One Iraq War Vet Declares War On Hollywood
by Sgt. WelshPlease go to this link first – click here – to understand what I’m about to rant about and why I’m so pissed.
Almost 90% of Americans believe the war in Iraq is and was a waste. The Hollywood media feeds the public wasteful, depressing, and horribly fabricated stories. When did the U.S. military become the bad-guys? We are stereotyped “Generation Kill.” I guess that is all we do. All we do is go to Iraq, hunt innocents and slaughter them. I guess that is what I did for eight months while I was there.
I guess I really didn’t save Iraqi families from being tortured by foreign jihadis. I didn’t set up the first ever Iraqi elections. Or see my brothers blown up, shot, maimed, and killed. Getting attacked from Mosques and hospitals–and you know what? We just took it, day after day we took it and we kept going. An IED blowing up underneath me each day. We couldn’t fight back; we were ordered not to. No matter how much vengeful, pent up aggression I felt, or how much I wanted to kill, I didn’t act on it. We have a code, Rules of Engagement. “RULES,” rules that are followed.
But according to then Senator and now President Obama, all I did was air-raid villages and kill innocent civilians. This is a video I will never forget:
People like Pat Dollard and Micheal Yon tell the true stories.
Please watch these clips and tell me if you buy into what is portrayed. Honestly, tell me what you believe.
HBO’s rendition–was this the way it went down according to Evan Wright’s book? Or is it HBO fantasy?
Or how about this from “In the Valley of Elah.” In the start of the movie, he fixes the flag.
<!–[if gte mso 9]> Normal 0 false false false EN-US X-NONE X-NONE MicrosoftInternetExplorer4 <![endif]–><!–[if gte mso 9]> <![endif]–> At the end of the movie, it portrays the soldiers doing horrible things (nothing good in Iraq–the entire film), it gives Tommy Lee Jones’ character the right to flip the flag at the end (the so called “international distress signal…come save our ass”). Theme of movie—Iraq is unpatriotic and helpless. To me it means what we did over there is… unpatriotic.
And last my personal favorite, Brain De Palma’s rendition “Redacted.” THIS SHIT WOULD NEVER HAPPEN OVER THERE. IT IS COMPLETE fabricated bullshit. A bunch of soldiers standing around with no security. Nothing in this clip would ever happen. A wannabe gangster Sergeant talking about his three tours…? Yea right. And a PVT allowed to act that dumb? Ridiculous.
Thank you so much American media, special thanks to Hollywood. Our entire sacrifice was a complete waste. My friends died for nothing. We are exploited and lies are told. The truth is never reported. The good outweighs the bad. But you will never see it.
Yours truly,
I guess this is just a bunch of lies too:





Subscribe via RSS
160 Comments
CCFK
You seem like the type of person who would attack a Vietnam veteran, and then 20 years later you will be horrified that they have psychological issues from the way they were treated at home.
“I would rate your outrage as a fail”.
I would rate you as a disgrace.
Sgt. Welsh: Believe me, there are a lot of us out here in flyover country who do appreciate your sacrifice and the difficulty of your mission. Don’t ever believe otherwise. Thank you from the bottom of my heart.
CCFK, obviously you are misinformed. Obama DID say that about Iraq…. it was a pretty big deal during the campaign. Why don’t you ask your congressman if you can take a trip over there? You know, to see first hand how it is. Or, are you one of those freaks who idolize Hollywood and collect autographs? Is that why you voted for Obama… because he’s a celebrity?
I am steeling myself for the upcoming Magical Mystery Tour of Obama apologizing to the Muslim world for everything the US has ever done. I fully expect them to laugh at him and reciprocate with more terror. He telegraphs his weakness just like Jimmah Carter. They are going to roll him too. Lord help us and all of our military.
CCfk, who the hell are you, to make comment’s about a subject you would never have the balls to experience yourself. Were you next to Michael Yon or Sgt Welsh. If Not STFU and Thank the people that actually protect you, instead of drooling over the people that want to kill you
I have worked with many soldiers who were in Iraq and Afghanistan so I know what the true stories are. I also hear the stories from their wives and families. What Hollywood puts out about this war is drivel and I am happy to note that the majority of these movies fail at the box office.
Thank you for your service. Know that many, many Americans value you.
Sir, please, please believe there are millions of us who are grateful for the sacrifices you and the others in the military have nade and for the good you have done. Please ignore CCFK’s asinine comments as the utterings of an ill-informed, leftist, moronic dolt. I do understand how you feel, though. The other day I thought to myself that I’d bet Saddam is probably somewhere in hell, laughing at the way President Bush was treated by people cut from the same cloth as CCFK. Again, thank you for continuing to serve our country and to protect us, even with America’s first Affirmative Action president at the helm. God bless you, and try to remember some of us appreciate that you have done more for us than we’ll probably ever know.
Sgt. Welsh, thank you for your service and like some of the other commenters have said, please know that even though Hollywood doesn’t tell you about those of us who are grateful, it doesn’t mean we don’t exist. Your bravery and perserverance are visible and your outrage is justified, but know that you are loved, admired and prayed for by many who don’t have Hollywood’s far reaching voice.
In truth, I didn’t watch your Valley of Elah, Rendition, or HBO clips because I’ve already refused to give them my time or money for denigrating our troops. I did watch your video at the end, though, and I appreciate the wake up call. It’s easy to sit back and get complacent because you and others have done such an amazing job protecting us. I’m sorry that we haven’t been protesting the negative portrayals loudly enough for you to realize that you are greatly appreciated. You deserve that and so much more.
So, God bless you and thank you so much.
Brother
I feel your pain. I have pulled three trips to Iraq and I’m 5 months into my first to Afghanistan. At my shop in CA we have a wall with 24 photos on it. Photos of our fallen brothers, friends that have worked and served with me. One of those photos is Criss, he was in my wedding. Another is Mikey, I was his team leader. He died right in front of me. I’ve been in the Corps for 13 years, 7 of those as EOD. I love my job, and I know what you feel. Each time I would see a brother die I would feel that rage burn in to me. Yet not once did any of us ever allow that rage to take over. We never went went on a killing spree of locals just to satisfy that rage. We did our jobs and our duty. We are the lost, the broken, the useless. We are too ugly, to mean, to violent for Hollywood. The truth is, we are too real for Hollywood. You, me, and all the others like us, we are the real, the true heros. I’ll bet a paycheck Bian De Palma thinks he is so brave for making that crap movie. Hey Brian, if your so brave, come hang out in the Afghan mountains with me and my team for a week. Come walk the villages we walk, come drive the trails we drive. Then we will talk brave. Sgt Welsh, you, and all of us, we are above them. We are above those that taunt, and jeer. We are “doers” not talkers. We are warriors brother. We are the man in the arena, and we do what we do for us, for our reasons. And our reasons are above all others. We have duty and honor. The sad thing is, they have the paycheck, that’s how America see’s success, the rich are the good and the true. Our new president said some pretty crappy things about the warriors, we are above that, we have honor and duty. Those that criticize are petty, shallow and arogant. Remember who you are and what you did, what you have accomplished is above what they talk about and they can never take that away. Let them make there movies, let them talk their talk, let them hate and forget. Be proud Sgt, keep the honor. Semper Fi.
CCFK – you clearly ascribe to Falsifyability – there is no conceivable set of circumstances that could ever prove you wrong. In this case it’s your abject and baseless hate of our military and your utter adoration of Obambi.
Sgt. Welsh – my husband will be doing his second tour in Iraq. The thought of him being there under a President who is devoid of knowledge, courage, or honor is terrifying. You made me feel a hell of a lot better – even if leadership fails, men and women like you will continue to go above and beyond. Thank you.
I can certainly understand your frustration – but the blame needs to be placed on the traitors that wasted American resources on a useless war – not the messengers that stood up and said what our country was doing is wrong. How much more useless sacrifice would have happened if everyone marched in lockstep? Blame the cabal of Zionists who controlled our foreign policy – those with loyalties to Israel, not the US. The ones who say you as disposable goy like they are taught from the Talmud. Look at people like Wolfowitz.
Oh, and I see that Netanyahu is saying their perception of Iran being a threat is more important than the GLOBAL economic crisis. Just a glimpse into how these parasites think. Everything is about them.
Wake up.
[...] Iraq vet takes on Hollywood, singles out Brian de Palma’s “Prefabricated.” Related. Posted by Dan Collins @ 7:56 am | Trackback SHARETHIS.addEntry({ title: “Emancipation Defalcation [Dan Collins]“, url: “http://proteinwisdom.com/?p=14207″ }); [...]
During most of the Iraq War, it appeared to me that the vast majority of media reporting was negative, and many liberals in Hollywood and elsewhere were swept up by this incessant negative drum beat. Critics of Bush, “neocons,” or Republicans in general, heard exactly what they wanted to hear and reacted to every death, every IED, every car bomb, every incident of rogue soldiering, and every incident of “friendly fire” with what can only be descibed as a morbid kind of glee.
But in all honesty, anyone with even a modicum of knowledge of U.S. military history knows that this war was probably one of the cleanest, least destructive wars in our history. Fatalities were low for both civilians and combatants for such a conflict, and the survival rate for those wounded unprecedented. Even the magnitude of stupid mistakes on our part during this war pales in comparison to stupid mistakes made during Vietnam, Korea, or even the “Good War” — World War II.
So why all the negativity in the press?
Simple. Modern-era Journalism 101.
As a former practicing military journalist, I realize that according the fundamental rules of modern-era journalism, in news reporting, death always leads, followed by serious injury, and then significant destruction and high-visibility/high-dollar property damage.
But it’s also clear to me that al Qaeda, Iraqi insurgents, and others who would do the civilized world harm are also well aware of these rules, and thus make regular car-bombings or other mass mayhem a key part of their strategy to keep any positive news off of the front page or TV news, or unreported entirely.
In short, because of its current rules of journalism, the Fourth Estate has, in effect, become a catalyst for terror, leading to far more death and destruction of innocent people in Iraq, and elsewhere, than any amount of errant coalition bombs ever could.
I often wonder if the folks in the media realize how skillfully they are being played by the bad guys, and if they plan to make changes to their modern-day journalism rules to temper such murderous media manipulation in future conflicts.
And those in Hollywood who are quick to jump on the “America is evil” or “U.S. troops are monsters” bandwagon based on what is reported by the media may also want to reassess their complicity in aiding and abetting those in this world who are truly evil.
Sgt. Welsh, the media and amoral clowns running the country now don’t care about your opinions or the state of the military other than to neuter it. May they be cursed.
Mama Mitzvah – January 29th, 2009 at 6:39 am
“I guess I am one of them there zionists, what with me being a Jew and all. I even have duel citizenship, TERRY. So Sgt Welsh, I hope you will accept from a “parasite” such as my family and me, a huge G-d Bless you and thank you for bringing to light the lies of Hollywood and the MSM. The people who serve the Army, Navy Marines etc deserve the gratitude of all Americans and the world.”
Only country that has benefitted is Israel. Same ones who wanted us to fight Israel’s war in Iraq want us to attack Iran for them next.
We were far better off with Saddam in charge of things over there and with a few trillion less in debt. Wasn’t worth one American life, much less thousands. But the goy are dispensible to attain Israel’s goals according to Zionists.
Sgt Welch,
Thank you for your service! I don’t have any regard for liberal Hollywood. They spout all of their BS expecting us to believe their opinion is greater and more accurate than ours just because they are in front of the camera? They are self-absorbed gluttons. These elite wealthy liberals try to tell us what you and we should do and then they get in their $100,000 plus cars and go to the club. They tell us that Republicans and Conservatives are rich selfish people as they walk in their multi-million dollar homes staffed by maids, cooks, and personal assistants? Give me a BREAK! It’s the other way around most of the time.
Hollywood libs should be taken to Iraq for 6 months. I bet they would sing a different tune. You are the hero, sir. They are activist mob cowards who shove their opinion down our throats. I for one am not listening to them and I stopped watching and buying tickets to their movies. I’ll do my best to support Conservative Hollywood but that’s it. Breitbart and others like him- thank you! If you make it, I’ll buy it. The other liberal tyrants can all take a long walk on a short pier. Again, thank you again Sgt Welsh. It’s nice to know we have a few good REAL MEN left in this nation. Don’t go to Hollywood and LA to find them; they are few and far between.
Keep it up, Sarge. We have family serving over there, for the last few years, and we KNOW first-hand just how much GOOD is being done since we hear it straight from the Army engineers who are rebuilding and liberating.
BTW, to say that Iraqis don’t want democracy and could never understand or appreciate is RACIST. Just because they have not had it (thanks, Saddam) doesn’t mean they can’t learn it and appreciate it.
I can’t understand the shrill voices on the left who clamor for unlimited free (read: HATE) speech here in the USA (witness the vile SNL treatment of the Palin family, for example) yet these same pundits say that the kind of freedom THEY insist upon here in America would not be appreciated by Iraqis? Not ever?
Right…let’s keep all these other folks in their natural “habitat” so we can visit them on occasion as if they were in some kind of zoo.
I totally stand with Sgt Welsh. As a former Marine and mil blogger, who spent three combat tours in Iraq, I feel his frustration. I’ve had enough of our bias media. As the violence subsides in Iraq, the slim ball mainstream media slowly leave the country. If they can’t report negative stuff on Iraq, they won’t report at all.
I appreciate your service you are doing, and have done, for the country. Forget CCFK. Especially when he/she (we’ll call it and “it”), It does it’s Hmmmmm crap. I work in the biz and it is very true that all these filmmakers have a side and love to sing and dance their message till everyone tastes the kool-aid.
Sgt Welsh –
If it is any consolation all these Iraq movies were bombs at the box office – Millions of us know the spin the MSM gives to our military – a funny internet post was how they would have treated the D-Day invasion today – “Thousands of French civilians killed” instead of “Nazis beaten” – their main sin IMO is moral relativism – look at how they treat the Israelis after having 7,000 rockets thrown at them over the last couple of years
Just look at how they treat Vietnam Vets – according to them they are all psychos
The good news is that millions of us “get it” and have looked towards alternative news – ie, new media – it is a shame that you have to go to web sites to get a truer picture but also the newspapers are dying – wonder why
Somebody was snidely questioning Michael Yon’s credentials – he is an ex Special Forces who has the respect of most men in the field – I truest his objectivity a lot more than the NYT
I think you guys are the best generation we’ve had since WW2 – thank you for your service
What’s genuinely interesting is that the Hollywood crowd are clearly liars, just on the face of it.
If they genuinely believed that American soldiers were simple killers, they would also be terrified that when the guys come home they’d go looking for their enemies and detractors. Penn, et al., are just as convinced as anyone that American troops are decent people. That enables them to be as insulting and denigrating as they like.
Regards,
Ric
Thank you for writing this. It can’t be reiterated enough. As we all know too well, on the TV networks good news is no news when it comes to our own – quite humane – military. For those of us not living in a fantasy world, thanks.
CCFK – “But according to then Senator and now President Obama, all I did was air-raid villages and kill innocent civilians. This is a video I will never forget:”
“Hmmm…we don’t hear the question, we don’t know the date, we don’t even know that that Obama is talking about Iraq.”
If you were not aware of the video before now means that you have bought into this bs liberal crap without knowing the facts. Do your how work, boy, and quite showing your ingnorance.
Sgt. Welsh – Thank you. I am just one of millions that really do support our military. The media has highjacked the message, but we do support you. My daughter is in the delayed entry program with the Marines and will be going to boot in September. She is my baby, but I know her brother and sister Marines will have her back.
Yeah. Kind of hard to watch. I was there in ‘03 with the NSW Task Group and then in ‘04 as chaplain to 2nd BN, 2nd MAR. Too many memories on the one hand and wish to God I could be back there. One has to make choices, though, and mine took me away from the fight.
Take heart, though, Sgt. What we have done and are doing is right, and true, and honorable. I am fully prepared to stand before God for my part in helping to identify, isolate and kill evil men in this war. I’d do it again.
God keep you, brother. Keep the faith.
Sgt Welsh, thanks for your service. I don’t think going to Iraq was a waste, but, I do think we should’ve gone in with overwhelming force, not just the 100,000 or so soldiers who were sent. That wasn’t your or your fellow soldiers’ fault that was Rumsfelds’ fault for being an idiot. I wish I could’ve gone in the military, but I had asthma and they wouldn’t let me, because my family has served in every conflict since the French & Indian War, and I wanted to do my patriotic duty. So, instead, I make sure service members know I support them.
So, my questions is… why does the military put up with people in power like Pelosi or Obama, who are a bunch of appeasers?
Cliff – January 29th, 2009 at 8:24 am
“Sgt Welsh, thanks for your service. I don’t think going to Iraq was a waste”
To answer that intelligently, you have to answer “what was the cost.” Can you tell us what the cost of this war was in total? What was gained for Americans?
Posting this primarily to cast one more ‘vote’ in favor of our troops AND their efforts and sacrifices. My impression of them, after seeking out the news that MM largely ignores, is that they are the cream of the crop, period.
PopMedia couldn’t be bothered to inform us of the day to day work done by our own citizen-soldiers, preferring to focus on the politics {being in the pocket of the ‘rightful heirs’ to power- the Democratics}. The droning from the Left has them claiming they ’support the troops’, just not anything they actually accomplish. In this they reveal that they learned a lesson from the “baby-killer” days of Vietnam. Or did they? What they lurned were new ways of being disingenuous.
Thank you, Sgt. Welsh for all your efforts. That the major media oppose them is more evidence that you are doing the right thing, and doing it well. You deserve better, it’s true. But take some comfort in knowing that a huge percentage of the American public still regard your profession and our shared cause to defeat the jihadists as noble.
Respectfully,
Jeff Perren
Sgt. Welsh thank you from the bottom of my heart for your service and the videos. Our son was a Marine until health issues forced him out. He misses it every single day! People like CCFK and those ignorant libs in Hollywood have their heads in the sand, hate our country, our military, and defend those who would cut thier heads off, were they given the chance. I agree with other posts…CCFK I would pay for your plane ticket to Iraq if you really think this is all a bunch of BS. Sad thing is, our new president probably thinks the same way you do and that’s why he is truly an Obamanation!!! Sgt. Welsh there are millions upon millions who consider you and all others serving in the military heroes. I salute you and continue to pray for all who put their lives on the line for us every single day. SEMPER FI
Thank you for your service, Sgt Welsh.
Sgt. Welch,
Your heroics have not gone un-noticed, but we have been far too silent.
Although I have always had questions about the war, lets not forget that the Gore, Clinton, and a host of others stood before Congress and told them that “Saddam must be stopped” because they believed that he was attempting to gain nuclear weapons. AND THIS WAS BEFORE GEORGE W. WAS IN OFFICE.
Lets not forget about the yellow cake that even MSN reported many layers down on their website.
Lets not forget that even Hillary came back from her Iraq Vay-Cay and stated that things weren’t as bad as she thought.
Everyone talks about the despicable treatment of our Prisoners, but seem to forget the beheadings of our soldiers, reporters, etc. Oh and BTW those beheadings were done with a knife like cutting off a turkey wing, NOT a nice clean single blow. You can find the video’s on line. And I am sorry, but I have little sympathy for a few men who were forced to stand around naked. Really! I have been to Frat parties that were worse. Waterboarding you say? Lets do a “torture” to torture comparison first! I guess we are supposed to have them sit down with Aunt Bee with some milk and cookies.
Sgt. I support you and everything you stand for, as does everyone I know. We owe you a debt of gratitude, and you should know that there are a lot people here at home who have your back. We just need to speak up more.
Terry the troll,
What did you EVER do for your country. Do you think America is so dead that people like you will actually run it for any length of time. People wise up to stupid things…. You are that thing.
Sgt. Thanks to you and all before you for service to our country. I served, and will never forget! God Bless the USA!
-JCR
John –
When the military no longer serves the interests of this country (and they don’t) then they are at best a drain on this country and at worst a threat to it (witness them confiscating guns in New Orleans).
I don’t see how joining the military serves this country one bit. Serves the GOVERENMENT, sure! Are you guys supposed to be wary of the government as conservatives? The Founding Fathers were and they opposed standing armies. It serves the individuals who join who are increasingly amoral and uneducatated adrenaline-junkie lowlifes. These people are being primed to be set against the American people (again, witness New Orleans). This is a threat to this country, not a service.
thank you for your service SGT. Welsh.
” It serves the individuals who join who are increasingly amoral and uneducatated adrenaline-junkie lowlifes. These people are being primed to be set against the American people (again, witness New Orleans). This is a threat to this country, not a service.”
Terry, you almost got a response until you printed this lovely statement. There are smart and dumb people in all parts of life. The statement above removes any doubt of your objectivity, or clear thought.
PS. I asked what you ever did for the country… Not are you a vet!
John.
Christopher – January 29th, 2009 at 8:59 am
“Your heroics have not gone un-noticed, but we have been far too silent.”
What a sick concept of “hero” you have. Killing people because the government says so makes all the Nazis heros, too. Better revise your definition.
“Although I have always had questions about the war, lets not forget that the Gore, Clinton, and a host of others stood before Congress and told them that “Saddam must be stopped” because they believed that he was attempting to gain nuclear weapons. AND THIS WAS BEFORE GEORGE W. WAS IN OFFICE.”
Big fans of Democrats, then, are you? Big fan of big government?
That only reveals the depths to which AIPAC writes our foreign policy. Saddam didn’t have nuclear weapons and was no where close to them (funny, Pakistan does and we aren’t invading THEM. That choice is the best advertisement of gaining nuclear weapons there is for these countries. Better start paying attention to the signals we are sending because other countries are.). And these same Zionist parasites are the ones hyping up fears about Iran and nuclear weapons! All about war for Israel’s goals and at America’s expense.
“Lets not forget about the yellow cake that even MSN reported many layers down on their website.”
Yellow layer cake? Run for the hills!
“Lets not forget that even Hillary came back from her Iraq Vay-Cay and stated that things weren’t as bad as she thought.”
Big fan of Hillary, are you?
“Everyone talks about the despicable treatment of our Prisoners, but seem to forget the beheadings of our soldiers, reporters, etc.”
You mean people defending their homeland? WE are the invaders. They are like the Wolverines in the movie Red Dawn. Never forget that.
“Oh and BTW those beheadings were done with a knife like cutting off a turkey wing, NOT a nice clean single blow.”
More respectable that some coward that shoots people off a FLIR screen. THESE PEOPLE ARE REAL MEN – that is what frightens you. You KNOW you don’t have the chops to do something like that – to truly face your enemy. Same with the VC.
“You can find the video’s on line. And I am sorry, but I have little sympathy for a few men who were forced to stand around naked.”
How about others in this pig-headed “War on Terror” like described here:
http://www.antiwar.com/reese/?articleid=12744
This is not America. It is what the Zionists wish, though. A hollow, valueless Frankenstein of a country easily manipulated by fear and catch-phrases.
thank you soldiers for all you do..and f- the haters…..just remember every thing comes full circle (2012)….i will never forget 9/11/2001 or my friends who parished that day……these people here posting these negative posts are the ones who don’t believe in Freedom…or understand the cost of it…..
Amen…
Sgt. Welsh is a liar. Here’s why.
The embedded video is about Afghanistan, NOT Iraq. Obama has made this point multiple times. That we need more troops on the ground in Afghanistan in order to better fight the terrorists there, and that lacking those troops, we’re left to fight an inefficient air war that often leads to civilian casualties. This is in no way, not even a little bit, to suggest that the men and women fighting in Iraq did nothing other than ‘air raid villages and kill innocent civilians.’
Complaining about public misconceptions about the war in Iraq is fair enuf. Lying about the context, not to mention lying about something President Obama said is not. Full stop.
Great post. As a Soldier I agree completely. I just saw “Battle for Haditha” I thought bin-Laden Productions made it. I couldn’t have been more pro-insurgent had it tried, deserves a place with “Redacted” in war propaganda.
It is so sickening my friends tell me stories of what they went through over there and even as their commanding officer I am still in awe of what they say, but Hollywood makes tripe, that loses money, and says “no one wants to see a war movie.” Please.
Thank you for saying this, my beloved Stepson has served 3 tours in Iraq and the CAP Cadet I was closest to for years and think of as my own son is there now on his second tour with the Marines and I KNOW they are, have been, will remain good, true, honest Americans who would no more do the things the pissants in Hollywood try to sell us as normal for our soldiers, they are not and never were that kind of people. (Nor was my father who served in the Marines for 20 years from Korea to Vietnam.) Have not seen, and refuse to see any more Hollywood movies about our military until they get it right,thank you for expressing what many of use feel.
Jack Bauer, I’m going to assume that’s comedy. Don’t quit your day job. My point about the Sgt.’s dishonesty stands.
The media’s involvement in the war, and ALL topics is well beyond simply reporting the facts. People in this country don’t seem to realize that the days of integrity in reporting and honorable news casters are long gone. From Katie Couric’s “got ya” journalism, to Keith Olberman’s constant blabbering of incoherant crap and calling it news…people are being brainwashed. Just beccause they wear nice suits and have white teeth does not make them news reporters.
From the bottom of my soul I thank all the soldiers in our military who protect this wonderful country. Just yesterday my 18 month old daughter and I spent the day making hand made valentines to send to Iraq.
Please don’t let the naysayers influence you. Liberals are notorious followers, and their leader is simply a “good speaker”.
Sgt. Welsh, thank you for your service. God Bless You for the sacrifices you and your fellow servicemen have made and go unrewarded and denigrated.
It pisses me off, too.
Time to make the REAL Iraq War movie. Let’s pass around the tin cup, and DO IT!
Dear Sgt. Welsh:
Thank you for your service. May God bless you and watch over you.
Dear Hollywood and the Left:
Let me see if I get this right:
1. After 9/11, it was pretty much unanimous that the Taliban and Al Queda were the #1 threat to the US.
2. After deposing the Taliban, the sights could be set on Al Queda. However, Al Queda is not a country. What to do?
3. There sits Saddam Hussein. In 1991, the US-led coalition, as a condition in ceasing the annihilation of the Iraqi army, agreed to a number of stipulations involving destroying and dismantling any WMD capabilities Iraq had or was pursuing, to be verified by UN inspectors. In the subsequent decade, he repeatedly reneged on this agreement, frustrating WMD inspectors at every turn. As a result of this and information gathered by the intelligence agencies of the US and Britan, it was widely believed, by both Republican and Democrat, the Clintons and the Bushes and our allies across the pond, that Saddam was still harboring WMD capability.
4. Based on this shared belief, President Bush is given authorization by Congress to use military force to depose Saddam. In March 2003, the US military invades Iraq.
5. Though the Iraq army is defeated quickly and Saddam goes into hiding, no WMDs are found in Iraq. While this may be considered a damning indictment of both US and British intelligence agencies (I say ‘may’ because between the time serious consideration began about whether the US would invade Iraq (summer 2002) and the invasion, Hussein had plenty of time to move any WMD to Syria), it does not point to “Bush lied”, as the belief that Iraq had WMDs was rather bi-partisan and unanimous, to the point that one big worry leading up to the invasion was whether Saddam would use chemical weapons against US troops.
6. Instead of deposing Iraq and leaving its people to the mercies of their neighbors or internal strife, the US military stayed and attempted to rebuild Iraq.
7. Almost 4 years of struggle followed, and many believe the war was mishandled. Bush could either cut his losses or find a way to win. He chose the latter. Enter one Gen. David Patreaus. Getting the additional troops he needed to employ a new strategy in Iraq, within a year Al Queda in Iraq had been almost completely annihilated, and Iraq’s govt. announces that 15 of the 18 benchmarks set for being an established constitutional democracy had been met.
Recap: Almost 6 years after invasion, a) a brutal dictator has been deposed, b) the US has rebuilt his mess of a country to the brink of it becoming an established constitutional democracy in Al Queda’s back yard ( a major PR and morale blow to Al Queda ), c) Al Queda has been severely weakened, d) not a single terrorist attack has occurred on American soil, as Al Queda was busy fighting and losing exactly the kind of war they are least equipped to fight (i.e. against trained and equipped soldiers instead of unarmed civilians), e) Osama Bin Laden is neither powerful in life or in death as a martyr, but has been marginalized to point of irrelevancy, and f) all this was accomplished with less US casualties than were suffered on D-Day or 1/10 of the casualties of Vietnam.
Whether or not you opposed the initiating this enterprise (as did I), or whether or not you thought the post-invasion pre-surge period was mismanaged (as did I), to continue to deny the accomplishments of the US military and to deny the success and goodness of the present state of Iraq for both the Iraqi people and the US, to continue to proclaim the situation in Iraq as a colossal failure is be at serious odds with the facts.
Sgt. Welch~
Thank you for your service. You are a hero to me, and I am forever grateful for the sacrifices you have made and the freedom you have fought to protect.
God Bless You!
Please allow me to interupt the senseless hero-worship to say that CCFK is correct about the snippet of video at the first of this post. It’s lack of context hurts your argument.
I also want to second the opinion of Mr. Blifil in his comment which begins, “Obama has said on numerous occasions that the service is honorable, but the mission is fatally flawed.”
I have family and friends in Irag, people with a great desire to serve their country and help their fellow man. I myself cannot go due to health concerns. (I checked with the local Air Force recruiting office.)
It angers me that our military men and women are being used to further the size of certain people’s pocketbooks rather than to further the cause of freedom. From day one of this mess, America has had more private contractors profiting from the war than U.S. military personel defending our interests.
This unsanity has to stop. But Pres. Obama seems unwilling, perhaps unable, to do anything about the real problem. The American people must demand that this exploitation of our military, our families, our friends, our society and the Iraqi people end.
Leaving hero-worshiping comments on blog rants, calling fellow Americans cowards and wishing death on those we don’t agree with are useless activities. These things ignore the problem, just as Pres. Obama ignores the problem.
Jack, I have no choice but to assume you’re serious, so I’ll respond in kind. The reason we invaded Afghanistan in the immediate aftermath of the 9/11 terrorist attack is that Afghanistan is where the terrorists were. That’s why it made more sense than invading, I dunno, Canada. Feel free to disagree. As for Pakistan, if Osama Bin Laden is encamped there, and using the Pakistani government’s unwillingness to go after him as a kind of protection? Yes, we go in, we take him off the board.
This is war. It’s not cheerleading to suggest we fight it.
Don’t let the ignorant so-and-so’s get you down, including our very ignorant new and inexperienced president who has never been in a combat situation and is rather wet behind those gigantic ears of his. Many people, including me, understand what this war is really about and how important it is that we man-up and not turn tail and run as all yellow bellied neo-libs seem to want to do. President Bush did a great job of sending a ‘don’t mess with the US’ message. Obama is sending a,’we are pansies hear us run’ message. I’d rather be hated and at the top of the food chain that get eaten while I’m acting all warm and fuzzy.
Ahh, Jack Lad, your point finally emerges. What really ticks you off are folks who think the war in Iraq was strategic error while supporting action in Afghanistan at the same time. The geo-political version of chewing gum and walking at the same time.
Careful you don’t trip.
Lola – January 29th, 2009 at 9:39 am
“Terry we get it, your an anti Semite. And frankly your rantings are more fit for Munich circa 1935. And I would bet you don’t even get what I mean by what I said to.”
Anti-Semitism isn’t hating Jews – it is being hated by Jews.
Indeed, look around. The financial situation is much like Germany in 1935 Germany. BTW, in *1933* International Jews declared WAR on Germany. You are just too blind and ignorant to see that same actors are responsible for our own financial crisis. At least Germans woke up to it.
Melissa – January 29th, 2009 at 10:34 am
After a handfull of immigrants with box cutters brought this country to its knees (if you believe that version of the story) Bush not only didn’t close the border, but encouraged a massive invasion with promises of Amnesty. So, no, Bush has made us less safe by giving foreigners both a REASON and a MEANS to attack us. Our food and water supply are huge targets, for example. But understand Bush and the same people who controled him as they control Obama (there is no “change”) can’t wait for another attack and will stage one themselves if no one takes the bait. They want to declare martial law. They want more money and power. What is to stop them?
You guys just keep doing your jobs, lookout for your buds, kill the enemy when you get the chance, hit the deck when the motars come and low crawl to the bunker or hole, If it is your time to get it, you can’t do a damn thing about it. If you get visitors (VIPS) tell them you want counter battery fire and detection systems which are available, if you don’t have it get it. It picks up the incoming rounds by radar, sounds a siren, early warning, gives you time to hall ass to the bunker or hole, it send co-ordinates to you counter battery team and they blow the sons of bitches up, should also have gun-ship support to comb the area after you ditermine where the rounds come from, quick reaction force to go in gunning for the gooks on the ground, also neck wound bleeding can be stopped sometimes with direct pressure to the wound, but remember the pressure has to be on both sides of the wound to stop the bleeding as in corotid arterial bleeding, if you are going to pray do it on the way to the bunker or hole just get your ass moving, keep up the good work, cover your six and have fun when you can. I was a combat rescue specialist in Vietnam, medic and gunner on USAF Super Jolly Green Giant, three miniguns two PJ’s, flight engineer/gunner, Pilot, co-pilot and sometime combat photag, we got mortars and rockets at least three times a week at Danang RPVN, 66mm mortars, 122mm soviet rockets{incoming}Katusha, and the largest attack we had 116 impacts, 1 kia, 7 wounded US casualties, counterbattery fire was 175mm and 105mm howitzers, cobra gunships hit the launch area after the attacks, found 16 enemy gooks dead, and search and destroy teams later found almost 100 rockets nearby all 122mm, destroyed in place by c4 by engineers, also lots of blood trails. You guys should do better than we did, we didn’t have armored vest of NVGs or thermal imaging, if you don’t have air support, C130 gunship, or helicopter support, then your officers have their heads up their asses, write your congressman, tell them about the stupidity if they are unwilling to fix it or protect you like you should, the helicopters can also provide air evac in case you do no have med facilities available, tell the old man (CO) that he can also use the choppers to rece the local are for potential sites the enemy might use. Good luck, keep your heads down, pass the amunition, and there are no athiest in the battleground of the foxhole. Vietnam Vet 1971-72
[...] VET DECLARES WAR [...]
God Bless you Sgt. Welsh and THANK YOU for your herioc service. There are sooo many of us who support not only our troops but what you are doing in Iraq and Afganistan. People who have no understanding of the nature of our current enemy are clueless as to why we fight, where we fight and why it matters. For those who can’t seem to get a grip on why Iraq..read the below link. Hollywood has done an about face over the last 50 years when it comes to supporting our troops during wartime. Hollywood does more damage with ridiculous (box office failures) like Rendition, Redacted, etc. by giving solace to the enemy. For that, I see Liberal Hollywood as MY enemy.
Make sure to scroll down for article once on site
http://www.weeklystandard.com/Content/Public/Articles/000/000/003/236jmcbd.asp
HEY Welch!, PULL YOU HEAD OUT! stop whining and stand tall. there an’t no medals or any amount of media coverage gonna change sh@t!. we all do what we do just like every other SOB in every other war. you do it for the man next to you. you do it for your country, presidents come and go.
but the Marine Corp is forever!.
The Truth is the Truth because we all know what really happens.
In our hearts we know, we will remember, we made the promises to never forget! and thats why we are “always faithful” faithful to each other.
Semper Fi
GeronimoRumplestiltskin – January 29th, 2009 at 10:19 am
Dear Sgt. Welsh:
“Recap: Almost 6 years after invasion, a) a brutal dictator has been deposed, b) the US has rebuilt his mess of a country to the brink of it becoming an established constitutional democracy in Al Queda’s back yard ( a major PR and morale blow to Al Queda ), c) Al Queda has been severely weakened, d) not a single terrorist attack has occurred on American soil, as Al Queda was busy fighting and losing exactly the kind of war they are least equipped to fight (i.e. against trained and equipped soldiers instead of unarmed civilians), e) Osama Bin Laden is neither powerful in life or in death as a martyr, but has been marginalized to point of irrelevancy, and f) all this was accomplished with less US casualties than were suffered on D-Day or 1/10 of the casualties of Vietnam.”
a) Actually, he was an elected secular leader. Now they can vote in religious clerics. How does that fit in with your scheme? Musharaff was brutal dictator who led a military coup. Why did we deal with him? OOOOOOHHHH, that’s right, he had a nuke. So, listen up, countries. If you don’t want to be invaded by the US, be sure to beg, borrow, or steal a nuke (Israel choose the latter route by stealing them from us).
b) people still don’t have power and water like they did with Saddam. Even if what you said is correct, it wasn’t worth one American life or one American dollar.
c) We funded Al Queda – we created them. We have created more terrorist due to our actions.
d) The terrorists know of Sun Tsu. Never attack an enemy in the process of self defeat. We are collapsing more every day. Why would they attack us. You imply that somehow a war in Iraq somehow prevents someone coming here and committing at terrorist act. HOW? You go on to say how absurd it would be for them to attack our military. Exactly right. They didn’t before – what makes you say they would start now. Those people defending their country in Iraq are like the Wolverines in Red Dawn. We are the invaders. Would you like it if this country were invaded? Think.
e) funny spin for “getting away with 9/11″ – that is if OBL ever was responsible at all.
f) that was back when we had the resources to spare – not 35 TRILLION in debt.
Thanks for serving our country !
[...] more: Big Hollywood » Blog Archive » One Iraq War Vet Declares War On … america, americans, Interesting, iraqi, media, obama, troops, [...]
A main reason the Liberal Press and blood suckers on the left don’t like the war, is that it takes money away from their other pet projects such as creating more entitlements so they can buy more future votes and stay in office longer.
Thank You, Sgt. Welch for your service to our country. Please know that many ordinary citizens know and appreciate what our military has done in Iraq , Afghanistan and around the world.
We are outraged that Obama became president on very little information about him and his background and on a whole lot of lies about our President Bush and our military. YOU have kept us safe and done the hard work needed to be done. Mr. Obama has benefited from that and the lies that the media and political campaigns told in order to get him elected.
The ignorance of the electorate along with voter fraud around the country has resulted in a travesty of having a president in the WH now out and about apologizing to the Muslim world for America. This is the outrage ignorance breeds.
We have a long road ahead these next four years and maybe longer to regain integrity and decency in America. A hard job but nothing like our military has endured for our freedom. Free to make ignorant and foolish choices. Thank you from the bottom of our hearts for keeping us free and doing the heavy lifting. We will never forget and we will always revere our military. The finest and most humane in the world.
God bless you, Sgt. Welsh.
All appreciation.
It’s a sad day when your own nation turns your back on you for protecting and serving her. I’d love to see how all these overgrown children would react to being thrust out to the front lines of the war on terrorism. I’d love to see their reaction to how the terrorists set up mortars in school playgrounds and then after they fire and before we can blow them up, leave so that if we do retaliate we end up shooting innocent children.
I’d love to see their reaction to watching an 11 year old girl being forced to walk into a crowded market with a bomb strapped to her stomach; then the bomb being set off via cell phone and her body parts being flung over other innocent lifeless bodies.
Or maybe that’s a misguided wish, maybe they’d be on the other side already, cheering it on?
Sgt. Welsh, you have my profound thanks for doing what you do.
Wouldn’t it be cool if our troops invaded Hollywood?!
You rock, Sgt. Welsh!
Lola, you’re making a fairly basic error. My complaint has nothing to do with my feelings about the military or even the war in Iraq. My point is that the video the Sergeant used to prove President Obama’s ungrateful/inaccurate opinion about Iraq was in fact about Afghanistan. This was dishonest, whether intentionally or not. And sure, calling him a liar was extreme, and I’m happy to retract it. But that doesn’t make the use of the video any less mistaken or inappropriate.
blueman – January 29th, 2009 at 11:38 am
Are you familiar with the terrorist that murdered kidnapped British soldiers and booby-trapped their bodies? Same ones that blew up a hotel as a terrorist act. They were known as the Irgun and I bet you haven’t even heard of them. But they were rewarded with these and other terrorist acts by being given their own country that is highly subsidized by US and German tax payers.
So, “terrorism works” is the message WE have allowed to be sent by our support of the terrorist state of Israel.
Sgt. Welsh, The sad truth of the matter is that 53% of Americans in the United State have their head up their A$$ and voted for the “ONE”. Mostly because they are misinformed,uneducated and the biggest PUSSIES. Always the ones to bitch the loudest about injustice,but the last to take action. This includes, but is not limited to all, of Hollywood. The other Forty-Six percent of Americans, if not ex-military, or law enforcement or law abiding citizenery commend ALL “fighting the cause for Freedom”. You have every right to be angered, you do-not stand alone, there are many who feel the same as you and all our fallen countrymen&women through the ages. Thank you for all you and all services have done and truely scarificied for America and Others.
SGT Welsh thank you for your service to this great country and to thousands of innocent people around the world. What you men did over there, and continue to do is GOOD. Pay no attention to the liberals, you know how they like to whine and bitch about everything. There are still millions of people who love you and support you. God Bless
Sgt. Welsh, you are truly a great American.
I support you and your fellow soldiers, and do so with all respect for you and your mission.
I am one of a small but growing group who stands in opposition to some peace activists weekly in West Chester, PA.
We call ourselves American sheepdogs and among our numbers are vets from different eras, regular citizens with family members in the service (we have several Blue Star Moms and Dads) and just plain Americans (gun and bible clinging) who care about our troops, and want to see them succeed!
Keep shouting the truth, and God bless you!
http://americansheepdogs.com/
God bless you Sgt. Welsh! I support you and all of America’s troop, and wish you success in all of your missions. Keep giving it to the morons in Hollywood, and keep telling people the truth!
I have a nephew who spent 5 months in Iraq, and is scheduled to go back this summer. I also proudly count myself a member of a group from West Chester PA, who support our troops every week, in opposition to the peace activists who gather there to protest the war. Among us (American Sheepdogs) are vets from different eras, and Blue Star Moms and Dads, as well as others who are simply there to show our support for our brave men and women in the armed forces!
http://americansheepdogs.com/
Terry:
Thank you for writing such foolish things in response to my comment:
“Actually, he was an elected secular leader. Now they can vote in religious clerics.” You are truly out of your gourd if you think elections under Saddam were ‘free’ in any sense of the word. And yes, they may now vote in religious clerics; we, in the US, may vote in ministers, rabbis, priests, or a cleric of any other religion should we so choose.
“Even if what you said is correct, it wasn’t worth one American life or one American dollar.” Yeah, all those things I listed were worthless. Keep telling yourself that, though it pretty much negates any claim to being part of a “reality-based” community.
“We funded Al Queda – we created them.” Yes, we armed them and trained them to fight the Soviets, the world’s greatest evil at the time. That they repaid our aid by turning on us speaks more to their character than ours.
“You go on to say how absurd it would be for them to attack our military. Exactly right. They didn’t before – what makes you say they would start now.” Jesus, do you know anything about what has happened on the ground over there? I will try to sum up the testimony of my many friends in the military (including a few in the Pentagon) as to what has been happening in Iraq:
The Iraq war is a “Bleeding” war. Its purpose is not to defeat an enemy, which would be almost impossible, since our enemy isn’t well-defined by his nature as a terrorist. Its purpose is simple but effective…to will bleed his ability to bring the fight to us by draining his munitions, manpower, wealth, resources and recruiting bases. After Iraq’s defenses fell, we did something very odd for an army that was (ostensibly) merely focusing on occupying and rebuilding a country: we left the borders open. This was done to encourage the enemy to fight us on their own soil, causing them collateral damage, and all the while bleeding their ability to wage war on us where we’re most vulnerable, here in the U.S. (I suppose your liberal mind has now filtered out the reports of the MSM that Al Queda in 2003-07 was pouring into Iraq, which was presented as evidence of the war’s failure). While in Iraq, US troops have fought Chechnians, Lybians, Jordanians, Sudanese, Iranians, Lebanese and Iraqis. To assert that Al Queda was too smart to be lured into battle against US troops is easily refuted by testimony from our own soldiers, leaders, and even the MSM.
Pre-surge, our tactics were ineffective. Our soldiers would go into a community to try to root out the enemy and build infrastructure, but once they returned to base, Al Queda operatives would come in and kill everyone who helped or was suspected to helping the Americans. Patreaus’ strategy was to form “pods” of soldiers as a consistent establishment in the communities (for which he needed additional manpower, hence the surge). By establishing a consistent presence, they began to earn the trust of the Iraqi people (now able to contrast the US soldiers’ day-to-day humanity with Al Queda’s day-to-day brutality), who began to assist them more and more with their efforts. Al Queda in Iraq began suffering large numbers of casualties, and as the “Bleeding” became hemoraging, began surrendering steadily. As of today, Al Queda is finished in Iraq, and their morale and reputation has been dealt an enormous blow. For you to deny these facts, as related by our soldiers, leaders, and even the MSM, is to continue to refuse to face reality.
“funny spin for ‘getting away with 9/11′ – that is if OBL ever was responsible at all.” Wow. Even foolish enough to wander into “Truther” territory.
“that was back when we had the resources to spare – not 35 TRILLION in debt.” In light of yesterday’s “Stimulus” Package of primarily pork spending being passed by the House with only Democrats voting for it, hearing a liberal fret about govt. spending can only strike me as humorous.
Sir, you are a fool. That you wish to display this publicly is to your own misfortune and my pity and amusement.
Sgt. Welsh,
God bless you for your service and dedication. You, and the thousands of other soldiers that demonstrate daily true courage to preserve and promote freedom, are in our prayers nightly.
As for your blog post, it speaks about the issue from a perspective that many of us do not have. We do share your anger and outrage, but I also condition that outrage with optimism. I’ve seen America where it stands now, and 4 years later we were blessed with Ronald Reagan and a renewed spirit of patriotism that I still believe we can return to.
Welsh,
declaring war on hollywood is a just and noble cause in my opinion.
members of the military like yourself who give up so much for our freedom, and yes our freedom of speech just to have that same freedom used against you is shameful.
you are a great American. and dont worry about these little KOS kids who have for one reason or another decided to come over here in an attempt to create a ‘Gotcha!’ moment. something i have witnessed over the years is when a lefty tries to win an argue with their superior intellect they are usually found wanting
These military expenditures have bankrupted the country and all you clowns in costume can think about is your stupid mission.
Most of us out here wish you all would just shoot yourselfs.
Mr. Blifil:
I stand by everything I have written. I choose to believe my friends in the military who have served in Iraq and the ones currently in the Pentagon, as well as the reports I glean from various news sources, both foreign and domestic (my job requires me to be online about 12 hours a day). That you continue to cherry-pick which reports to cite in order to prop up your fantasy of an Iraq teetering on the edge of collapse reflects worse on your judgment than it does to the content of any of my statements.
Sgt. Welsh,
Believe me, we are in your corner bro…I have seen those movie clips and they are a joke, especially that punk~ass E~8 talking about his 3 tours…POGS! The movie that really pisses me off though is In the Valley of Elah…I was so enraged by this movie, so insulted and when Tommy Lee Jones raised the colors upside down, I almost puked…
God Bless!
Beau Payne 3rd Ranger Bat, Benning
101st Campbell, Rakassan
93-97
To SSGT. J Ontiveros;
Pull your head and the Left’s dick out of your ass, the latter of which you seem particularly willing to take.
First of all, you may fight only for the man next to you, but there are those of us who fight for our country and its values as well.
Secondly, as a Marine, you might want to reconsider letting the Corps take it up the ass, and instead have the balls to stand up and defend it. Not all Marines enjoy the cock to ass proximity that you do.
And see, it’s not just about standing up and defending the Corps’ honor against media lies, it is about the very thing you claim to be most concerened about: protecting the life of the man next to you.
Let me tell you how it works in America. if the CIC doesn’t enjoy sufficient public support to fight a war to its necessary victory, he is very often unable to.
And this leaves each and every one of us in the field exposed to everything from gear, weapons, and ammunition shortages, to retreat before the real beast of defeat has reared its head.
This leads to new troop deaths, and via self-imposed defeat, it leads to the value of the lives of those already killed being degraded to absolute zero.
And what controls public opinion in this country? The media.
So when you tell Sergeant Welsh to stop worrying about what the media says, you are committing the greatest sin of all. You are letting down the man next to you, you are leaving him without support, without cover, without a chance.
Wise up, hard charger.
GeronimoRumplestiltskin – January 29th, 2009 at 12:26 pm
“As of today, Al Queda is finished in Iraq,”
They weren’t IN Iraq before (even if they are now). So, we wasted a trillion dollars (with the money flowing to people like Blackwater, Carlyle Group, Halliburton, etc…) and thousands of American lives to do nothing.
Terry,
As you continue to join Mr. Blifil in the “bury your head in the DailyKos” approach to what has been accomplished in Iraq, I consider my previous comment (12:35 pm) and the last sentence of my 12:26pm comment to suffice as a response to you and similar fools.
Good day, sir.
I don’t read DailyKos and I am a conservative like Pat Buchanan (and a host of other conservatives opposed to this war for Israel from the start).
I’ve noticed a lot of you who speak glowingly of the mission in Iraq and about how Saddam was “bad” are on the wrong side of the Israel-Palestinian issue. You don’t seem to mind Israel’s oppression of the Palestinians…and that we pay tons of money to SUPPORT (and one of the main reasons we are hated in the world.) In short, your POV is being programmed by the Zionists and Israel. Mine is consistent. America first, not Israel.
Dear Sgt. Welsh,
God’s blessings and our thanks to you and your fellow Soldiers, Sailors, Airmen, Guardsmen and Marines for your heroic service to our country and for liberating and defending the innocent and defenseless people of Iraq.
Thank you for fighting and defeating America’s evil enemies.
Your disgust at the anti-American cowards’ anger-displacement against our Military is more than justified. I trust you’ll not waste more time on their self-loathing insanities.
I appreciate and share your scorn of irresponsibile movie-makers. Take comfort in the fact that their narcissistic movies were box-office duds for good reason: America rejected them.
Obama’s phenomenon is already fizzling. Events are overtaking him much faster than his acolytes ever fantasized.
As for America’s victory in Iraq — History will, I think, be very good to those such as yourself that kept the faith, while keeping up the fight. Bless you!
I’d love to see Matt Damon challenge you to a debate.
Take care, and keep writing O’ Happy Warrior.
A.S.
Terry
your use of the word oppression when speaking of how Israel is handling the Palestinians is sickening. how would you like to have thousands of unguided missiles flying towards your city? Hamas deserves what they get. and ever wonder about civilian casualties there? well thats because the great group Hamas fires rockets from hospitals and schools. and your sentence where you mentioned saddam being “bad” pisses me off too. i guess you think genocidal tyrants awesome. but i dont. he is dead now and i am happy that are military dealt with him.
Sgt. Welch, I just made my 10th tour overseas to support our warriors with some entertainment. I KNOW how important your work has been….I KNOW history will show you did the right thing with this mission. I believe in you and all that you protect with your bravery and patriotism. You have my thanks, my support and my prayers. I will continue to support you in country and back home….without you we are nothing….certainly not FREE.
Thank you for the sacrafice of yourself and your family.
I know how you feel. I was at Balad during the first election, when the Iraqis ratified the constitution. Outside of Iraq, all the media could do was tell us how badly it was going to go and how futile it was. The successful election, with millions of purple fingers waved in defiance of terrorists, was a momentary blip on the media radar, which then refocused on Abu Ghraib, fake stories about flushed Koran’s and other assorted disinformation and lies. Our accomplishments meant nothing to CNN and the NY Times, much less Hollywood. But remember one thing that a far better writer than Brian DePalma once said about “gentlemen now a-bed,” that “they shall curse themselves and hold their manhoods cheap whilst any speaks who fought with us this day.” They don’t have the honesty to curse themselves, but they know what they are, and that’s why they envy us.
kurt(the infidel) – January 29th, 2009 at 1:38 pm
“your use of the word oppression when speaking of how Israel is handling the Palestinians is sickening.”
No, their actions are sickening and is condemned worldwide. Only reason you don’t hear about it is because the US media is, for all practical purposes, owned and run by Zionists.
“how would you like to have thousands of unguided missiles flying towards your city?”
How would you like for China to start building colonies on US soil? Think they might be attacked? Well, how is that different that the land Israel illegally occupies?
“Hamas deserves what they get.”
I bet you don’t even know that Israel broke the cease fire and was in violation of UN resolution 242? Did you? CNN does.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KntmpoRXFX4
“i guess you think genocidal tyrants awesome.”
Apparenly genocide by the Israelis is fine, though???? You have inconsistent views.
Terry
you definitely are a “conservative” like Pat Buchanan. post a picture of your swastika tattoo would you please.
Please don’t ever ban the likes of Terry or MRblifil or Harley. It’s always good to see what stupidity and hatred look like. Anti-semitism lives on the left.
Sgt. Welsh -
The last video was more graphic than I had anticipated. Not only the outright murder of those 3 men in front of the dirt pile, but every last bit of this video drilled horror into my soul. The hardest part to watch was from under the bunk while the morters grew closer and closer, and one of the soldiers prayed and asked God to make it stop. We civilians could never understand how horrifying a situation such as that must be. From that point in the film I found it difficult to concentrate as I was crying. All I could think was that those men lying on the floor, begging God to stop the morters were someone’s son, brother, husband. Every person who walks freely in this great country should be required to watch this video and only then should they be allowed to oppose our men and women who are protecting us. I can almost guarantee there would be a lot more patriotic folks walking about after witnessing that horror.
There are not enough words to thank you and your fellow soldiers for all that you have done to protect us and our wonderful country.
Please remember you are admired and appreciated for all that you have done.
I find it funny that placing America first causes such hysteria among the brainwashed here. It has been all but eliminated from our media and you guys don’t seem to have any context so you flail around accusing me of being on both the “Right” and the “Left.” You do know why they call what is on TV “programming” don’t you? LOL! You guys are definitely programmed. I stopped watching it and can see clearly.
Here is a great 10 minute video on how the “left/right” thing is a distraction.
http://www.wimp.com/thegovernment
[...] Almost 90% of Americans believe the war in Iraq is and was a waste. The Hollywood media feeds the public wasteful, depressing, and horribly fabricated stories. When did the U.S. military become the bad-guys? We are stereotyped “Generation Kill.” I guess that is all we do. All we do is go to Iraq, hunt innocents and slaughter them. I guess that is what I did for eight months while I was there. [...]
My Awesome Mix Tape #6 – January 29th, 2009 at 2:39 pm
“All I could think was that those men lying on the floor, begging God to stop the morters were someone’s son, brother, husband.”
And if not for a cabal of “dual citizens” within our government with names like “Wolfowitz” and “Perle” those men would not be in a foreign country fighting a war for Israel. And we would likely not be watching our country collapse under the weight of these senseless wars.
“Every person who walks freely in this great country should be required to watch this video and only then should they be allowed to oppose our men and women who are protecting us.”
Considering freedom in THIS country is rare nowadays, you may have to change your statements. What this is all about – training and desensitizing Americans to military occupation so it can be implemented in the US (NorthCOM) – is more apparent every day. Our military, in violation of Posse Comitatus, is being used for CHECKPOINTS INSIDE THE US!
“I can almost guarantee there would be a lot more patriotic folks walking about after witnessing that horror.”
Yeah, should make people want to clear our troops out of this war for Israel and save our OWN country first. No war for Israel. No war against Iran.
“There are not enough words to thank you and your fellow soldiers for all that you have done to protect us and our wonderful country.”
That war has only WEAKENED America. Get your priorities straight.
First and foremost, thanks for you service to country. You are a true patriot. Second, I love the areticle and agree 110%. As a prior military member, now civil servant, I see first hand the sacrifice of our US military. I have both family and friends that are in Iraq or have served multiple tours. All that I have spoken too are in complete support of the mission. Sure, they have minor gripes, but given the job they do I think they have the right.
I too am fed up with the portrayal of the military as mindless killing machines. The lack of honesty in the portrayal of our military and country in general from Hollywood and the MSM is abhorent. Still, I hope you do understand that the majority of this country thanks you for your service and sacrifice.
I understand that there are a select few that have banded together to create movies that show the good that America and it’s military do in the world. I purchased a DVD called “An American Carol” and really enjoyed it. The director gives the military it’s just rewards. Even the fun he pokes at the military is in good taste and something that anyone who ever served can easily identifiy with.
Hey, anytime I hear about a new liberal movie decrying the horror’s of the Iraq War I just throw 300 in my DVD player and I feel all better.
“Remember us.” As simple an order as a king can give. “Remember why we died.” For he did not wish tribute, nor song, nor monuments nor poems of war and valor. His wish was simple. “Remember us,” he said to me. That was his hope, should any free soul come across that place, in all the countless centuries yet to be. May all our voices whisper to you from the ageless stones, “Go tell the Spartans, passerby, that here by Spartan law, we lie.” Dillios
Kit – January 29th, 2009 at 3:15 pm
Terry,
What do you mean by “dual-citizens?”
+++++++++++
Citizens of two countries – in this case Israel. Foolishly, the US does not forbid dual citizens from serving in our government. No other country allows this to my knowledge. You don’t see Americans running Israel’s government but we sure see a lot of Israelis running ours and subsequently we fight wars for them, give them tons of money, turn a blind eye to their espionage, etc….
God Bless you, Sgt. Welsh, and THANK YOU for your service to our country.
I guarantee that most Americans appreciate our troops.
Jack Bauer:
All I can say this this: you have have managed to do the impossible by forcing me to side with TERRY on something. This should give you a hint on how much of an idiot you are being.
“What a despicable attitude.”
Um, remind me again, which one of you is the idiot doing the drive-by flaming?
“How can you justify this illegal war in Afghanistan?”
Probably using the EXACT same ways we justified our WWII attacks on the Vichy Regime’s colonies: they provide logistical aid to our enemies, they should not be surprised by retaliation.
“Afghanistan NEVER attacked the US.”
Petain and Laval never attacked the Western Allies in WWII.
They just funneled money and staging areas to those who DID.
Nice strawman.
“No Afghani was on-board the four planes on 9/11.”
And no Frenchman fought alongside the Germans and the Iraqi nationalists in Iraq against the British in an effort to sever the Egypt-India connection (and, given the VERY high percentage of Germans marked down as “Frenchmen”, chances are not many of them fought against us in Madagascar, Trans-Jordan, or Morocco EITHER). They “Only” granted the Germans logistical support to sustain the attack.
Not unlike what the Taliban did.
Please come again.
“Yet you blithely want to send terror into the poor people of Afghanistan.”
Right. Ask how many of them would LIKE the Taliban back.
If you need suggestions scheduling the polling, may I suggest that you try and squeeze it in after you poll Iraqi teenagers on what brands of kite were the most popular under Saddam?
“More troops to kill innocent Afghanis.”
And this is a sad reality of war that cannot be avoided. The thing you avoid mentioning is most of the “innocent Afghanis” that are actually, you know, INNOCENT are killed by their fellow Afghanis the Taliban and by foreign Islamists- our FOES. That, and they can get away with doing such reprisals willy-nilly against such “collaborators” while we actually PERSECUTE those in our ranks who attack the “innocent Afghanis” and RIGHTLY SO, I might add.
But you just don’t get that, do you?
“You sir, are are a disgusting WAR MONGER.”
Awww, they are so cute when they TYPE IN ALL CAPS IN THE HOPE THAT IT MAKES UP FOR THEIR LACK OF PROOF BY OFFENDING THE RECIPIENT, aren’t they?
“Shame on you and your ilk.”
Well, Mr. Bauer, let me show you that two can play this game.
No sir, shame on YOU for being a KNAVE, an IDIOT, an APPEASER OF TERRORISTS, and an ILLITERATE FOOL who has absolutely NO grasp of history, warfare, diplomacy, or COMMON SENSE, and who merely is a LOUD, ARROGANT BLOW HARD incapable of making an argument of any depth whatsoever.
(See? I can do it too! And I did it far more effectively then you did!)
“I’m going to assume you’re a war mongering jerkoff.”
Ah, more trademark civility. Look at the things that they are teaching to Preschoolers these days!
As for you, I will have to assume that you are a stupid, idiotic, terrorist-rooting swine who probably cannot find Kabul on a map.
“I want to know why it okay by you to invade Afghanistan and kill Afghanis when they had nothing to do with 9/11?”
Ah, the “take one unfortunate effect of event X and use it to completely smear event X” strategy. Very nice strategy, seeing as how it protects you from, you know, actually having to make an ARGUMENT.
As for the response, I will have to respond that yes, yes it is “Okay” to invade Afghanistan and kill Afghanis when they had nothing to do with 9/11.
And before you go off on a rant about how you have found an evidence of “NeoKon bloodlust”, I will point out that no, it is not a GOOD thing, no more then it was “good” to have thousands of children in Hiroshima be incinerated instantly by the Bomb, or to have to be forced to kill thousands of crippled German grandfathers press-ganged into the Volksturm by their Fuhrer as the “Last Line” of defense.
But, as terrible as those things, be it the deaths of innocent Afghani farmers, innocent Japanese schoolgirls, or innocent German retirees, it is something that must be weathered through. Because, however ugly those things are it does NOT invalidate our cause or the reasons we fight (particularly given the discipline we impose on our soldiers, unlike those of our foes). So, as tragic as they may be, I must say that, yes, they are “Okay” if it means that we can purge Berlin of both Hitler’s cabal and the old military aristocracy, that YES, it is “Okay” if it means breaking the Japanese Empire and its barbaric Bushido code into pieces that it never can reforge, and that YES, it is “Okay” if Afghanistan can be turned in to a flowering Democracy in Central Asia, having been purged of the factions and forces that have given aid and comfort to our enemies in ways that have helped to claim American lives at home, abroad, and those of our allies at home and abroad.
So, let me phrase your “question” in a different light: “I want to know why it is okay to bury our heads in the sand while a tyrannical and theocratic faction gives aid to our sworn foe and kills innocent Afghanis, Americans, Britishmen, Italians, Israelis, etc. Who are in no way connected to the crusades, to the fall of the Moors on the Iberian, and to the WWI destruction of Ottoman Turkey after a DIRECT attack on our homeland by forces affiliated by the aforementioned group?”
See, not so clear-cut now, is it?
“Come on, tell me why you should send more US troops to a country that has never attacked the US?”
Let me think here: The king of Swaziland is being an authoritarian A**hole, and has been ruthlessly crushing his people to maintain his lavish and feudal lifestyle, so perhaps it would be only humane to depose him and help Swaziland become a Democracy?
Oh, wait, you are “implying” that the country is Afghanistan.
Well,
Perhaps because the leadership of that country helped to fund, train, and give shelter to Osama Bin Laden and Al-Qaeda, who are our sworn foes who attacked us and killed roughly 3,000 people on American soil in a terrorist attack on a CIVILIAN target?
Perhaps because the nation is run by kleptocratic, theocratic, and tyrannical goons who have repeatedly declared Holy War on ourselves and the entire West?
Perhaps because there was a chance of apprehending the man directly responsible for an attack on us who was hiding their with the regime’s approval?
Pick one or more of the above.
“Nor ONE Afghani was ionvolved in the plot to murder 3000 Americans”
That depends on what you define as the “plot” persee, and whether or not “ionvolved” has a different meaning from “involved.”
Perhaps you are (in a VERY narrow sense) correct that not a single Afghani held council with Bin Laden or Atta on the exact stratagems to employ on the attack.
And if “ionvolved” is defined as “To play the Spanish fiddle in a Portuguese musical,” then I could easily see how no Afghani was “ionvolved” in the plot.
But I am guessing that, somehow, “ionvolved” means the same thing as “involved.”
In which case, that is a VERY narrow definition of “involved.”
The fact is that the Taliban gave aid, food, and training to the September 11th hijackers, that they helped funnel money and material to them, and that they have a long and distinguished history with the head of the organization that did the plot: Osama Bin Laden.
So, in short, SEVERAL DOZEN Afghanis tied to the Regime AT LEAST were involved with the plot DIRECTLY (and I am not counting those who must have been indirectly involved with the plot).
Hell, that’s better justification then we EVER had for going after the Vichy regime!
But somehow, the fact that no Afghani was “Ionvolved” by playing the Cello to the Portuguese adaptation of Figaro’s Wedding somehow invalidates the casus belli.
Perhaps you are a bit too passionate about the opera if you think THAT overrides diplomatic and political realities?
“Why are you cheerleading like some cowardly chickenhawk for more collateral damage that you know will occur.”
Firstoff, how do you know what a Cowardly Chickenhawk looks like cheerleading? Surely their wings are difficult to fit into Pompon? Which brings me to my next question: how do you know WHEN a Cowardly Chickenhawk is cheerleading? Surely they have too much stage fright to do it in the presence of others? and even more so, is there a difference in cheerleading when a Cooper’s Hawk does it from when a Sharp-Shinned Hawk or a Red-Tailed Hawk does it?
The inquiring minds of the next generation of great Ornithologists wish to know!
In addition. as for the idea of any of us cheering for more collateral damage, I doubt ANY of us would. But the fact is that, even in the cleanest of wars against a somewhat restrained or honorable foe, these things are inevitable. And we are NOT fighting a restrained or noble foe. But that we recognize this fact and encourage the mission does not mean we relish it, but that we grimly accept it as the cost each generation has paid to live in Freedom and to spread freedom.
Apparently, that concept is beyond you.
“More innocent men, women and children will die in Afghanistan.”
For ONCE, you are right. And it is something that sincerely troubles me. However, what you fail to notice is that these poor souls will fall in far greater numbers to our ruthless and unjust foes then to us, and that they already HAD been perishing by the thousands for YEARS BEFORE the invasion, due to the Taliban’s theocratic rule.
And yet you claim that this somehow discredits us?
“Explain that to me. Do you support invading Pakistan as well”
If the time comes that Pakistan becomes a clear and present threat to the West, to America, and to our Freedoms either directly or through aid to those that are, then yes I would.
“setting the Muslim world aflame”
If that is what must be done, then let it be done. But I sincerely hope it does not require that.
“Before you start call others a LIAR”
Too late, Arsehat.
“defend your war mongering”
Already have.
“chickenhawk”
Since I am neither a bird nor someone unfamiliar with the rigors of conflict, I get the impression you are talking about someone else.
The fact is that you have made yourself to look like a ranting, raving idiot who has no grasp of the realities on the ground.
And the fact that you make TERRY look saner shows how badly you are doing in convincing everyone.
(And don’t worry Terry, It’ll be your turn soon enough).
Since when do moonbats need proof?
In today’s climate of insanity, allegations are given the same weight as evidence.
Okay … I’m trying this again … Without the “cussage” to see if it takes … Please forgive if my previous comment shows up after I post this one:
I am acquainted with Sgt. Welsh and other fine and brave and selfless young men who have served this nation in our military before and since 9-11-01.
About a year ago a young man (an Army Ranger) who was a childhood friend of my son-in-law was killed in Iraq by a filthy terrorist’s sniper bullet.
A couple years before that, another of his childhood friends a Marine, lost his leg to a filthy terrorist’s mortar shell fired into their housing facility as he slept. Ironic how that Marine says he can sleep comfortably with the loss of his leg to a dirty b*stard enemy rat, yet, it’s the bullsh*t attempts to wound and injure and emotionally kill our troops here at home by the very people he and the other servicemen have given all to protect that causes the greatest restlessness.
I have several other young Marines (and Soldiers) I know and love and admire that have served this country since signing up AFTER 9-11-01, and AFTER the initial Iraq invasion … and have served multiple tours in country, one nearly losing his life on his second tour … only to request, post-healing, to be sent back.
I have also become friends of the families of these fine men and women, some of which have lost their loved ones in war. Their understanding and sacrifice leaves me in complete awe, and envy for that level of spirit and strength.
These men, and women, have done nothing wrong. They, if anything, have put their own safety and lives in second or third consideration in order to NOT insult or harm (a kinder, gentler, more compassionate war) the ‘innocents’ in Iraq (and Afghanistan) … Had they fought this war the way war was intended to be fought, the ‘collateral damage and lost lives’ would be countless. Historically it is one of the lowest … if not the lowest loss of lives, military and civilian, with far less destruction than could ever have been hoped for.
The democrats and the MSM (AND Hollywood) in this country have not bothered to use that ‘consideration’ when negatively reporting on, making asinine statements on the Floor(s) of our Congress, and in agenda-driven and hastily fictionalized depictions in film. No one is more bloodstained than you people … with the blood of our troops and the blood of innocent Iraqis. Your bullsh*t caused this war to go on longer and deadlier than need be.
As an American I can never begin to repay the men such as Sgt. Welsh, Sgt. Dan B****n, Sgt. Jason G*****, Cpl. Bennie D****n, Sgt. Carl D****s, “Smitty”, “T-Bagg”, “Iggy”, Pvt. Wilson, and all the rest of the young men who put aside their freedom to be young and carefree … and careless … in order to serve a higher calling … to voluntarily put their very lives on the line for a country they believe is worth sacrificing for … to recognize and believe in something bigger and greater than themselves.
And it sickens me to know that they cannot even put their heads down on a pillow at night to rest peacefully in the freedom they themselves have fought and bled to preserve … simply because people so much smaller than themselves … people they also defended … have a mental disorder and inability to “handle the truth”, and instead, in the safety and freedom of their own fabricated comfort zones, slander, demean and defile men who have continued to provide and protect that decadent luxury they afford themselves from afar.
In the last eight years I have come to realize the core source for all this sh*t-slinging on our troops comes from the individual sh*t-slinger’s jealousy upon recognizing they aren’t even worthy to shine the boots of these men. They lack the intestinal and testicular fortitude to actually make the decision to face evil and danger for a concrete cause greater than to recycle or not to recycle that damn aluminum can.
And finally, it REALLY irks me … no, it f**kin’ pisses me off, that Sgt. Welsh even had to write this piece.
Those who malign him and our military are the same damn dumb-f*ck-ups that insist that child rapists, or murderers “served their time and paid their debts to society” and should be left alone to live wherever without warning signs to the community … and believe that those f*cking human sh*t-stains sitting fat on the American hog in Camp Gitmo are worthy of kindness, consideration and compassion.
These brave, selfless men (and women) HAVE served their time and paid their ‘debt’ to this country’s freedom and liberty so YOU can pursue your mindless and selfish happiness, at their expense … physically and emotionally.
And P.S.
The fact that Hollywood’s movies in the last eight years depicting these men in the war have fallen headfirst into the rotting sh*tter is proof that Hollywood and the limo-lib left in this country LOST the war.
Welsh, THEY sleep safe and well at night because YOU and your brothers did/do the damn hard work to make sure they can.
Ya did good, Sgt. Welsh … Ya did f***in’ DAMN good. You beat the enemy, and you beat Hollywood, the MSm, and the democrats! Put your head down on the pillow and take a long and peaceful nap. You earned it, you deserve it. And you know me, as I always say: F*** `Em!
Hey, Welsh … Thanks, sweetie. I owe ya a few beers.
Maggie
Lola,
I couldn’t be clearer about my objection to the video. Not a single soul has argued that I was wrong in my assumption (the video was about Afghanistan, not Iraq). That’s it. That’s the point I wished to make. And yet time and time again, you make false accusations, empty boasts, emptier threats, and in the name of what?
I get it. Firing verbal bullets at anything that moves makes you feel like Ann Coulter. The uglier and more vicious you can be? The brighter the sun shines inside your head. It’s a weird way to engage with the world. But hey. Everybody has their reasons.
So let’s make a deal. From this point on, I’m going to pretend you’re invisible. Like a bad stink. I would suggest that you do the same. And we can both stop wasting each other’s time. I know I have better things to do. As for you? I guess we’ll find out.
You KNOW its a bad thread when not one, but TWO people override Terry in regards to “Fisking Priority.”
Here we go,
Carolina Yankee:
“I am a conservative.”
Your comments make me question as to what STRIPE of that you are.
“I support our men and women in uniform, and I’m damned grateful that they’ve chosen to serve and protect our nation. I am mindful of the sacrifices these brave people have been called upon to make, and I’m proud of the way in which they’ve conducted themselves under very trying circumstances. Our military is staffed with dedicated and top notch patriots who deserve the utmost respect from every citizen of the USA.”
While this is all very nice and lovely, it would be that much more convincing if it came from someone who actually sounds like they RESEARCHED anything.
“However I believe the mission our soldiers were ordered to undertake in Iraq was wrong.”
And, as any lawyer or Scientist will tell you, Believing does not equal what IS.
“Iraq had no WMD’s or any facilities to make them”
Obviously, somebody has not studied the Al-Anfal Campaign, the Iran-Iraq War, or the testimony of pretty much every one of Saddam’s Baath party bigwigs or most of the intel services on the planet (Including those who OPPOSED the invasion).
And this is while ignoring the many OTHER points on the Docket to justify the invasion.
“nor was Iraq harboring or associated with any Al-Queda”
BZZZZTTTTTT! Wrong Answer. Intel from everybody ranging from the Turks, to Us, to the Iranians, to Egypt, to France, to Canada, to Oman pointed out that Saddam was funding and providing aid to many Islamist groups, including several groups tied to Zawahiri and Bin Laden (including one particularly nasty group in Yemen whose name eludes me for now, but whom I doubtless will remember).
“or Iranian”
Now THAT I can believe.
“Saddam’s secularist Baath Party government hated the Islamic fundamentalist world view of Al-Queda and the medieval mullahs in Iran as much as we do.”
And Hitler and Stalin DESPISED each other to no end. And the Protestants and their French Catholic allies during the 30 Year’s War would have almost certainly have been just as happy to slit each other’s throats as they were to fight against Austria and Spain. Didn’t stop either of those two examples from getting along just merrily until the alliance ceased to be useful. The same situation is now playing itself out in Syria, where Assad (ALSO of that secular Baath PArty) has been funneling Islamists across the border to us and the Israelis like it’s gonna go out of style. This hasn’t seriously destabilized the regime, and if anything has STRENGTHENED IT by ridding the country of the young, zealous converts who, if deprived of another target, would likely come after Assad himself.
I believe Totten said that Assad and his far more imposing father took great pains to make sure that those issues are “for export only.”
And there is more evidence from pretty much every spy network worth its salt that Saddam was pulling the exact same gimmick.
“In short, there was no justification for our invasion of Iraq.”
You REALLY haven’t read the Gulf War Ceasefire, have you? UN Resolutions regarding Iraq? Our stated justification for going to war?
If not, then how would you know? As you have pointed out repeatedly, you can’t. and don’t.
“Nor was there any justification for the occupation of defeated Iraq.”
Oh, you mean BESIDES helping to establish a Democratic Iraq, eliminating the problem we left after the First Gulf War, and preventing the Islamists from moving in and taking control directly? If anything there is more to justify our presence in Iraq after Saddam then there was to justify the invasion (and THAT, coupled with the number of justifications we can pile up to dispose Saddam, should tell you something!).
“The American people never agreed to multi-year post war presence in Iraq.”
Ah, yes, the American people. Note to Carolina Yankee: The US is not a direct democracy, and for VERY good reasons. Also, keep in mind that the “American People” never agreed to carpet bomb Germany and Japan, to intervene to prevent Korea and Vietnam from being overrun, or to ensure that Imperial Germany would be sufficiently reformed after WWI.
Those things alone should reveal how fickle and thin that cheap line is.
“The whole idea to go in light and get out fast, ala the Gulf War of ‘91, right?”
And THIS is where you are obviously incompetent at juding military and political goals. The idea was NOT to “go in light and get out fast.” It was commonly agreed that it would be NICE to do that, but not at the cost of implementing the ACTUAL “whole idea”: To get thing RIGHT this time, unlike what happened after WWI and the First Gulf War.
“And I can’t believe that any American family would’ve knowingly agreed to undertake this task if the knew even an inkling of the emotional/financial cost to be endured of having a loved one and/or breadwinner undertaking multiple deployments in harms way.”
Which is why Thomas Paine took great time to wax poetic about the “value” of Sunshine Patriots. The fact is that he who can outlast the enemy has often won. If this had not happened in WWI, Democracy would almost certainly have been squished out in Europe at the hands of a tyrannical and belligerent Imperial Germany while the rest of it abroad would have been living on borrowed time.
Had we failed to do that later in WWII, the consequences would have been even worse.
And, when we crumpled and ran from Vietnam (pathetically reciting many of the VERY SAME THINGS you so blithely state now) the bloodshed not only crushed any movement towards democracy in Indochina, but also might have threatened to endanger Democracy here, as the USSR’s war council examined American weakness and came VERY close to approving an attack against us. It was only luck that that vote did not go through, which gave us time to recover.
The fact is that those who do not value freedom enough to fight for it IN SPITE OF the cost will often find that it is stripped from them. Before the German Westward offensives of 1940, France was infamously racked by pacifism, including those who viewed Germany as being only seeking what was just for it and those who viewed capitulation as better then another War. I believe one of these individuals loudly questioned “Do you want to die for Danzig?” Of course nobody would want to for some miserly port city in Poland wracked by ethnic infighting. But the question more accurate of the situation was “Are you willing to die for Danzig?” Which asks if one is willing to fight and die, even when one does not want to, for the sake of saving those few Poles and their freedom on the other side of Europe.
Unfortunately, several months later, the answer was clear: no. Not was nobody but the Poles and the Germans willing to die for Danzig, but nobody but the Danes were willing to die for Copenhagen, nobody but the Norweigians willing to die for Oslo, nobody but the Finns wiling to die for Helsinki, and the list goes on.
And, pretty soon, it became clear that nobody was willing to die to protect Rotterdam, Amsterdam , Liege, Brussels, Sedan, or Paris.
And, if you are not willing to die to defend your home city, do you think you would be willing to do so for those handful of Jews living oin your corner?
It was only Churchil, DeGaulle, and a hodge-podge group of exiles who declared that they WERE willing to die for Danzig, for Warsaw, for Copenhagen, for Oslo, for Helsinki, for Amsterdam, for Rotterdam, for Liege, Tours, Athens, Sedan, Paris, Salonika, and several other cities that they probably had never ever been to, for people (like those Parisian Jews on the corner) that they would never meet.
It is only due to the forces of fate and chance that we know that they were right.
And now it is time for the West to re-learn that painful lesson.
“The Iraq invasion was based upon a canard concocted by an administration”
As well, apparently, as most of the world’s intelligence agencies, Saddam’s own bureaucrats, the UN, NATO, and several anti-War individuals, including Hans Blix (who admitted that our charges were mostly just, but that we should have given more time to the ineffective sanctions).
“either hell bent on gaining control of Iraq regardless of the cost, or an administration incapable of conducting a vetting process no more complex than what is asked of a grammar school student writing a book report.”
So which is it, evil genius or stupid idiot? Think on that, because those two are usually not complimentary. Oh yes, and that would be a very tough grammar school, would it not, if it is not satified by the mountain of evidence physically recorded, compiled by our Intelligence, foreign intelligence (including those opposed to us, like Iran) and admitted by Saddam and Co themselves. What more would they want for such a book report, the unanimous approval of all the gods on Mount Olympus?
“Remember the Internet “yellow cake” hoax offered by Secretary Powell as proof of Saddam’s intention to acquire a nuclear arsenal?”
No, I do not. I DO, however, remember a British report detailing Saddam’s attempts to buy Yellow Cake from Niger that Powell bandied about. But that wasn’t a hoax.
“Was that the best our government investigative agencies could do?”
Actually, no that wasn’t. The best OUR government investigative agencies could do was to send an ambassador with no intelligence training or standing and to have him try to go through official channel find out before promptly retaliating when his incompetence was found out.
It was the BRITISH who provided that particular info.
“Would they have fallen for the Bank of Liberia hoax too?”
Given the incompetent performance of American intelligence before, I wonder the same thing.
“It’s absurd!”
For ONCE, I agree with you.
“Our nation was coerced into this Iraqi misadventure by politicians”
Many of whom had the suriname of “Hussein.”
“who either lied to our faces for their own sinister reasons, or who were too damned stupid to exercise the fact finding skills we expect from ten year old children.”
Given the incompetence of the Hussein Regime in Iraq, I must say that either of those two are very possible. But, in any event, their numerous tripups were even worse then ours were, and even the UN admitted we had the charges right, but that we were “Rushing” to action.
“Over the years the rational for this war has changed”
Not really. Our Rational for the invasion has remained virtually unchanged from the start, and it is still around if you had any interest in serious research.
As for the rational for STAYING in-country, you are right. But only because facts on the ground change, and so does the strategic rational (for instance, Allied rational for the war in Korea altered frequently as the battle lines changed, but that does not mean the previous rationals were false).
“as each new reason offered as justification has been exposed as false.”
Obviously, not to the extent you seem to think, as you have failed to get ONE single point on that issue correct.
“Now we’re being told that we’re nation building in Iraq.”
And you think that isn’t true? Good luck finding the proof for that!
“Constructing a nation out of the disparate and hostile tribal remnants of empire that have only known political unity at the point of a tyrant’s sword since the Abbasid Caliphate of Baghdad was created in the late Eighth Century.”
Oooh, nice attempt to use historical gobeldegook to try and make a point. But even that is inaccurate, as the first time it was ACTUALLY united under a tyrant’s sword was the Neo-Assyrian Empire. Nice try though.
And another thing: France and Germany were both undemocratic nations until three two centuries ago for the first one (in name, less then 200 in fact) and just over sixty for the latter (and this is not counting the fact that the country was not united), and that Chinese history was largely a history of Imperial and royal dynasties for several millenia until 1911? The fact is that, however impressive your attempts to sound serious may be, the fact is that there is a first for everything and that much is unthinkable until it actually happens for the first time.
“Throughout this whole ordeal, our troops have conducted themselves admirably. They deserve our respect for the outstanding manner in which they’ve risen to crisis upon crisis, all the while upholding the ideals upon which our nation was founded.”
So, respect the troops, but don’t trust any of the reports or evidence they dig up? It must be remembered that most of the evidence found relating to Iraq’s WMD programs, its violations of the UN, etc, was literally dug out for the first time or at the very least confirmed by the troops.
Some of the very same evidence you seem to think doesn’t exist. So, are the Troops noble, gullible fools, or noble, scheming liars?
“They also deserve our understanding and comfort for the callous way their noble idealism been abused by those political creatures too crooked or too stupid to have ever been given authority to command them.”
I agree, though I get the impression that it would not be in the same sense you mean that as.
“The sergeant is right, Hollywood has disrespected the American soldier. Lefties call our troops mindless killers because they themselves are too stupid to understand the difference in responsibility between the hammer and the hand that wields it.”
To play devil’s advocate, can they not be excused from that when it appears that you yourself have difficulty understanding the difference?
“Screw the lefties!”
No comment.
“Yet we conservatives have been idiots too.”
Yes, we have, though not on the things you seem to want to call us out on.
“We’ve allowed our respect and devotion to the admirable men and women serving in our military to blind us to the inexcusable manner in which the idealism of our valiant troops has been misused by the liars and/or fools that we’ve elected to command them.”
While the latter part of that sentence is sure to draw some laughs from this crowd given the date (though not from I), you once again fail to notice that, in order for all the forgeries you seem to love calling us out on to be false, we have to disregard the large volumes of evidence coming in from all levels of the troops. How do we mesh this out? Ad they noble liars or noble fools, according to you? Because, the fact is that , for an operation of this scale, there must be an active participation from the troops you (justly) wax poetic about. So, are they liars or fools? Which one?
“In the final analysis Sgt. Welsh, it isn’t the libbies in Tinseltown who’re responsible for all of the justifiable angst your service to your country has created in your soul.”
That is true. My personal guess is on the Jihadists.
“We conservatives are equally responsible,”
By ‘we’, you are reffering to yourselves and other likeminded individuals who go around and make claims long on ranting and short on evidence that insinuate that the troops are liars taking part in a coverup or fools duped by an unscrupulous administration?
If that is so, then I might grudgingly agree with you.
However, that is probably not the case.
“if not more so for your righteous anger.”
And you think you are helping the matter by attacking his mission and either his personal integrity or his intelligence (if not both?).
“We’re your parents, your aunts and uncles,”
That would be a rather imbred family, I must note.
“your teachers, your wise old sages down at the corner gas station.”
Given the quality drop I have noticed in both areas, I am not sure you want to claim that as a PLUS.
“We should’ve known better than to have allowed you to be so callously used. We should’ve never let your desire to serve your country and to do what’s right, combine with our own desire for revenge after 9/11.”
And can you tell me how those two parts are any more different from the desire to do what is right and the drive for revenge against Japan following Pearl Harbor? Because, if not, you have only succeeded in digging yourself further in the hole.
“We abrogated the responsibility we have as citizens of this nation thoughtfully”
Yes, we have. Though not in the way I think you think it means.
“prudently and compassionately use the tremendous power of our military might.”
Perhaps you would like heading to Iraq to tell the poor souls we fished out of Saddam’s torture rooms about how we failed to “prudently and compassionately use the tremendous power of our military might?”
Because something tells me that they may hold a slightly different opinion on that matter then you do.
“Relying instead upon the say-so of those whom we elected to exercise this power”
Point taken.
“abandoning the responsibility we all have of questioning their fitness or basic intelligence to exercise this awesome power.”
In some cases, that is just. However, given the poor factual basis, the lack of evidence or research, and the ignorant conspiracy theories you have spouted, you might not want to open that particular can of worms.
“The leftie loonies in La-La-Land aren’t the only ones deserving of your contempt sergeant. They have a lot of company in that Hall of Shame because all of us conservatives are in there with ‘em.”
Yes indeed. You have CERTIANLY demonstrated the truth of that statement to him (though, again, not in the way I think you want to.)
“I can only speak for myself”
Which leads me to wonder where you got the “we”s you used previously from.
“and maybe I’m fulla beans”
Medicinally, that is unlikely. Allegorically, though, that is certain.
“but sergeant you are your fellow soldiers deserved a lot better from us than you’ve received.”
Again, I agree with you on that much.
“And speaking strictly for myself, I’m sorry.”
If I thought for half a second that was to apologize for the tremendous load of tripe that lies above that sentence as well as the attitude of the country in general, I would agree with your sentiment.
As it is, I will only wonder how long our Republic can hope to last with fools to the Left of me, Fools to the Right, and murderous Knaves that the two sides refuse to see staring right ahead, their swords already bloodied and ready for use on us.
Welsh and The Ghost Behind You
Thank You!
I hope I can merely live a life that reflects the honor of men like you and all those who wear the uniforms of this great nation.
Welsh and The Ghost Behind You
Thank You!
I hope I can live a life that reflects the honor of men like you and all those who wear the uniforms of this great nation.
Hey,Terry, in 2000 Crazy Pat received 0.7 percent of the popular vote. Half of his voters were old Jewish bubbes in Florida who were confused by the butterfly ballot – and the remaing 15 or so Buchanan voters were Jew hating fringe lunatics like yourself.
The only reason that old sack o’ manure gets on TV is because liberals want everyone to think all conservatives are as whacko and bigoted as he is.
Thank you Sgt. Welch and all other members of the armed forces
The media will always try and make money off of true patriots.
It’s nice to see a lot of them going out of business.
Not everyone in the US has partaken of the “kool-aid.”
Semper Fi
Corky:
“G-D Turtle….Shorten it all”
No.
“No Wars for israeli iron booted murdering filthy warmongers. America First Committee!”
I hope you are joking, lest I am forced to do another trillion-word rant on you (and delay poor Terry’s fisking even further!).
“Obama said “shameful” Wall St Gonifs! I say spill their blood. Hey Mr. Gitmo here is a map of Miami, NY and of course Hollywood! Behind that rock! here this Tree!”
Are you even TRYING to make sense?
Welsh –
Great post. You have every right to be upset with the way the military has been treated by the elitist left in Hollyweird.
I can’t speak highly enough of individuals like you and Pat, Michael and Andrew that are doing so much to get the truth out to the masses.
Thank you and God Bless.
Sgt Welsh,
I scrolled through most of the comments. Men and women out there are saying it better than I could, fighting the good fight against the liberal menace (and the anti-Semites too!).
I just wanted to say thank you for your service. No one asked to go out there, you weren’t duped, you made the choice, signed the paper, took your chances with your eyes wide open. That takes more cajones that most of the Democratic party combined. And you will not be forgotten, sir.
What is going on in that part of the world will not fade. The Libtards will chase after someone else (hopefully over a cliff) and history will be written by those interested in Knowledge. And it will reveal the Truth you and your brothers know now. So be patient. This too will pass.
Sgt., keep in mind that you are completely not alone. The last eight years our communications systems have been hijacked by people who wish to change our form of government. They too will be found out and fade. A lot of men and women throughout the country, even the world, know the sacrifices you and your brethren have made. And am grateful and would gladly buy you all a case of beer (apiece) for putting your ass on the line.
Terry — man, please get some counseling or some help. Do you have a close friend you can talk to? (maybe an elderly one that is deaf) I am a healthcare provider and I can tell you, seriously, you are on your way to a heart attack.
Sgt. Welsh — you sir cannot be thanked enough not only for your service to our nation but for speaking up and being a voice that has not been heard enough. God bless you for bravery on both counts.
Sgt Welsh – thank you so much for your service and for laying it on the line to Obama and to Hollywood. I know that your service was not a waste and that you have kept this country safe. My dad is a veteran of World War II and Korea and if he were still here, he would be furious at how all the military is being portrayed by the liberal left, Hollywood and by Obama. These outlets shame all the vets of all the wars that were fought for this country. My dad would salute you and so for him; and for the rest of this country – I salute your service and thank you from the bottom of my heart.
Nice work The Almighty Turtle.
A wonderful history lesson, by history I mean not to many years ago.
Perhaps a little opinionated against some well meaning people but factually accurate.
In college I had a professor ask if any one could give justification for invading Iraq. Strangely enough it was in an English class. I sighted the UN’s sanction 15… something or other. I put forth the argument that the world had spoken and all intelligence data had pointed to Iraq having WMD’s. Granted we gave them most of their WMD’s.
As most Americans know having a right leaning perspective in college is a tough road to hoe. I bit the bullet and put in my two cents, to the gasps of students because of the symbolism of my long hair.
The UN and a majority of all other countries agreed that Iraq should be dealt with. It goes with out saying that the UN is big on talk and short on action.
My professor asked, since I was the only one willing to give a reason, what happens if we find out that Iraq doesn’t have WMD’s. I responded that the Iraq’s would be better off in the long run in spite of bad information.
While the media talks about all the civilian casualties because of the invasion they pale in comparison to the casualties brought on by its leader Saddam Hussein. The media seems to forget that Saddam was great at killing his own country men and women. The atrocities he committed upon his own country are staggering and quickly forgotten.
As a side note pay no attention to Corky Thatcher… he’s special.
Thanks again Sgt. Welch and all other military men and women serving our country. God Speed
Dear Sgt. Welsh:
Some of us get it, what you wrote, and get it abundantly (also, what you wrote). I cannot express to what degree of revulsion I viewed each of those titles when they (originally) aired and for the same reasons you’ve expressed.
And, I agree that Yon and Dollard get it, too, have the real news.
I hear Barack Obama making these unbelievably discourteous-to-downright-disgusting lies in his “me be celebrity” tone (that unfortunate people actually find credible) with that bravado-spin he applies to false reports, and I can say that there are many, many Americans who are not (at all) comfortable with D.C. in these times for the same reasons I am not and as what you’ve identified.
I thank you from the bottom of my heart for your service and I mourn all American and Allied personnel who have lost their lives in service, as also extend my gratitude for their service to their families.
Many of us do get it, we see the lies, we notice them, we don’t fall for them, either.
My profound apologies for spelling your name wrong Sgt. Welsh….
Sincerely,
A bad speller
Also, I don’t know if actors who participate in these titles recognize what damage they do to their careers — their “onscreen credibility” — by being a part of work such as these (these clips, your post).
BUT, there was a time I could indeed suspend disbelief in a person’s moral and ethical character and enjoy onscreen work before me, but no more. There are many talented performers and filmmakers whose work at some point in the past I enjoyed, but, after the recent, more grim reality of our world and taking notice of it, and then hearing, reading various performers and filmmakers betray my “trust” as an American, loyal to my fellows, my country, it becomes impossible to continue to find their work acceptable afterward.
I venture to guess that a lot of American consumers feel as I do — and why it is I pass up theatrical purchases where once I’d have made a buy.
A thousand apologies for spelling your name wrong Sgt. Welsh, I have a friend with the last name Welch.
Hardball, you’re missing the point. Tho’ given the feeding frenzy on this thread, that’s to be expected. Obama’s point is not that difficult to understand. Until we get an adequate number of troops on the ground in Afghanistan, we’re forced to fight an air war that leads to greater civilian casualties. By definition. Obama’s hardly the only person to make this point, a number of generals have said the same thing. Suggesting that comment was made about Iraq is disingenuous. Suggesting that Obama thinks we’re bombing innocent civilians on purpose is worse than disingenuous, it’s intentionally stupid.
And ironically? The only person here who seems to yearn for the Soviet Union and the ability to restrict someone’s free speech? That would be you.
Weird how that works out.
“Hardball, you’re missing the point. Tho’ given the feeding frenzy on this thread, that’s to be expected. Obama’s point is not that difficult to understand. Until we get an adequate number of troops on the ground in Afghanistan, we’re forced to fight an air war that leads to greater civilian casualties. By definition. Obama’s hardly the only person to make this point, a number of generals have said the same thing. Suggesting that comment was made about Iraq is disingenuous. Suggesting that Obama thinks we’re bombing innocent civilians on purpose is worse than disingenuous, it’s intentionally stupid.
And ironically? The only person here who seems to yearn for the Soviet Union and the ability to restrict someone’s free speech? That would be you.
Weird how that works out.”
I couldn’t have said it any better myself.
“…As for Obama, if Rush Limbaugh merely criticizes, he weeps and gnashes his teeth with the pain.
There’s a reason why boys like Barack Obama don’t join the military.
I know for sure there’s one thing we’re going to learn, and that is what it’s like to have a President with absolutely no conscience, absolutely no sense of decency, absolutely no sense of honor…” – by THE GHOST BEHIND YOU
- – - – - – - – - –
Well said, GHOST, very well said.
Hey Terry -
What you took the time to tear apart, line by line, was my OPINION. Last I checked, even with “The One” in office, I was still allowed to speak my mind freely.
You have no business trying to tell me how my opinion is wrong. As I have no right to do so in return.
You are NOT, nor will you EVER be, my AUTHORITY. Even my husband knows that the only authority to which I accept disapproval of my opinion would be that of God Himself.
What I don’t understand is why you don’t go somewhere where your opinion is appreciated and championed? Surely there are plenty of sites that would find you a kindred spirit.
You must be a terribly lonely soul to enjoy coming back here over and over again. And I’m betting somewhere in your past you were taught to treat others in such the manner in which you treat people here on Big Hollywood. Memories of an overbearing mother or father yelling at you nose to nose, telling you that you are worthless perhaps? For that, my heart goes out to you. I’ve met a lot of damaged people in my life who always seem so ready for a fight. For that you should seek therapy.
Don’t go away mad though Terry, just go away.
Christopher:
“I was under the impression the US did not recognize dual citizenship i.e. when you take your oath of citizenship you have to renounce your ties to any foreing government or potentate (something like that)”
Actually, that is not so. We do recognize dual citizenship.
That doesn’t mean that Terry is correct, just that we allow it.
That being said, I am working on his long-overdue debunking on this thread as we speak.
P.S.
The Amazing Turtle? I’m flattered.
Donna V. – January 29th, 2009 at 6:07 pm
Hey, Terry, look at what George Washington, the Father of Our Country, said about the J33ws:
May the Children of the Stock of Abraham, who dwell in this land, continue to merit and enjoy the good will of the other Inhabitants; while every one shall sit under his own vine and fig tree, and there shall be none to make him afraid.
=====
Note, he didn’t say US tax payers should be enslaved and make themselves targets by propping up a fascist homeland for said people. What you say has no bearing at all on the phoney UN creation of “Israel.”
He also warned about foreign entanglements.
So, who else gets a US taxpayer subsidized homeland? Where is the homeland exclusively for Whites that is paid for by US tax payers?
My Awesome Mix Tape #6:
Your bit of hyperbole, while perhaps right at heart, has forced me to side with Terry a SECOND time today! This is not an insult I will take quietly.
“What you took the time to tear apart, line by line, was my OPINION.”
(well, you are going to HATE what I’m going to do, aren’t you? Well, Too damned bad!)
And you THINK that is wrong or illegal? WTF does it look like I DID to some previous posters? THE EXACT SAME THING! And with DAMN good reason, as it is at the heart of all political debate!
“Last I checked, even with “The One” in office, I was still allowed to speak my mind freely.”
Yes. However, if you think the fact that you are free to do so somehow PREVENTS someone else -be it me or our resident Stormfronter- from doing likewise, EVEN by destroying or debunking your precious opinion, then you have NO grasp WHATSOEVER of the First Amendment!
“You have no business trying to tell me how my opinion is wrong.”
No, he does not. But only because he would be wrong, NOT because he cannot try. Like I said, that is the heart of debate (particularly on politics) and it is with no small amount of sadness that he probably has more right to spew his drivel then YOU do to butcher the Constitution in a half-arsed attempt to stop him!
“As I have no right to do so in return.”
Yes you do. What the HELL do you think you have been doing anyway? All is fair in love and war.
“You are NOT, nor will you EVER be, my AUTHORITY.”
I have to agree with this.
“Even my husband knows that the only authority to which I accept disapproval of my opinion would be that of God Himself.”
In that case, you will be forced to get God on the line and have a discussion about pesky little things called “FACTS” that you may have heard of; because they can instantly destroy and discredit your opinion (for instance, on the character and text of the Constitution and the First Amendment).
“What I don’t understand is why you don’t go somewhere where your opinion is appreciated and championed? Surely there are plenty of sites that would find you a kindred spirit.”
Seconded.
“You must be a terribly lonely soul to enjoy coming back here over and over again. And I’m betting somewhere in your past you were taught to treat others in such the manner in which you treat people here on Big Hollywood. Memories of an overbearing mother or father yelling at you nose to nose, telling you that you are worthless perhaps? For that, my heart goes out to you. I’ve met a lot of damaged people in my life who always seem so ready for a fight. For that you should seek therapy.”
I cannot know what “Terry” went through, but I can say that he or she should seek help.
“Don’t go away mad though Terry, just go away.”
Seconded.
That being said, while Ia greed with your condemnation of Terry, I cannot abide for a mutilation of the Constitution on the altar of protecting ANYONE’S opinions. If you try that again, I will be forced to do this again.
Good night.
Thank you for your sacrifice and service, Sargeant. I appreciate you more than you will ever know.
Sgt. Welch:
I have read this entire thread and found that although the resident trolls make impassioned attempts to demean you and your post, none has lifted a claw to discredit, debunk, or even examine the veracity of the Hollywood/HBO clips you’ve provided. They are smug, allowing the lies that bolster their polemic to stand in their minds unchallenged.
You are not the liar.
The rights given to us by God, codified in our Constitution, can only be exercised and enjoyed by us so long as the American Armed Service Member is willing to give his life for them. Period.
God Bless You. Thank you for your service.
Welsh, just like not all Marines are heartless baby killers, not all of us American citizens are mindless zombies that believe everything the man on TV says. For those of us who believed in you and wanted you to succeed, there were plenty of non-traditional outlets to get our news.
Hollywood might portray you as the villain and Democrats might portray you as “victims” needed to be saved from Evil George W. But, at least half of the country had your back. I will leave it to you to figure out which half that was.
Sgt. Welsh…it’s not only people in fly-over country, or little town America who respects and appreciates you guys. It’s even me…a big city girl from NYC who thinks you guys are the best and bravest America has. 100 idiot college professors (or 100 reporters or 100 actors) aren’t worth 1 U.S. soldier. Because a soldier means everything to us. The professors/reporters/actors may not understand this, because their narcissism gets in the way. But you ARE the good guys. And it hurts me that those pissants hurt you.
God BLESS you for what you did and what you do and for your code of honor. I am in awe and so thankful that words can’t even express it. I love you all.
Sgt Welsh, thank you & your fellow men & women in arms for your service. What you did will never be forgotten. Don’t let those fools from La La Land speak for an entire country. There are millions of us who support you & what you have done. We always have & we always will. From the bottom of my heart, I thank you for protecting our way of life, and most importantly, protecting our freedom.
http://judgeright.vox.com/library/post/lying-without-lies-kills-america.html
Sgt. Welsh;
God bless you man and all those who’ve paid the price America takes for granted. Welcome to the war at home. It is the war of ideals. Please see this video to understand the Liberal mind. It really is a tragic comedy or a trainwreck in slow motion.
http://judgeright.vox.com/library/video/6a00e398d7a95b000300f48cf1ce0c0003.html
Terry, The Almighty Turtle or which ever talking head you are at the moment:
You dear sir or madame also need to seek therapy and/or return to whatever meds you have decided are no longer necessary.
Most important fact or opinion (your choice) I will leave you with is this: GET A LIFE.
My Awesome Mix Tape #6:
That DOES IT! Obviously, you fail to notice the fact that I am opposed to Terry at every turn, that I have debunked him in other threads (look at the last 24 thread, for example) and that I have just spend quite some time typing up a massive rebuttal and debunking of him on this thread.
But no, you insult me here. and that is something I will NOT tolerate, especially from a hypocritical and foolish person such as yourself.
“Terry, The Almighty Turtle or which ever talking head you are at the moment:”
Oh, it is the Almighty Turtle, always has been. I have NEVER been Terry or any one of his marching band.
“You dear sir or madame also need to seek therapy and/or return to whatever meds you have decided are no longer necessary.”
And you, Madame, need to learn to read, learn to use rational thought, learn to identify authors by their prose, to learn the Constitution, and to learn to not put your foot in your mouth. The fact is that I have disproved your point grudgingly before, but this personal attack is not one I will tolerate.
“Most important fact or opinion (your choice) I will leave you with is this: GET A LIFE.”
I do have one, believe it or not. It may be slightly off-time due to my illness this week, but I do have one.
But the most important fact I demand of you is an apology for this false accusation.
Mr. Blifil:
“Utter bs.”
Please do not be so hard on yourself. “And I dare you to post some links that aren’t funded by the moonies to attempt to substantiate your baseless drivel. ”
Hardly any more baseless then your drivel, and- before I give you any links at all, I want you to give me a clear definition of a source that is properly “pure” for you. Because I won’t go around putting up half a dozen links trying to appease your vague qualifier when I can ask you to do so first.
I sincerely ask for you to do so.
“In what way tied?” Well, he provided money, weapons, and intel for what are the equivalent of regional corporate offices for Al-Qaeda, before and after 9/11. “The bin Laden corporation had poured cement for them at one point?”
No.
“Because of “several groups” we sent thousands of our troops into harm’s way in a hornet’s nest?”
Um, yes, and because of the ceasefire violations, and the WMD, and various other issues.
“Even if a crazy person who accidentally flushed his Lithium down the toilet were to believe that “several groupsd” existed, that person will still conclude that Saddam had nothing to do with either planning or financing the attacks of 9/11.”
So, since Germany had nothing to do with the planning or financing of Pearl Harbor, it was unjust of the US to seize German assets in country (even before the German declaration of war a few days later)? No. It is called “co-belligerence”, and is an alliance in all but name. And the fact is that, in this era of asymmetric war, can we afford to NOT retaliate against our foe’s co-belligerents?
“I’m glad you’re earning your think tank sandwich coupons”
Odd, I’m not. Do you know where I can get some?
“but please don’t insult our intelligence with such patently false bilge.”
If I’m insulting your intelligence, it ain’t because I’m making things up.
“Oh and by now you’ve had time to “remember” the group from Yemen.”
Which brings me to a rather embarrassing point: it was not Yemeni, but Bahraini, the Army of Muhammad, tied to Zawahiri and Egyptian Islamic Jihad- a group allied with Al-Qaeda proper.
“I’ll even give you time to look ‘em up on teh Googlez.”
Sorry, I don’t have “Googlez.”, and most of the time between your posting and this one was because I spent a great deal of time needling Terry on this issue.
“I can’t wait to hear about how your dog ate the link.”
Like I said, I refuse to give you a link until you provide an example of a source you consider “Pure” enough to take seriously. I get how this goes; you toss back the Blog entry as being unproffesional and biased, the formal report as being fake and bought, and everything else as being cooked up, so that you can laugh about how “skimpy” my sources are.
Sorry, ain’t gonna work. If you are honest, you will give an example, and the onus is on ME to provide or be humiliated. Or, you will uncloak your transparent plan and claim this is a patently fake attempt to dodge the question blahblahblah, and then you will mock me for not providing a source for you to finesse your way around to discredit. If you are going to do that, then I see no reason to waste my time or effort. So give an example or be done with it.
“Oh and the documents professing sales of Yellowcake from Niger? Forgeries. Here’s some “research” that will satisfy your scholarly mind:”
“The I.A.E.A. was able to review correspondence coming from various bodies of the government of Niger and to compare the form, format, contents and signature of that correspondence with those of the alleged procurement-related documentation. Based on thorough analysis, the I.A.E.A. has concluded, with the concurrence of outside experts, that these documents, which formed the basis for the reports of recent uranium transaction between Iraq and Niger, are in fact not authentic. We have therefore concluded that these specific allegations are unfounded.””
I greatly appreciate you providing the source, but you are missing the main reason: The reason the Niger issue is important is not because Niger actually sold it to Saddam (as you correctly point out, they put the kibbosh on that sale) but because Saddam tried to get it in the first place, as stated by Resolution 687 under Article C, Section 12.
http://www.fas.org/news/un/iraq/sres/sres0687.htm
As such, Saddam violated the ceasefire he swore to uphold. The fact that he failed is but a detail.
“Thanks for playing our game.”
You are welcome.
Welsh:Thanks for serving and welcome home. I’m from the South which has always provided a disproportionate share of good soldiers to defend this nation. You have heard good soldiers say many times that they fight for the right of libs and losers to demonstrate against them. I disagree. The election of Obama and a leftist congress should tell you and me that “it’s over”. The America that you and I grew-up in and read about is dead. Good soldiers should get out of the service now. I was treated like crap for serving in Vietnam and my first cousin Jimmy Martin died in Somalia because Clinton refused armor and firepower. To sacrifice for your country,family and buddies is good. To offer your life for losers like the majority who voted for the “messiah” is a wasted life. Afghanastan and Irag will revert to radical islam just as Vietnam reverted to communism which means that all of our young, brave men died for nothing. Take care of your family and let the Obama hord wreak their destruction. Democratic republics have never lasted much over 200 years so we have been living on borrowed time anyway.
I and my family Appreciate the service and sacrifice of the Military
we also Understand fully the need to be in IRAQ
I have been called a Warmonger and much worse because I vocally support our military and the operations in Iraq and Afghanistan
we also boycott actors actresses and singers who vocally appose our military and the war’s my motto SHUT UP AND DANCE HOLLYWOOD
I proudly wear a Lanyard at work with the 101st Airborne on it
and sing the praises of our military
and thank god everyday for what you do
Proud and grateful Army Mom
Poor clueless Terry asks: Where is the homeland exclusively for Whites that is paid for by US tax payers?
Terry, once again you display your boundless ignorance. Half of the Jews in Israel are not descended from European Jews. There are black Jews in Israel.
Perhaps you should try reading something besides Stormfront propaganda, the writings of David Duke and whatever garbage you fill your head with for a change.
And of course Washington wasn’t talking about Israel, a country that did not exist at the time (duh). He was welcoming the Jews to this country. Jew hatred is unAmerican.
Thank you and God bless you. That goes out to EVERYONE who put on a uniform to protect our way of life.
[...] can see this frustration over on this post at Big Hollywood. This marine is angry, and particularly so because Hollywood does think that it can picture life [...]
Good job Sergeant Welsh, enjoyed reading your post. After returning in 2006 from Iraq, I had many of the same feelings and still do. Those feelings were mostly against the liberals of the country, but also many conservatives that had lost faith because the fight became to hard and the lies of the MSM/Liberals. Hopefully, young Marines, Soldiers and other military members like yourself, wind up in Hollywood and Politics to change the way this country will view the war in the future.
Semper Gumby,
GySgt Ron Landers (USMC ret, retread 2005-2006)
Sgt. Welsh,
Thank-you for your service AND for speaking up.
God Bless.
Great post Sergeant Welsh, really enjoyed reading it. After returning from Iraq in 2006, I had many of the same feelings and still do. The way most of the liberals and even many conservatives had lost faith in the fight made me angry. Especially, since their discouragement was based on lies or distortions from the MSM and leftists. Americans have grown to expect small numbers of casualties and short conflicts without realizing this is a long war that won’t end with the Afghanistan and Iraq Campaigns. Hopefully, Marines and other service members like yourself will go to Hollywood or into Politics, so that in the future this war and its veterans will be remembered for the honorable service rendered. Semper Gumby from an old Jarhead.
GySgt Ron Landers (USMC ret, recalled 2005-2006)
D*mn, thought 1st comment did not get posted. Confounded computer thingy.
[...] The soldier’s story is also referenced here [...]
Sir, I am not American, I live in Canada, but I have family in the states, and even if I didn’t I still want to thank you. Thank you. For your sacrifices and hardships, I’m sorry that your media and the elites of your country denigrate the lives given in pursuit of a noble objective.
For what it is worth, I thank you sincerely, and I wish you God’s blessings.
God Bless
LegioN aka Nic
Hollywood is full of a bunch of PANSY’s!
The United States Military is the BEST in the world. Thank you for your service and sacrifice. You fight for us and WE WILL FIGHT FOR YOU!
Sgt welsh thank-you for your service.The liberal left whose constitutional rights you defend do not want a constitution anymore and think it outdated. We appreciate you and all that serve. I do not watch regular tv nor do I spend any money on movies or anything that has to do with Hollywood. There are those of us who are there for you in whatever you need.
Corky:
“My bet is there is no Pat Buchanan, Lew Rockwell, Ron Paul conservatives here”
Ah, so you WEREN’T joking. Oh well. Sadly, you are wrong however, there are plenty of fans of the aforementioned idiots, which you would know if you READ anything.
“Just disgusting warmongering Neocon types”
Ah yes, the cartoonish demonetization. Do you even know ANYTHING about Neocons like myself? And, sadly, you are mistaken when you mention that we are the only ones on here, as you and your ilk can attest to.
“who belong on Huffington Post!”
Have you ever READ the Huffington Post, knave?
If anything, YOU and YOUR ILK deserve to go there.
And don’t fail to notice the absolute lack of facts and reason here!
Sgt. Welsh,
Take heart, not everyone in the country believes the lunacy alternate-reality that spews forth from the morally bankrupt monstrosity that calls itself Hollywood. I would venture to say that at least 60 million people in this country (those who voted for McCain/Palin) are smart enough to see through the lies and propaganda. The other 69 million (who voted for Obama — well, the number is slightly less than that, since there were lots of people who voted dozens of times in states such as Ohio, thanks to their Secretary of State) yes, have sadly succumbed to the never-ending stream of brainwashing that spews forth from 95% of movies and television.
Hollywood is out of sync with the real America, who knows up from down, right from wrong, and good from bad. So take heart. Unfortunately, the evil ones (Hollywood) are rich and powerful. Why? Because we PAY MONEY for their garbage. I have not been to a movie in years, and I have not watched any television station other than Fox News (plus Nancy Grace, plus my guilty indulgence of reality shows on Bravo) in years. It disgusts me and makes me sick to see how the left has co-opted and taken control of these outlets and turned them into America-hating propaganda machines. They only succeed in doing so because of a spiritual vacuum which exists in this once-great nation of ours, where the Christian foundations of our country have been chipped away at and removed, to be replaced by the Left’s socialist/communist/humanistic/morally bankrupt Religion of the Left.
Take heart, all is not lost. GOD knows what the American nation and its honorable military have done to advance HIS kingdom on earth. MANY people in America also know. We live in a hostile environment at this time because Satan is always attempting to attack God and God’s creation. Satan never rests nor sleeps. Take heart. The final victory belongs to GOD. God Bless You and your brethren in the military for keeping us safe and keeping the world safe. I am a patriotic American who loves this country deeply and am infuriated at the Godless evil whores who are currently in positions of power in this country. Take heart. You have done well. America did well. George W. Bush did well. You and he deserve all honor and gratitude. Not everyone is taking in by the Hollywood propaganda scam.
With thanks and Gratitude for your sacrifices,
Laura
In reply to the inane comment written by”
Terry – January 29th, 2009 at 1:11 pm
“I’ve noticed a lot of you who speak glowingly of the mission in Iraq and about how Saddam was “bad” are on the wrong side of the Israel-Palestinian issue. You don’t seem to mind Israel’s oppression of the Palestinians…and that we pay tons of money to SUPPORT (and one of the main reasons we are hated in the world.) In short, your POV is being programmed by the Zionists and Israel. Mine is consistent. America first, not Israel.”
FACT: Our support of Israel, along with the financial aid we provide Egypt and Jordan IS putting America First.
Fact: The US is the largest provider of Financial Foreign Aid to Egypt and Jordan.
Fact: We provide this financial aid to Jordan & Egypt contingent upon both countries engaging in peaceful relations with Israel. We do so in order to help stabilize the Middle East, which is in the best interest of America, Canada, and Europe.
Fact: Supporting Israel IS Putting AMERICA FIRST!!!
***Israeli Ingenuity Saves U.S. Lives
The U.S.-Israel relationship has evolved into a mutually beneficial alliance which has yielded military technologies, helping to protect American and Israeli lives.
*** The Arrow, a missile defense system that is currently deployed in Israel & it is the most important of the technologies. Jointly developed by the US & Israel it is the ONLY operational system that has consistently proven that one missile can shoot down another at high altitude and speed.
***Strategic cooperation has made important Israeli military innovations available to the United States, which uses them in real combat.
Examples:
***The Israeli-developed Hunter unmanned arial vehicles gather critical intell& kill terrorists—all without endangering pilots.
***The Litening targeting pod, an Israeli-made system with infrared sensors that identifies ground targets and enables pilots to fly at night and in bad weather. The Litening made it possible for American fighter pilots to deliver the munitions that killed al-Qaeda’s leader in Iraq, Abu Musab al-Zarqawi.
***U.S. armored personnel carriers are protected by Israeli-developed reactive armor tiles, which explode outward upon impact, diffusing the force of incoming fire. So far, more than 800 U.S. troops have avoided injury or death as a result of the reactive tiles.
***The US & Israel continue to work together to reduce the threat of IED’s, which have been responsible for the majority of U.S. casualties in Iraq and now Afghanistan.
*** Israel regularly shares intel on American adversaries that has proven extremely useful for the United States.
No other U.S. ally has developed such extensive intel on Middle Eastern regimes as Israel has been forced to do for 60 years, and no other nation has shared such intelligence with the United States more frequently than has Israel.
***The US & Israel cooperate on Homeland Security.
-Israel is one of five countries participating in the U.S. Counterterrorism Technical Support Working Group, whose experts collaborate to develop anti-terrorism technology.
-American law enforcement agencies are increasingly studying Israel’s battle against terrorism.
-Israel frequently hosts delegations of American police chiefs, sheriffs and emergency responders who have returned and implemented what they learned from Israeli security forces to prevent terrorist attacks such as suicide bombings.
FACT: Supporting Israel is putting AMERICA FIRST.
For those who seemed confused as to the definition of anti-semite:
An anti semite is someone who hates/persecutes/disciminates AGAINST Jews. Antisemitism is characterized by a combination of religious, racial, cultural and ethnic biases towards/about Jews.
Anti semitism is NOT defined as being hated BY Jews.
Well said Sgt Welsh. OOOORAH!
Thank you for your service and your sacrifice. Thank you to the men and women of the United States Military who serve their country with honor and dignity.
Duty. Country. Honor.
Duty, Honor, Country: Those three hallowed words reverently dictate what you ought to be, what you can be, what you will be. They are your rallying points: to build courage when courage seems to fail; to regain faith when there seems to be little cause for faith; to create hope when hope becomes forlorn.
Sgt Welsh: you and your men in Iraq exemplified those words during your tour of duty, as do all the men and women of the United States Military whereever they serve.
God Bless America.
God Bless The United States Military.
God Bless the families of those who serve now, have served, and will serve in the future.
In reply to the inane comment written by”
Terry – January 29th, 2009 at 1:11 pm
“I’ve noticed a lot of you who speak glowingly of the mission in Iraq and about how Saddam was “bad” are on the wrong side of the Israel-Palestinian issue. You don’t seem to mind Israel’s oppression of the Palestinians…and that we pay tons of money to SUPPORT (and one of the main reasons we are hated in the world.) In short, your POV is being programmed by the Zionists and Israel. Mine is consistent. America first, not Israel.”
FACT: Our support of Israel, along with the financial aid we provide Egypt and Jordan IS putting America First.
Fact: The US is the largest provider of Financial Foreign Aid to Egypt and Jordan.
Fact: We provide this financial aid to Jordan & Egypt contingent upon both countries engaging in peaceful relations with Israel. We do so in order to help stabilize the Middle East, which is in the best interest of America, Canada, and Europe.
Fact: Supporting Israel IS Putting AMERICA FIRST!!!
***Israeli Ingenuity Saves U.S. Lives
The U.S.-Israel relationship has evolved into a mutually beneficial alliance which has yielded military technologies, helping to protect American and Israeli lives.
*** The Arrow, a missile defense system that is currently deployed in Israel & it is the most important of the technologies. Jointly developed by the US & Israel it is the ONLY operational system that has consistently proven that one missile can shoot down another at high altitude and speed.
***Strategic cooperation has made important Israeli military innovations available to the United States, which uses them in real combat.
Examples:
***The Israeli-developed Hunter unmanned arial vehicles gather critical intell& kill terrorists—all without endangering pilots.
***The Litening targeting pod, an Israeli-made system with infrared sensors that identifies ground targets and enables pilots to fly at night and in bad weather. The Litening made it possible for American fighter pilots to deliver the munitions that killed al-Qaeda’s leader in Iraq, Abu Musab al-Zarqawi.
***U.S. armored personnel carriers are protected by Israeli-developed reactive armor tiles, which explode outward upon impact, diffusing the force of incoming fire. So far, more than 800 U.S. troops have avoided injury or death as a result of the reactive tiles.
***The US & Israel continue to work together to reduce the threat of IED’s, which have been responsible for the majority of U.S. casualties in Iraq and now Afghanistan.
*** Israel regularly shares intel on American adversaries that has proven extremely useful for the United States.
No other U.S. ally has developed such extensive intel on Middle Eastern regimes as Israel has been forced to do for 60 years, and no other nation has shared such intelligence with the United States more frequently than has Israel.
***The US & Israel cooperate on Homeland Security.
-Israel is one of five countries participating in the U.S. Counterterrorism Technical Support Working Group, whose experts collaborate to develop anti-terrorism technology.
-American law enforcement agencies are increasingly studying Israel’s battle against terrorism.
-Israel frequently hosts delegations of American police chiefs, sheriffs and emergency responders who have returned and implemented what they learned from Israeli security forces to prevent terrorist attacks such as suicide bombings.
FACT: Supporting Israel is putting AMERICA FIRST.
For those who seemed confused as to the definition of anti-semite:
An anti semite is someone who hates/persecutes/disciminates AGAINST Jews. Antisemitism is characterized by a combination of religious, racial, cultural and ethnic biases towards/about Jews.
Anti semitism is NOT defined as being hated BY Jews.
It is simply not true that people in Hollywood or Americans anywhere else do not have great respect for the dedication and sacrifice of the American soldiers who have risked their lives in Iraq and elsewhere. But, the pride most Americans feel for their men in combat is irrelevant to the issue of whether Iraq has been a disaster for America, which it has.
Sgt. Welsh,
I thank you for your service and many of us, as you can see, do our best to honor that service in every way we possibly can. These Leftist cupcakes who show up here KNOW in their hearts that American soldiers and Marines and airmen wowed the world with the Victory in Iraq – they had all but stuck a fork in you guys and you showed em what American troops are made of.
America is proud of you, don’t ever forget that. There will be more than chickens coming home to roost for the likes of Reid, Obama, Pelosi, Murtha and McDermott.
Sgt Walsh
Thank you for your service. The only film I’ve seen on your list was valley of elah and it wasn’t for me.
It’s odd, maybe even ironic, that you would choose a deliberately out of context quote from Fox News to make your case against Hollywood feeding the public “wasteful, depressing, and horribly fabricated stories.” Funny enough, Obama had said this in the context of not having enough troops on the ground so that we could do MORE than just air-raids.
Unfortunately, the good doesn’t outweigh the bad. Bad news always sells, and when bad is as bad as Abu Ghraib, etc, it will outweigh the story of giving candy to kids anyday. The fact that bad news sells, has nothing to do with hollywood, and everything to do with how we, as a society, consume news.
[...] A comment on Sgt. Welsh’s “Big Hollywood” post yesterday: [...]
Sgt. Welsh, Thank YOU for your service!
I love all of this “Obama was taken out of context” crap!
He meant what he said, he meant that our military was air-raiding villagers in the middle of the night..PERIOD and he meant every word given his background (education, mentors, environment, mother – all whacked out leftist), his ignorance (more conventional troops in Afghanistan don’t automatically = success, but they do give the Taliban a lot of targets and they do ironically, create a slush fund for spending a lot more $$$$, something liberals always rails against, that is military spending, but the O-man looks like he’s gonna ramp up dramatically), special forces are much more effective in Afghanistan, but you can’t produce them overnight, do you actually think that lefty Obama would create more SF? Never, everything he’s against, that is, manly potentially mean stuff, he’s basically as limp as his politics and fellow weak-kneed liberals, by the way, are there any straight male liberals/demcrats? Seems to me they’re all women with issues (i.e. ugly), gay/tranny/freaks, emo-men/boy metro types and various and sundry freaks, but I digress
[...] A comment on Sgt. Welsh’s “Big Hollywood” post yesterday: [...]
My nephew did 2 tours, he was in the Army. I believe inhis intergrity and yours! Thank you for your service and God Bless all those that serve in the Armed Forces.
Veterans’ Day 2003
© By Ruth E. Longwell
Terrorism
When does it end
So everyone can start to mend
Today is Veterans’ Day
Watching Good Morning America
Four soldiers dead
Their wives
Each with new babies
That will never meet their dads
Tears flowed
When parts of a letter was read
Written by a soldier Jesse Givens
Before he died
To his family
Some parts said to his wife
After you tuck in Toad and Bean
Give them hugs and kisses for me
Go outside
Look at the stars
And count them
Don’t forget to smile
For all Veterans
Go outside
Look at the stars
Count them
And smile
Our thanks!
Almighty Turtle,
If the US wants to win in Afghanistan, they have to stop air raiding villages and killing civilians. It is an indisputable fact that NATO and its allies are now killing more civilians in Afghanistan than the insurgents are. President Obama was right. Slaughtering Afghans at innocent wedding parties is unacceptable.
I never served this country, I dont pretend to know what you guys went through. I may be the only one but I dont believe Hollywood. I dont believe Obama and I dont believe there are any objective reporters left.
Remember this, and tell your firends:
Those people who attack you. They use your values and moral code against you. They have always dont this to doers. If they can make you feel guilty for doing then they think they can conrol you.
Its a battle as old as time and I am on your side. I believed in your cause.
[...] A comment on Sgt. Welsh’s “Big Hollywood” post yesterday: [...]
You have no idea what the fuck you are talking about.
You must be logged in to post a comment.