
Kyle Smith Wonders if ’J. Edgar’ Is the Disappointment of the Year
Kyle and I may share a similar political philosophy but we rarely agree on films. I sense we might agree on this one:
…but as “J.Edgar” sits at an astonishing 39 percent it would be disingenuous not to notice that this film is getting hammered by critics. Despite its Oscar-winning director, writer (Dustin Lance Black) and Oscar-nominated star Leo DiCaprio, it is at the same approval level as “Immortals.” This is a disaster for a serious, highbrow, historical drama. The thought of critical reception didn’t occur to anyone on the set of “Immortals” but “J.Edgar” was made to win critical hosannas and Oscars.
[…]
Oh, and “J.Edgar” is terrible and I predict pitiful box office and zero Oscar nominations.
Ouch.
Kyle’s a superb writer. His blog is here.
Blu-rays for Under $10
My policy regarding Blu-ray purchases has shifted… again.
It started with “No freakin’ way am I replacing DVDs with Blu-rays.” to “Well, if they’re cheap enough I can always sell the old DVDs on Ebay.” But after they wouldn’t sell on Ebay I went back to, “No freakin’ way.”
What I’m discovering now, however, is that not all DVDs are alike. The ones I purchased when the format was first released 15 or so years ago look like crap, not much better than VHS. A perfect example was Kubrick’s “The Shining,” which looked so awful I had to shut it off after 15 minutes. The picture was blurry and not even in widescreen. So picking up the Blu-ray for $8.00 made sense.
Thankfully, most of my DVDs look perfectly fine. This includes copies nearly a decade old. Even the hundreds of black and white films I recorded on DVD off of TCM (before TCM installed the blocking device) look good. Any new films I purchase will obviously be in the Blu-ray format but only from the five-for-$20 previously-viewed bin at Blockbuste — not that there’s much to choose from these days even at that low price.
(more…)