10,000 Violent Women and one Screenwriter, Part III
by Robert J. AvrechNote: Links to the previous chapters are found at the bottom of this post.
In which we meet Eden, a pleasant and amiable mother, lover of classical American literature with a special affection for Jane Austen. Our fine lady is also an accomplished former drug addict, stripper, prostitute and for an extra added attraction, a cold-blooded murderess.
Eden groans in frustration as she awkwardly applies her make-up.
Her fingers shake as she pulls taut her eyelid, tries to draw the eye-liner in a reasonably straight line.
“I been home so long I’ve forgotten how to put on war paint. I should’ve done this before, but time got away from me.”
Home: the inmates in this women’s facility refer to prison as home.
“I appreciate you letting me see your room.”
“Cell, it’s a cell, Mr. Av-e… Av-e-re-re.. uhh, how do you pronounce it?”
“Robert.”
Eden nods, tosses her white-blond hair. A trustee, Eden has been chosen by the Prison Supervisor—Warden is so old Hollywood—to show me her cell and serve as guide to the pet program, the subject matter of the film I’ve been hired to write by Show Time.
I immediately understand the choice. Eden is, um, unique. In a population of several thousand female prisoners who are violent, angry, sullen, clinically depressed, grossly overweight, flat-out psychotic, frighteningly masculine, and almost all tattooed like pagan priestesses, Eden is tall, lithe and pleasantly feminine—a surprising quality that should not be a surprising quality in a female prison.
Imagine one of those Roger Corman B movies, a woman’s prison film of the mid-seventies where all the women are unnaturally beautiful, and you’ve got a pretty good idea of what Eden looks like. Tall and wispy blond with haunting gray-green eyes, Eden has the look of innocence and vulnerability that is a magnet for men.
Which Eden took full advantage of when she set up the fatal ambush.
Eden’s only physical defect is a minor limp that reminds me of Piper Laurie in The Hustler.
As for her psychic defects: endless and of course appalling.
“Eden, it’s okay.”
She gazes at me, at my reflection in the tin mirror, taking my measure. It’s a prison look, a visual raking over that is deeply unnerving. Inmates live or die by their ability to judge others correctly.
“Really,” I tell her, “there’s no need. You look just fine without it.”
“You’re lying. Men lie.”
“Huh?”
“You heard.”
“Eden, I do not lie.”
“What-ever.”
Eden continues fumbling her make-up. The truth is Eden looks like she’s about to cry as she attempts to get the eye-liner to do what she wants it to do.
“I haven’t done this for like who knows how long,” she confesses. “If I did, the rug munchers would figure I’m up for Mexico and go to town on me.”
“Eden, lose the make-up. We’re wasting time.” I no longer ask, I tell. I am all business now, a screenwriter and producer on a tight schedule.
Heaving a huge sigh of relief, Eden snaps up a Kleenex, pumps thick white gel on the tissue, smears it on her face, removes the make-up.
She studies her naked face in the mirror for a long moment.
“That’s me.”
Eden looks better now, like a sturdy milk-maid in a Soviet style social realist painting, not like the former stripper, whore, junkie, cold-blooded murderess she is.
The walls of the cell are dull yellow cinder block. There is one narrow window, way up high; it has bars on it, and the pane is two inches thick, bullet proof plastic. There is a shiny steel toilet in the corner. Three paces in one direction, two paces in the other.
Eden’s private world.
I remind myself that the man she murdered has no physical world.
Flashback:
When I tell my wife, Karen, about the project, Within These Walls, she hits me with a level gaze—eyes like chips of coal:
“Not a good idea, Robert. Remember all the time in Sing-Sing doing research for that other script—it was not a healthy experience.”
Your faithful screenwriter shrugs, utterly clueless:
“This is a woman’s prison, how bad can it be? Besides, I am not going to turn down the chance to work with Ellen Burstyn.”
Karen looks at me and half-smiles, tolerantly but with—I sincerely hope—affection.
Evil exists; and face to face, it is a shock to the soul.
The love of my life can foresee the psychological black cloud that is fated to haunt me after conducting my prison research.
There is a reason I’ve been in love with my wife since we were nine-years old. She’s much smarter and level-headed than yours truly.
End Flashback:
There are a dozen stuffed teddy bears on Eden’s bunk. Snapshots of three children are taped to the wall right next to her pillows.
“Wanna meet my kids?”
“Love to.”
She points to an angelic looking little black girl, about five years old.
“That’s Keesha.”
Eden’s finger trails along to a photo of a second little girl. She’s got olive skin, high cheekbones and jet-black hair that trails all the way down her spine.
“This is Orenda, her daddy was an Injun. Apache. Met him on a drunk in Tucson. Orenda. She’s eight in this picture.”
“Beautiful name, what’s it mean?”
“I think it means magical power, that’s what the Injun told me, but he was like such a liar, so who knows.”
Eden moves on to the next photo.
“And this is Cody, my big boy.”
Eden rests her forehead on the wall, on a photo of a brooding teenage boy with a cigarette dangling from his lips. Cody looks, well, like trouble. His hair is dyed the color of Pepto Bismol, ink already disfigures his young skin, already there are unfortunate piercings in his nose, his ears, and G-d knows where else. He wears a T-shirt that proclaims: Dead Kennedys Live.
What does that mean?
Three children, three separate fathers.
“They don’t visit me, my kids, I mean.”
“I’m sorry.”
Eden shrugs.
“Don’t even know what they look like now. These picture are so old.”
I say nothing.
”I write them letters, every week. I tell them what I’m thinking, what I’m studying. I tell them how I’ve repented, how I’ve found Jesus.”
“Do they ever write back?”
She just looks at me.
Eden has been busy in prison for the past twelve years. She’s earned her high school degree and she’s working towards her college sheepskin.
“It’s hard,” she admits. “I got a lot of catching up to do. Basically, I was like illiterate, dropped out of school in tenth grade and started dancing.”
Eden is not talking about ballet.
“Tenth grade?”
“I developed early.”
“They didn’t ask for proof of age?”
Eden studies me for a long moment. I’m getting used to the women here looking at me as if I’m the dumbest man in all creation.
She likes English literature. The great books are all here: Moby Dick, The Scarlet Letter, Tristram Shandy, Middlemarch, and my eyes rest on my late son Ariel’s ZT’L very favorite novel of all time: Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice.
I leaf through the paperback. The spine is cracked, and Eden’s notes are written in a childish, cramped hand in the margins. Eden has highlighted almost every line in the book.
I ask Eden what she likes best about Pride and Prejudice. She ponders a long moment. We exit her cell and make our way to the shed where the inmates train the dogs.
Eden is silent, thoughtful, as we make our way across the yard.
Cindy the CO accompanies us for I am not permitted to go anywhere in the prison unless I am accompanied by a CO.
Cindy, as sharp as they come, immediately picks up on Eden’s pensive mood. Cindy reaches over and flicks a residue of make-up remover off Eden’s chin. Eden doesn’t thank Cindy and Cindy doesn’t expect a thanks. Inmate and CO have a tacit communication that is as powerful as I have ever seen. It’s a fragile relationship, a delicate balancing act that seesaws back and forth a hundred times a day.
Just as we reach the shed where the pet program is situated, Eden halts in her tracks:
“The thing I like about Pride and Prejudice, the thing I like best is how the men and women talk to each other with all this respect. It’s like they get angry and stuff, but they don’t cuss and go at each other serious-like. Men and women in the book, it’s kinda nice.”
To be continued…
To read Part I of this series, please click here.
To read Part II of this series, please click here.
Copyright © Robert J. Avrech







Subscribe via RSS
Got a Tip?
24 Comments
Bill:
In Cedars Sinai hosital here in Los Angeles, beautifully trained dogs are often brought into the children's cancer floor. It is just magical to see the immediate synergy between patient and dog.
Robert – something I was told once that always stuck with me – that life is nothing more than choices. Whatever we are at present – we got there through past choices.
I wonder if the recidivism rate is the same for women as it is for men…
Excellent read, as always. Looking forward to the next installment.
Bill:
I don’t know about the general recidivism rate for men and women. But I do know that prisoners who go through the dog training have the lowest recidivism rate of all inmates in the American penal system. The program started in women’s prisons and is now also in men’s prisons. I have not kept up with the stats.
K:
Thanks so much. Part IV next week.
What is this, some sort of fetish for women’s prisons? Seek help, Robert!
Robert – right after WW2 the VA had a study with about 50 or 100 men who were in for psych reasons. You can imagine some of their problems.
I think the study was at the VA facility on Wilshire Blvd (is that still there? Used to visit my uncle there in the 1950s) – but they gave half the group a dog or a cat to care for and the other half did not have an animal.
As you can imagine the half with the animals left (were deemed “cured”) far earlier than the other half…
Having an animal to care for is good for the soul I believe…
Coincides with the prison experience…
“Caged” with Eleanor Parker; still the best women’s prison film, hands down.
Red:
Glad you’re enjoying the series. There are tons of prisoner advocates and programs. Lost in the shuffle are the COs who, in my experience,are also prisoners of a sort. I have always felt that CO’s get a raw deal, in life and in the movies. I tried to correct this as much as I could under the constraints of story and genre.
Trent:
Thanks so much for your concern. My wife is a fine psychologist and I see her on a regular basis:-)
Jeff:
Good film. Later in the series I sit down with CO Cindy and give her a list of my 10 favorite prison movies. Stay tuned, then you can hammer me for my choice for very favorite women in prison flick.
BTW, have you seen Irene Dunne in Ann Vickers, 1933. She plays a prison reformer who says to inmate Helyn Eby-Rock: “We’ll have to get you off the snow—cold turkey.”
Not strictly a prison picture, but close.
Jonathan:
Thanks so much for the kind words. After I left prison I asked about the t-shirt and was told that the Dead Kennedys were a popular punk band. I decided not to interject my after-knowledge into the moment.
Repulsive name.
I’ll bet their music is not exactly Cole Porter.
Alice:
You’re very kind.
In Hollywood we never copy work by another writer, noooo, we’re just paying an homage.
I am really enjoying your writing. I was reading your old blog too, but thought I’d let you know I am enjoying this series.
Retro Hound:
Thanks so much for the generous words. Very glad you also read Seraphic Secret. It’s our home.
A. Obler:
I am deeply moved by your comment. I feel honored that Ariel’s, ZT’L, neshama, soul, and memory, have afforded you some measure of reflection and comfort. Karen and I sincerely hope that you will be comforted among the mourners of Zion.
Please do stay in touch.
Batya:
Great idea. I’ll contact you before our next trip. Thanks so much.
Sounds like Eden had a similar start to my sister – stripping in 10th grade, kids by four different fathers. My sister’s anger has been mostly directed inward, however, and while her life has been frequently self-destructive, she keeps struggling forward toward something better, for her and her kids. It hurts to see her fall so often, though. Reading this, I can’t help thinking, “there, but for the grace…”
Robert,
Great stuff, you have me looking forward to each Wed for the next installment. I have been a fan of prison films since I was a kid. In college I took Criminal Justice. The professor had us watch “The Glass House” with Vic Morrow and Alan Alda. He stated that it was the most accurate prison film he had seen (this was 1981). My impression of women in prison were the 70’s movies and that episode of “Charlies Angles”. Your writing made me feel I was standing next to you, see you on the 11th.
Julie:
It must be hard having such a troubled sibling. I can’t imagine how difficult it is for you. I also sincerely hope that your sister’s life gets better, and that her children emerge intact from such chaos
John:
I have never seen The Glass House, but I doubt that any movie can capture the true experience of prison. I spent time in Sing-Sing and this women's prison and I have to tell you, I have never been the same. Prison is hell.
Glad you're enjoying the series.
I wouldn’t say it’s difficult for me, so much; the hardest part is knowing that there’s nothing I can do to help her, beyond making sure that she knows she has a family who loves her. No, the difficulty is hers, but somehow no matter how rough things get, she always manages to muddle through. Her kids are really amazing; she’s been blessed in them. I just hope and pray that they’ll find their ways into adulthood without following too closely in her footsteps, but that remains yet to be seen.
Thanks again for this series, Robert.
[...] To read Part III, please click here. [...]
[...] To read Part III, please click here. [...]
You must be logged in to post a comment.