HomeVideodrome: Brian De Palma ‘Scarface’ Edition
by Hunter DuesingWhen I first saw Brian De Palma’s Scarface, a decidedly eighties remake of the classic Howard Hawks gangster movie, I loved it. I was a teenager, the perfect age to see Tony Montana’s dizzying rise in the Miami underworld, followed by his violent, cocaine-fueled fall.
Now I kind of hate it.
My dislike of Scarface mainly stems from the movie’s obnoxious fan base. There are many movies and bands I enjoy that are cursed with followers that are beyond irritating, yet I refuse to let them poison the enjoyment I get out of whatever it is they love for erroneous reasons. Scarface is different in that the film’s fans are indicative of the movie’s failings as a story and a as a piece of art. It’s a classic case of rabid fans “not getting it.”
The point of Scarface was to present the dark side of the American dream, giving us the story of an immigrant who gets to the top of the food chain in the most brutal, horrible manner possible, only to lose it all in an explosion of violence. The problem is that the film’s violent climax, while iconic, is also intoxicating in how it glorifies Montana’s death. They way Montana goes out after getting all the lead the drug cartels have to muster pumped into him is even more exhilarating than the process in which he builds his massive criminal empire, the way he goes out killing his enemies and screaming like maniac seems like the best way to go when watching this movie.
This gangster yarn seems to be something people are more keen on worshiping and emulating for the wrong reasons, in that Tony Montana is not a role model, yet he is treated as such by the movie’s fan base. I would argue that for this very reason, the movie is a failure when it comes to presenting its themes. The film sets out to present the so-called American dream gone bad, yet it presents it in the sexiest, most desirable manner possible. It’s the cinematic embodiment of the “get rich or die tryin’” mentality that I’m not so sure the filmmakers intended.







Subscribe via RSS
Got a Tip?