‘Never Let Me Go’ Review: Victims in Dystopia
by John Nolte“Never Let Me Go” is most certainly on the moral side of presenting human life and more importantly, the individual, as uniquely precious, and this British import based on the novel by Kazuo Ishiguro deserves credit for that. Where it fails, however, and does so miserably, is in its presentation of the human spirit. About a half-hour in the central premise of the story is finally revealed and fully explained. Not to give too much away, but essentially we discover that our three main characters have been born into and chosen for a horrific future. As tragic and sad as this is, there’s just no way to get around the fact that watching our protagonists quietly and passively accept this fate like dumb stockyard cattle does not make for compelling storytelling.
—–
Set in a dreary alternate past where everything’s familiar except for the central circumstance, the year is 1978 and Kathy, Tommy, and Ruth are growing up and benefitting from a prim and proper British education in what at first appears to be a storybook English boarding school. Something’s amiss, though. The young students don’t seem to have last names and normalcy is regularly broken up by the inexplicable. In-between standard academic courses, games, and meals, the children have been conditioned to never leave the school grounds and whenever they exit the building there’s an electronic device in their wrist that appears to do some kind of electronic roll call and/or head count.
By 1985, Kathy has grown into Carey Mulligan; Tommy, Andrew Garfield; and Ruth, Keira Knightley. Having graduated, they’re shipped off to the countryside to await their fate and work though a brittle friendship damaged by a years-long love triangle. You see, Kathy loves Tommy but Tommy loves Ruth and Ruth loves that she stole Tommy from Kathy. The motives behind the romantic machinations are eventually revealed as something deeper and more complicated than expected, but even in affairs of the heart this is a passive bunch and frustration at their inaction overwhelms any sympathy one might otherwise have for them. (more…)







Subscribe via RSS
Got a Tip?