I was never a big fan of the Beatles. For starters, I can’t spin that fast, and for all their musical innovation, I often can’t get past the whole nursery-rhyme vibe of it all. But Jeff Lynne idolizes them, and ELO is the greatest band ever, so I’ll defer to his judgment. And if you’ve heard the new album Watercolor Day, you already know that veteran singer/songwriter Seth Swirsky agrees.
Watercolor Day is only Swirsky’s second solo album, but his decades of experience are more than readily apparent. And for being, essentially, a rehash of ’60s and ’70s Britpop, the album sounds fresher than much of the flamboyant dance-floor fodder bleeding out the kiddies’ headphones these days. Is it shocking to anyone else that to go against the grain in the music world, you have be to modest and subtle? Not “look how profound and nuanced I am cuz I made this understated” subtle, but, you know… actually subtle? For Swirsky, who’s had nearly a decade to explain to his leftists colleagues how they’re absolutely wrong without burning bridges, you get the impression that subtlety comes second nature to him.

The album’s received plenty of praise and lots of adjectives like “shimmer,” “shine,” sweetness,” “bounce,” and the like, but to peg Watercolor Day as a happy record is leaving out the true meat of it. The best pop is music is sad pop music, and Swirsky’s got boatloads of melancholy oozing through his sweet, shimmery bouncing. Single “(Never Knew You) Harry” may sound like a goofy tribute to Harry Nilsson, but you get the sense that he’s not just saying, “Hey, you were a great songwriter,” but he’s lamenting the boundaries that time can place between people. If only he hadn’t been born so late, he could have been in the business when he first heard “Everybody’s Talkin’;” He could’ve been one of Harry’s contemporaries.
And this feeling of displacement hangs over the whole album– a yearning for some other time or place, even though this one is already so beautiful. It almost veers into breakup concept album territory. The narrator comes across as an introvert recounting his thoughts through a single day. He’s nerdy, full of romantic fantasy but held back by his timidity. We catch his mind admiring nature, longing for women past and present, and cursing himself for lost opportunities. “Distracted” shuffles around an insanely catchy trumpet riff as he realizes he never gets anything done because of his conflicting interests. On “Melancholy Rainbow,” the album’s longest song (at 3:25– score!), our protagonist muses about the titular omen of impending heartbreak shining through a window as he lays with his lover: “I don’t wanna let go,” he sighs. This theme of lost love continues through “Matchbook Cover,” “Living Room,” “Big Mistake,” “Stay,” and “She’s Doing Fine,” whose ambiguity suggest that Swirsky imagines this is woman still with him after she’s left. (more…)