated with the devotional reverence of a desert tribe welcoming rain. People would try to squeeze in anything from laundry to cooking, watching TV to just enjoying the magic of the electric bulb.
When the hours of electricity expired, like cavemen we would gather around the fireplace, quiet and collectively depressed, with no impact on the world or even on our immediate surroundings. Only in times like that is one capable of understanding the true magic and liberating power that technology gives to man. The ability to be free and proud, strong and happy, are based not on our merging with nature but on our ability to master nature, to control and oppose its powers, to use our reason and skill to elevate ourselves from the dark and wild realm of frightened beasts struggling merely to survive under the whim of capricious surrounding.
Two hours of electricity during the cold winter was not enough to heat our homes and city apartments, so people started chopping trees on the streets and parks for firewood.
Old beautiful trees were rapidly disappearing from city streets, turning the famously green Yerevan into a bare skeleton of itself. People needed heat to survive—between preserving trees and watching babies freeze to death; there was not much of a choice.
The demand for firewood was huge, though, and people became protective of their territories. Tree chopping gangs, armed with axes and machetes, formed to protect their neighborhood trees and distribute the wood among them.
In savagery and ragged outlook, these gangs were not much different from prehistoric territorial tribes. Police would not dare to confront them, especially when their own reservoir of gas was almost non-existent and they could not even promptly respond to many serious emergencies.
Fierce fights would ensue if someone tried to cut a tree in someone else’s yard or park. My friends and I, soft and spoiled city slackers, were now thrown into this anarchic struggle for life, spending hours in bread lines and chopping wood, dismantling wooden doors and benches in the parks to which we used to be taken by our parents in our not-so-distant childhood.
It was through chopping wood that I came to identify with Abraham Lincoln in such a way that years later I would make a very personal film about his legacy.
There was something comforting in knowing that the President of that faraway country that my friends and I idealized so much would also chop wood and go through harsh times before he was able to make an impact… and boy, we wanted to make an impact!
From our shared experience of the ‘dark age’ we carried out a zealous urge to make an impact, to claim our existence in the family of nations, to tell everyone that we are alive, that we are human, that we matter, that we want to achieve something, and that we don’t want to perish in this damn darkness of animal fear.
And then there is, of course, Albert, who was fatally impacted by the acts of 19 evil men whom he’d never met or heard of. Sorry for the doors, my friend. I’ll plant a tree in your memory in this faraway land that you and your sister loved. I’ll plant it for all the trees that I had to cut back home. Those beautiful trees that helped us survive through the nightmares of those ‘unimpactful’ winters of ‘92 through ‘94.





Subscribe via RSS
73 Comments
[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Big Hollywood, Michael Chavez and DNC DUDES, Mr. Pink. Mr. Pink said: Green = Red: Life As a Real ‘No Impact Man’ http://tinyurl.com/yljybrc [...]
Thank you for sharing this story. It is too easy to think of these "noble experiments" in a sort of vacuum. Your experience is a far more valuable lesson. My condolences for the loss of your friend. I hope he is in a better place.
That is something I think the spoiled eco-warriors in this country should experience: a true taste of their own utopia. See what it's REALLY like to have to "live off the land", to truly live a "back to nature" lifestyle. I didn't accept modern technology to chop wood again.
*MissQuinn*
Over here in Canada, we didn't hear about Armenia's trials in those years. But, if the many people who wish to trash this technology of ours in favor of living the sensitive eco friendly life, well, we may experience our own trials. A lot of the time, I feel like I'm living in an insane asylum.
marxists dont want us to 'exploit" "resources" like coal and wood because they respect only one resource, the "people". in detroit there are no 'resources' except the vicious ignorant demvoters. justified by their class warfare they have stripped detroit of its 'trees" ( the productive middle class) and now the only thing left are the classwarlords and the class(un)concious. for the entertainment i went on a ride thru the area around downtown (the green zone) to tour all the 'gardens' and laughed as the locals walked right up the bicyclists demanding crack money. lucky for them i was present to shew them away with my car antennae i use for dogs…
its only because hot chicks are hippies and like the softfascism that anyone cares to even notice them greens.
Great story and very illuminating about the "fashionably green" snobs and their "smugness". (See South Park)
I saw a story this summer on BBC 1 or 2 or….anyway, while in London I saw a story where this reporter and his family got ride of the car and went as "green" as possible, he even got *all pissed* because he couldn't get a freakin' windmill electricity generator on his roof! Anyway this idiot reporter has to walk his wife to a hospital when she goes into labor and all kinds of idiotic inconvieniences all to PRAY at the ALTAR of the leftist green fraudulent snow job called "Climate Change".
Remember the real victims of the logical end to the world green movement – socialism bending toward communism.
It was tried, it failed – these men can tell us about it, from first hand experience.
Wow! What a story. What you have described is the environmental utopia envisioned by Owlgore, of coarse not for gore but us regular people. We have to fight theses backward bastards with every ounce of energy or we’ll find ourselves in Armenia (no offense) ’92.
Well said, Yervand…
On a related note, I have a friend who will occasionally go off on a rant about how evil corporations are, how they are destroying the world, blahblahblah (all the usual crapola); he will do this even as we all sit there listening to music on his stereo and/or watching cable TV, drinking commercially-produced beer, eating commercially-produced food, etc; one of these days I think I will have to grab his big, heavy, 'barbarian sword' hanging on one of the ceiling beams, and start a little tirade:
"Dude, I couldn't agree with you more, and I'm ready to help you get all this evil out of your life! Let's start with you CD's and your DVD's; they are all funded, produced, and distributed by corporations. Next we will work on the stereo; again, all produced and distributed (and, incidentally, researched by) corporations. We can then move on to the TV and DVD player, then your computer; that will make a nice start. Then, if we can find someone with an acetelyne torch we can move on to those mountain & street bikes that you are so proud of."
And so on and so forth…
I will probably never actually do it, but its a lot of fun to think about.
This is a wonderful article, full of truth.
The backward bastards, as StanH called them, are coming for us.
Those enviro-facist weenies have no idea how lucky the are to live in the bountiful wonderful USA. Although I loved watching Ed Begley Jr. having a conniption fit the other day on TV, at least he walks th e walk more than anyone else who espouses the same beliefs, that I know of, which is his choice. The problem is, is the envirowhackos want to eliminate all choices, i.e. it is their way or the highway.
The writer of this article illustrates perfectly clear, why we are and should be proud of this country.
I agree with about ol' Ed B. he does "walk the walk". I wonder how he's reacting to "ClimateGate"?
Why do these fools want to drag us all back to the Middle Ages? If they want to live like paupers, let them. But don't force it on those of us who do not want to live that way!
I wish I knew some of these hard core environmentalists personally. I'd love to ask them why they feel they have the right to force their morals on me. I'd bet they'd be screaming bloody murder if I tried to force my morals (which are biblically based) upon them!
Do it. But you have to report back.
[...] more: Green = Red: Life As a Real ‘No Impact Man’ This entry is filed under America – Blogs, Big Hollywood. You can follow any responses to this [...]
Isn't it ironic that they call themselves Progressive?
Methinks they protest too much. They like to protest.
I think he and other true believers in AGW, are going to be having a very hard time, and yeah I think it was the source of his anger. Did you watch it? I kinda felt bad for him, he's so delusional. Because he doesn't strike me as a bad guy.
As someone who lives in Toronto, I experience this leftist mental asylum on a regular basis. Can you imagine how normal people who have to live in the "world class city" of Vancouver feel?
Fascinating story, Mr. Kochar. I went to the No Impact website and wondered how many people have signed up for the No Impact Project. Sounds like fun. Oh, sorry, did I say fun? I meant to say insane.
No I didn't see it but ya Ed Begly Jr. stikes me as a really authentic nice guy. Maybe he's angry these lying scientists are punking all their loyal supporters into looking foolish.
Thank you for you kind words.
If only ALL New Yorkers would be as enlightened as the Armenians were.
Then Colin Beavan could be beaten, robbed and eaten by starving millions of carbon neutral famine sufferers.
If Beavan wants a real "no impact" life, let him live in the Amazon with just a loincloth and a pointy stick, or, for real adventure, in Central Park.
Seriously, Mr.Kochar, great article.
Men like Colin Beavan live lives of comfort, prosperity, and leisure unimaginable even by kings 200 years ago, and are weighted with guilt.
We don't really want to see DrMorbius in prison, but I DO want to see about two million of those green Calvinists living in a Pol Pot commune, sharing the glories of life without technology. About 10 years ought to do it.
It was the source of his rage, and he screamed that it was all irrelevant and the true science is all on his side, all "peer reviewed". The delusion for him is complete and immune to contrary facts.
It is their version of Calvinism. Having "risen above" all religion to the new altar of "SCIENCE", they have found new meaning in their lives. It is absolute, it is relentless, it is almost exactly what Conan the Barbarian found in the followers of Falsa Doom. Funny by the way how Conan has become a high priest of the New Church!
Such precious, self-righteous, impractical environmental gestures are just plain boring and grating. Veggies only? How do those get into the city except in refrigerated trucks using diesel, engine oil, wooden pallets, fork lifts, more refrigeration, plastic wrapping, on and on…?
For every loopy eco-friendly dolt like him there are about 1,000 Chinese, Indians, Africans, and others burning carbon-based fuel sending millions of tons of particulates into the atmosphere, melting the Himalayan glaciers, sending even more into the jet stream to pollute our skies, and wishing they could have his options.
I wish many more citizens of former Soviet Satellites and republics would speak up as Yervand has and knock some sense into at least 51% of our cosseted, myopic electorate with their true stories of the hells created by "socialism," which is just a euphemism for some form of dictatorship and tyranny over individual freedom.
I happened to be in a Neiman's on Black Friday in the late 80s with two sisters who had escaped to the West. They had risked their lives holding Mass in their basement before coming to freedom. We watched as women mobbed a table with designer handbags–fighting each other for purses. One sister watched and offered, "I used to see people do that for meat."
These environmentalists are more pushy than any religion I have ever seen! (Except maybe Islam. At least they haven't resorted to violence. Yet.)
I am really starting to think this guilt thing is at the root of so much of this stuff. I can't think of any other explanation for such insanity!
Wow.
Newsflash for Colin… the methane given off from the rotting inedible portions of his vegan diet, composted or not, is one of the most effective greenhouse gasses produced by the activity of man…. MANY times more effective than CO2.
I bet Colin, and the film maker, are one of those idiots who think their plug in car is low enviro-impact… forgetting coal or oil was burned to generate the magic go juice that springs forth from the wall.
I thought liberals were supposed to be smart?
wow, i was reading this, called over my mom, and she completely knew who your grandfather was. haha, i'm sending it to all of my family now. its nice to know that most of the population isn't the armenians who don't shamelessly collect welfare checks and drive their beamers (but are displayed like crazy). they give us all a bad name; but i digress.
your story was super helpful; it created a visual display and helped me further digest this huge chunk of not only the loss of personal choice (a clockwork orange is on tonight, how appropriate) but the silly idea that humans have created "global warmning"
The Red EcoStalinistas desire to force everyone to experience Big Joe's Ukrainian successes! The Time to isolate these creatures of ignorance is approaching.
Thanks Jeamesb,
I regret, though, that I did not mention the fact that the nuclear energy station that had been operating in Armenia and had been responsible for 80% of electricity supply before the independence was shut down under the pressure from the opposition that used 'ecology' for their political advantage.
For those who doubt the link between the 'eco' movement and totalitariansim, this is might be a helpful example.
Thank you, Pol_Potsie,
What's more insane is that this lame nonsense was so well promoted.
Thank you very much for appreciating the article.
I agree with you 100%. I don't think Mr. Beaven can survive one winter even in Central Park with his 'no impact' method.
Thank you Nancy,
Most of Armenians in America are hard working and honest people who don't crazily drive thier beamers. We prefer Mercedes
I am very happy that you found this article helpful. Say hello to your Mom and family.
Sabotage, though, which is violence at a distance.
Re: Kings: ever read the Bill Whittle piece where he uses his Time Machine and takes a Pharoah to a wonder of modern technology? Hilarious.
I agree about the guilt- I think the realization that every move they make has an environmental impact is what drives some enviro's crazy enough to want to kill about 90% of the rest of us. Not them, of course- someone has to run the sustainable villages apres le deluge (of blood).
So get a gun, pantywaist.
They wouldn't last 10 days before they'd be screaming to be freed and again enjoy the benefits of belonging to this "wasteful" society.
My guess is that his peers are complimenting him for being so environmentally conscious, but laughing at him behind his back.
It would be worse than the Middle Ages. We wouldn't be able to cut down trees, it would be against the law. We would have to depend on everything being provided by the state so we don't have any detrimental impact on the environment. It's all about control and how much we would have to relinquish over every aspect of our lives. No wonder these bastard leftists embrace this movement so easily and so fully. They want to be the controllers because they know better than the rest of us.
Get a book.
I have plenty of guns. Unfortunately, the government has the superior firepower.
You really should try to rise from your mentally inferior position.
Great article! What is also amazing is that his hero is Joe McCarthy, living and working where he does. "He is a voting member of The Academy of Television Arts & Sciences." I need to go lay down now haha.
His bio is too short. Sounds like it would be a great book and movie!
What is it about BMWs and Mercedes anyway? Everyone here in the US think that they're the pinnacle of the automotive industry. They're good, yeah, but I can't help remembering that they're used as taxis in Germany. No big deal. I drive a Jeep Gran Cherokee with a big honking engine. Oh, but it is E85-capable (even though I wouldn't unless forced) so I'm able to tell all disapproving greenies to stick it where the sun don't shine.
The new Dark Ages?
Awesome!
Bring back the Divine Right of uh,………Globalwarmenists!
THIS IS WHAT IT SOUNDS LIKE WHEN GODS DIE
http://naturalfake.wordpress.com/2009/11/28/this-...
If these morons actually wanted to impress anyone beyond their sycophantic circle of activist friends, then they should have moved to a remote location in North Dakota, Wyoming, or Alaska, grow their own food, and live in an eco-friendly log cabin without any power or links to the evil civilization they despise so much.
In fact, I actively encourage all environmentalists to test out their eco-chops in said manner for no less than a ten year period. Nature has it's own way of curing terminal stupidity.
What gets me is that they'd be just as miserable under those types of conditions! It's not like they can make their own private island while the rest of us live in caves. Oh, wait, there's Hollywood. Never mind.
Good point.
Why? I like it on top of your mother.
Your idea that the government has superior firepower is so mentally defective that you deserve neither liberty nor security.
Re-thing your own inferiority, scumbag.
Wow, I have to admit that you're my intellectual superior.
I think anyone reading these comments would be forced to agree.
I'm not worthy…
Do these "greenies" realize that they are CARBON LIFE FORMs? If they really wanted to "save the planet" wouldn't they take a rope out back to the highest tree and hang themselves?
Actually, because they'd be in charge (all animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others) they'd justify that they need more (see: AlGore) because they're more important than the rest of us little people and have to do so many important things. Hollywood is an ant colony of its own – those self-important and inflated egos attached to bodies would also need more because they have to keep us little people in line with their propaganda and mind-numbing movies, which I'm sure we'll all be forced to watch – it's for our own good!
Beavan is a butthead. Kochar's experience is the reality to Beavan's fantasy. Being homeless is carbon neutral, but you have to beg, borrow and steal other people's resources to support yourself. Same with No Impact Man — without the multitude of technology and resources that surround him in Manhattan, he's a dead man. Try living carbon neutral in, say, central Alaska. In the winter. Then call me.
"I wish many more citizens of former Soviet Satellites and republics would speak up as Yervand has and knock some sense into at least 51% of our cosseted"
Seems like a good idea. But the problem with that is the decades of programming or deprogramming.
These Jokers of Team Soros forgot who they are fighting. They thought America turned soft and it did. But not all of her. "We The People" Americans are unique and whether that is enough to bitch-slap the soft side of America back into the right path for her remains to be seen.
WE HAVE TO DO IT.
Scientists Say "Warm and Fuzzy" Feelings Generated by Environmental Initiatives Increase Global Warming http://optoons.blogspot.com/2009/06/scientists-sa...
Beavan is a butthead. Kochar's experience is the reality to Beavan's fantasy. To start with, every living, breathing life form has an impact. The only No Impact Man is a dead man. Try living carbon neutral in, say, central Alaska. In the winter. Then call me.
Thank you for sharing your story. The envirofanatic idealists are so far removed from the reality of what there're trying to force onto the world. Beavan things he's so cutting edge, but his little experiment is just pathetic. I hope your story can make a difference. The western do gooders are following the pied piper of green socialism to our destruction. It is through stories like yours from people who have actually lived it that can hopefully show them the foolishness of what their doing.
Grab the first radical progressive elitist reporter, commentator, editor (you no, the ones not reporting on Climategate) and bring them to the airport. I'll have a plane waiting to drop to drop them at Big Al's house so that they can see how enviro friendly he really is.
Beautiful Story!
I also find it ridiculous that someone is going to eliminate his impact on the environment. Do you eat, do you breath, do you, err, dispose of waste? If you do, you are dumping loads of waste into your environment. Speaking of Flatulence destroying the Ozone layer or whatever, the worst things Humans do is not SUV's or Industrial plants, its Cow farts. Thats right, Agriculture produces many times more Co2.
Now, Honestly I could care less about Co2 but Modern agriculture actually does have huge affects. Salinization and Desertification of soil. Makes the land infertile and unusable, to both man and nature. That's why China is losing the equivalent of Rhode Island every year to desertification. This is also happening on a lesser scale in California *Gasp!*
If Liberals want a real Environmental problem they should look into that,because that's a problem with can kill millions of people through starvation.
Thank you for great piece. The "eco-socialists" are offering the "people" two choices – submit or die from rampant ecological disaster (like in all the disaster movies) their new problem is that the facade is falling off the fraud that is "climate change" and the other "tall tales" that are used to sell eco-socialism.
Wow, they blew up his delusion, huh? How come Mr. Average Citizen has seen this "climate change" stuff to be a ~snow job~ and celebs EAT this stuff up?
Ya, he's in a little Prius driving around Bev Hills, and they're still in their Benz's and Bentley's!
Truly, the only reason individuals like Beavan can do these little "experiments" is because nobody else, for the most part, engages in them. Personally, I don't worship technology, nor do I believe technology makes us "free" or "strong," but certainly can make us proud. And that's not a good thing.
However, the *use* of technology doesn't make us greedy, environment killing monsters, either. The simple existence of, or lack of, technology has nothing to do with the moral state of the individuals within a society, or that society's moral state as a whole. Simply put, it is possible to live a healthy and responsible lifestyle without worshipping the earth or engaging in such nonsense as this "no-impact" joke. Greed is a personal choice that individuals exercise – not a state of being for having a car or using light-bulbs.
Still, I would argue that we need to be careful in talking about technology. It is nothing more than a tool. It is not a cure for moral sickness, nor will it cure crime or hatred or any other ill of moral origin. "Science" is not a cure to any societal problem, and the Western tendency to so see "science" is why so many people are, shockingly, disillusioned over Climaquiddick. In fact, it is the reason that we even have this climate "scandal" in the first place.
the sinner,
Patrick
I don't place airs on being intellectually superior to others, as you do, anus gerbil.
But I will damn sure deal you a ration of insults, since that's the game you like to play. If you aren't man enough to tote up an A game when you go to insult people, don't play the fudge-packer defense. You're the little chocolate-covered a$$ bomb that likes to insult Christians for their beliefs.
Human person Jr. – yeah, as in "Man Lite" or "Little Boy Blew"
I couldn't give a rat's @SS less what others would agree. All they have to do is see the unprovoked insults that you make against others for believing in God.
You have about as much to do with conservatism as Hillary. And about as much sense.
"Government has superior firepower"….you are the epitome of chicken$h!t. Bet you're the first one to fold up and give away your freedoms. It's ok for someone else to put it on the line, but not you.
You are right, you are a Junior Human. I question whether you are worth the protections that my Navy and cohorts in the other armed forces afford you.
Well, y'see, if I had God on my side, my firearms probably COULD overcome grenade launchers, fully automatic weapons, etc. Or, at least, if the government did prevail, somehow (luckily, I'm sure) against God and me, I could go be with the 72 virgins when I die, right? Oh wait, that's another bullshit religion. Sorry, I got 'em mixed up for a minute.
So, for now, just for today, I think I'll work toward electing a different government, instead of challenging this particular government to a firefight.
I know it's cowardly. What can I say… If I had God on my side, maybe I'd be a bit more brave, or stupid, or something.
A brilliant essay, and I seldom use that over-used adjective! As America becomes a relatively poorer country, perhaps common sense will make a comeback.
Maybe the young eco-warrior will have second thoughts when he finds that after four years of brainwashing in college, he can't find a job. How will he buy all those modern goods produced by the evil corporations? What if he can't fly here, there, and everywhere on a whim? What if he can't afford a smart phone, an HDTV, a car? Or internet porn, lattes, laptops, condoms, antibiotics? Or food? Or heat?
We never had it so good. It won't be this good for long.
I am sitting here dumbstruck from your incredible story….thank you for writing and posting this chronicle of real life. Al Gore uses 20 times the carbon footprint of any of the "everyday" citizens of our country, yet makes millions of $$$ telling everyone else to live without, do without, and live like paupers. Honestly this plan of "green" insanity is from the UN Agenda 21 papers…..look that up and you will see why "Smart Growth" is leading to the "Smart Grid" to ration energy. Truly there is a population reduction plan going on here. I am so thankful this weekend for the Russian "hackers" or whoever revealed the CRU emails exposing the fraud of Global Warming/Climate Change. The fraud is now exposed. Shout it from the rooftops….if we can get the deaf, dumb and blind, Kool-ade drunk, idiots to get it through their heads…..I'll keep praying for that.
I think so. I also think that were are going to see a lot more AGW/libs getting angry as more information, is revealed about this Global Warming/Climate Change hoax.
And there are plenty in this country who would love to see this scenario in America all in the name of the environment and civil control.
Too true! It's always nice to have the capability, even if I never use it. I would only use it if I were forced to due to unavailability of regular fuel. Let's hope that never comes to pass.
The funny thing about ethanol is it is more polluting than gas because you get way worse mileage. It takes more ethanol to power an engine for longer because of the inefficent combustion, so pick a gas station close to your house or work, because you will be filling up alot more if you use it.
You must be logged in to post a comment.