If you’re hip to the movie news, by now you know that British actor Henry Cavil has been cast as Superman in Zach Snyder’s upcoming reboot. That’s right, a man born and raised in the British Isles will be portraying an American icon. When it was announced, many in the blogosphere assumed that we “wingnut fascists” would be outraged at the thought of an non-American playing the Man of Steel. They assumed that our narrow-minded jingoism would prevent us from endorsing a solid actor nabbing the lead role in a highly anticipated film. As usual, they were wrong. We true film buffs could care less where the actor hails from, we just want a movie that is true to the character and kicks some ass. Bryan Singer’s “Superman Returns” had an American Superman, but failed miserably in the aspects that mattered most. It wasn’t true to the character and didn’t really kick any ass.

But the casting does reveal a couple of interesting things.
Contrary to the propaganda coming from the Hate-America crowd, we are far more open to such things than other cultures, especially the British. There was a lot of snark when Gwyneth Paltrow and Renee Zellweger applied their best British accents to their portrayals of Emma and Bridget Jones. Plus, I doubt that the producers ever entertained the idea of casting an American Harry Potter or a Dr. Who born in Iowa. What about James Bond? Not only have they never considered Americans for the lead role, but they’ve turned down both Steven Spielberg and Quentin Tarantino as directors. Every Bond director has hailed from a Commonwealth nation. Apparently, it’s okay for other countries to maintain “national treasures” and “cultural icons,” but for Americans to suggest doing the same means we’re racist, nativist, and generally close minded. You see, to the rest of the world, we don’t actually have a culture. How can we? We are a nation made of other nations, a population of hyphenates who lack a common identity.
Well, this Prussian-American filmmaker calls foul.
Not only is Superman a Brit, but as NBC points out, so are Batman, and Spiderman. NBC mistakenly lumps Wolverine into the group, but any geek worth their salt knows that Wolverine a.k.a. Logan is Canadian. And Hugh Jackman who plays Wolverine is Australian, not British. Oh, well, more quality fact-checking from NBC. We should be used to this by now. (more…)