I just saw the new Matt Damon flick, The Adjustment Bureau, and wanted to like it. I really wanted to like it. But I didn’t.
Like many films, The Bureau is based on a fantastic ruse: Somewhere out there a group of men dressed in stylish black overcoats and fedoras called The Adjustment Bureau have a plan for how all of us humans will live our lives. Not ‘should’, mind you, but ‘will’. And they’re not talking about whether you drink Coke or Pepsi – they leave the small stuff to individuals so we have the perception of Free Will. The big stuff, though, the real significant choices – career, spouse, political affiliation (mostly Democratic, from what I could tell), is up to them. Every now and then they make an adjustment to our Plan to keep everything down on Planet Earth running smoothly. Unfortunately, about halfway through the film, the ruse gets in the way of the real story. And that’s too bad because the central message, the reason the director made the picture and we streetwalkers go to see it, is well worth talking about.

We may not talk about it much, but we think about it. We think about it a lot: The personal choices we make, especially the big ones, and the consequences that ensue, for better or worse. For example: Should I be a lawyer or a schoolteacher, single or married, pursue money or service, pleasure or sacrifice? And these are only a few, as anyone will tell you. These things matter, and in fact might even change the world. Perfect fodder for a thought- provoking movie.
George Nolfi, first time director and accomplished screenwriter and producer, no doubt wanted us to be neck deep in the “choice” dilemma and, for awhile, he almost pulled it off. We meet interesting characters that we immediately like, root for them to be together, and struggle along with them as the wise men of the Star Chamber do their best to keep them apart. We believe that Matt Damon could be a politician-on-the-rise, and Emily Blunt, especially Emily Blunt, could be a world-shaking modern dancer. Until the middle of Act II there is just the right mix of all these elements to make us “check our minds at the door” and follow them on their rough and tumble journey that finally ends with wedding vows. But Nolfi, faced with his own artistic dilemma, fouls it back to the screen. He includes so many scenes about The Ruse that it crowds out the message that the plot normally conveys.
(more…)