The Vault: An Exploration of the Gothic
by Matt PattersonPart 2 – In The Beginning
1965. Cafe Bizarre. Greenwich Village, New York City.
An unknown band takes the stage and begins to play. The electric viola weeps an unearthly, hypnotic lament, as the singer chants: “Not a ghost-bloodied country, all covered with sleep, where the black angel did weep…’”
–
Perhaps The Black Angel’s Death Song was just a little too bizarre for Cafe Bizarre. Perhaps the song’s rumored anti-communist message did no go down well in deep-red lower Manhattan. For whatever reason, The Velvet Underground are promptly fired from their first regular gig for playing the strange and dissonant tune they had been warned not to play.
But the Velvets had secured their future nonetheless: Andy Warhol was at Cafe Bizarre that night. He described the audience as “dazed and damaged” after the performance – Warhol loved it. He took them into his fold and became their manager, producer and sponsor. He helped them secure their first record contract; he painted the cover for the first album, The Velvet Underground & Nico.
It is (too) often said that, while their first record sold only a hundred copies, everyone who bought it started a band. Like most apocrypha, this is exaggeration which nonetheless contains a large truth, which is this – compared to their minimal chart success, The Velvets had a disproportionate impact on the sonic landscape of America. They single-handedly gave birth to what we call alternative rock, of which Goth is very much a subspecies. And The Black Angel’s Death Song may itself be the first piece of modern Goth.
Decades later, Iggy Pop would recall the effect The Velvets had had on him in the mid 1960’s. He was especially inspired by vocalist Lou Reed, who had once been a house song-writer for Pickwick Records: “Hey, he (Reed) can’t sing,” Iggy thought; “I can’t sing. Let’s all sing!” (I paraphrase here from memory an interview seen long ago.)
In Detroit on Halloween night 1967, Iggy debuted his band The Stooges. The performance, like all Stooges performances, was a slash and burn musical onslaught (more slash than burn – Iggy would make a name for himself by self mutilating on stage). In 1969, The Stooges recorded their first record – produced by The Velvet’s classically-trained violist John Cale. Like The Velvets, The Stooges would sell little, but inspire legions.
Meanwhile, back in New York, two teenagers in the sleepy suburb of Forest Hills, Queens had formed a garage band in 1966. Over the next eight years, this band would undergo many line-up and name changes. By 1974, they had decided on a monochrome look of jeans, t-shirts, and leather jackets, and settled on the nom de guerre The Ramones. Punk was born.
Musically, The Ramones were a throwback to pop from the 60’s – more Beach Boys than Velvet Underground. But their style was raw and visceral, and their delivery brutal – one, two, three, four and then a towering electric wave would wash over the audiences of Max’s Kansas City and CBGB in lower Manhattan, where The Ramones quickly ensconced and took residence.
Inspired by The Ramones (though they always took pains to deny it), across the pond, Johnny Rotten began to lead his merry band of anarchists to incandescent glory as The Sex Pistols in 1975. The Pistols made punk harder, more angry – they spat on audiences and each other. They terrorized journalists who dared interview them.
Nevertheless, The Pistols quickly garnered a small but devoted following, the core of which was known as the Bronby Contingent. Among them was a girl called Siouxie Sioux, and her friend, bass player Steven Severin.
There were other portents floating in the musical firmament in these years. David Bowie was riding to rock glory on the backs of Martian spiders; Alice Cooper was bringing horror show Vaudeville to Metal. A two-man combo called Suicide combined drum machines and primitive sythns with lyrical homages to ghosts and motorcycles, creating a template that would be copied over and over in the years to come.
All of these things combined and congealed, bubbling sometimes under the surface, sometimes simmering just on top, until 1976 when, like Frankenstein’s monster, a not-so-pretty amalgam of disparate limbs would finally take its first steps.
Alive! they cried, and called it Goth…
Next Time: 1976 – The Big Bang
Suggested Listening:
1) The Black Angel’s Death Song - The Velvet Underground
2) Venus In Furs - The Velvet Underground
3) 1969 – The Stooges
4) Judy Is A Punk - The Ramones
5) Anarchy In the U.K. – The Sex Pistols
6) Ghost Rider - Suicide
7) Keep Your Dreams - Suicide
Ziggy Stardust - David Bowie
9) The Black Angel’s Death Song - Vitamin String Quartet
(Author’s note: Look for the entire iMix of “The Vault: An Exploration of the Gothic – Part 2″ in iTunes)
Part one of this series can be read here.






Subscribe via RSS
Got a Tip?
31 Comments
Ugh, not this "Goth" crap again…
A crap culture, made up of weak-willed freak people and losers pure and simple.
Note from the author: The nucleus of Sex Pistols fans was of course the Bromley Contingent, not Bronby, as misspelled above. Thanks to eagle-eyed readers for the catch. Any further comments, suggestions, remonstrations, or adulations regarding "The Vault" can be directed to mpatterson.column@gmail.com.
http://conservathink.ning.com
Well, now I realize why I and millions of others didn't bother to listen to "The Velvet Underground". They're lousy. You can't understand a word they're saying and there's no tune. If the sloppy garbled words of "Black Angel…" are any example of their professionalism, it's a wonder those guys ever sold a single record, let alone 100. I am not impressed with them – but I am impressed with the intelligence of the audiences not wanting to buy a single record they made.
Had that album in college and peeled the banana sticker off the cover ruining it's collector value, but who knew. To me,VU was incredibly uneven. When they were good, they were extremely good. When they were bad, they were virtually unlistenable sounding like screeching chalk on a blackboard. Of all those you mention, David Jones (a.k.a. Bowie) had the most incredible talent. I saw his original tour when they played the Tower Theater in Upper Darby with the spiders show including Mick Ronson.
It was the first time I really experienced true theater combined with rock n' roll. . . what showmen.
heroin, prepunk music – eh.
Smashing Pumpkins – when they first started out in the 80's used to do a cover of Venus In Furs that was better than The Velvet Underground.
And finally –
Andy Warhoo musta been smokin' some good dope.
And
I heart Alice Cooper despite his perverse love for glam rockers like KISS – Hack Gasp.
I digress.
LOL
They spat on their audience and each other.
Must we pretend to like this?
Punk was for the young, dumb and angry… and anyone who says that is something they never were is a lying bastard.
There's a better word for this than Goth: Sh_t.
Are you only doing a series on Goth music, or can we expect others eventually? Industrial music has an interesting past, at least before it hit the late 80's-to-present phase of largely tiresome racket. You have Boyd Rice and his toying with aesthetic fascism and social Darwinism, the Neo-Folk offshoot, The Residents' bizarre story-telling, and electronic music experiments going back to the 60's.
The Cure's "Faith" is a must listen for anyone interested in Goth. Most people think of "Pornography" as their most gothic outing but I think "Faith" captures the anger and depression attendant with goth much more fully. "Pornography" was something else entirely, more dark and scary than aggressive and depressing.
I remember, as a young musician whose quest it was to become a great musician, just absolutely hating The Ramones, The Sex Pistols and all related punk music, because the bands sucked and the music sucked. In my simplistic way back then, I reduced it to, "Those guys can't even play their instruments!" There were usually a few spicy expletives thrown in for good measure.
My musical journey started with The Beatles as a kid, and Elvis Presley through my mom, who was a big Elvis fan. That grew through later bands like CCR, Jimi Hendrix Experience, Cream, CSN&Y, the Allman Brothers &c. Single albums that had a huge impact on me included Spirit in the Sky, Jesus Christ Superstar, Goodbye Yellow Brick Road, Billion Dollar Babies… and then I heard Europa from the Amigos album by Santana, and everything changed forever. John McLaughlin lead to Jan Hammer, Weather Report, Jaco pastorius, Larry Carlton. I was a closet fusion fan who played in pop rock bands (I was concurrently into bands like The Dregs, The Police, XTC, &c.).
I set this up with probably TMI, but for the reason that I think the devolution of rock into nihilistic forms like punk and goth was kind of a foregone conclusion, because that self-destructive undercurrent was there from the beginning. However, the other path to ever greater appreciation for good music and songwriting is also possible, and that's the path I ended up taking. This culminated in going from my BM being in jazz related music to my MM being in classical forms. So, if your kid is getting the police called on him (The real constabulary, not Sting's old band) for playing too loud in his garage band, don't utterly despair. He could turn out OK anyway. LOL!
I have it on good advice that the Beatles were "those honkies who ruined rock'n roll", and you'll find a surprising amount of Elvis influence in punk, and it's related genre of rockabilly/psychobilly.
…and you'll never have nights like this at any jazz club: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=56PU9XgVx0k&fm...
You want nihilism? Check out Santana's man-crush on Che and Fidel.
Boyd Rice's tales of his days working at Taco Bell and pranking the customers crack me up.
1)
When I was a 20-something and forming my political opinions, this is the stuff I was listening to. Bauhaus, Joy Division, Siouxsie, Dead Kennedys, This Mortal Coil… I was so tired of pop music and the vapidity of it's message. Goth and Punk music showed me there WAS something else out there to entertain the mind and ear. It took a while longer (sadly, I was horridly liberal in the days when Reagan was with us) but conservativism did much the same for my mind later on. I was able to break free of the ideology that made people perpetual victims for the benefit of a soul-less state, and see the beauty and possibilities that individualism and freedom afforded people.
2)
"Punk" and "goth" were titles accorded to music styles outside the mainstream and available to anyone who wished to participate. It was guerilla music, freedom, protest. It threatened anyone dependent on "the system". The tunes and the "look" were later co-opted and corrupted by Madison Ave., but punk's influence had already been disseminated by then.
Before criticising these genres as mere "noise" or the primitive antics of talentless hacks, consider what was really being done. An entrenched establishment was being challenged. People were taking music back for themselves. An entirely new style was developed. DIY was alive. If you don't care for the melodies (or the intentional lack thereof), you can't possibly argue against the SPIRIT. Don't we need that spirit again?
I'll grant that punk and goth were a form of rebellion against a VERY staid establishment. They also proved that a thrivingI'll grant that punk and goth were a form of rebellion against a VERY staid establishment. They also proved that a thriving, vital music genre could grow up with relatively little radio or album exposure. Regrettably, many of the same personality traits that drove this resulted in self-indulgent, dissonant CRAP for the sake of being different. It wasn't until it grew up a bit that, still rough and raw, we had the Clash, Siouxie, Sisters of Mercy, and the Violent Femmes. The bands that survived had actually learned some craft. We also then had the craft and artistry of what the Cure grew up into, Peter Murphy, and New Wave music. Last but not least, some truly stunning industrial music. Ministry and Skinny puppy were a breath of fresh air and adrenalin to a early 20-something. I still cue up NIN's "Pretty Hate Machine."
So what happened? Well. I for one grew up. The anger and nihilism no longer appealed (half of what I liked then.. belch.). Goth stayed depressing. Industrial got angrier and retreated back into the even more dissonant. The "Shock" value wore off and artists went in search of new ways to shock people. Never could stand any of NIN's later albums.
It's like they gained enough craft and talent to appeal, and sank back into the nihilism, narcissism, and post-modernism from which they sprang. And young audiences desperate to be hip and "not mainstream" followed them.
I like all these bands with the exception of Suicide, never heard of them. I really liked the Velvet Underground. Very innovative at the time. Had all their stuff on vinyl and bought it all again on CD. My son recently bought Funhouse by Iggy and the Stooges. That's worth a listen too. Thanks for the post.
Siouxsie & The Banshees really stands apart for me. One of my favorite bands, especially after they discovered melody, around Kaleidoscope or Juju. I'm only mildy interested in other Goth bands. I like how their music evolved over their long career. Even Siouxsie's recent solo album is great.
DTOM – I think what you articulated is a continuing cycle in music. The bands of the late 60's were in part a rebellion against the old to 40 singles radio payola system. The advent of FM radio made this possible, although commercialism eventually gets in and corrupts. This is similar to what you describe about Madison Avenue. Today, alt.country and alt.rock tries to do the same thing concerning treating the music seriously and bucking the system. Whether it is any good or not is ultimately in the eye (or should I say ear) of the beholder.
What became punk and metal changed from time to time and from place to place. In the late 1960s, the Stooges were a reaction to soft-focus hippie peace 'n love that dominated youth culture at the time. Only the Stooges, The Doors, and Velvet Underground exposed the real dark underbelly of the 1960s, the depair that was just below the surface. Coincidentally, Black Sabbath was itself formed for frustrated British rustbelt kids who toiled in factories while their more posh peers were having a groovy time in London.
By the time the New York punk scene was formed in the early 1970s, it was more about bringing rock and roll back to the people, as the rock gods of the '60s were either dying or got so wealthy, they were tooling around in private jets and snorting coke back when it was an insanely expensive drug.
What's interesting is how the British brand of punk was a combination of good ol' capitalism (Malcolm McLaren and Vivienne Westwood saw it as a great opportunity to promote their store and Westwood's torn t-shirts and bondage-inspired clothing) and the failure of Labour policies. Oh sure, The Clash took things way to the left and nobody would be caught dead cheering on Margaret Thatcher later on, but it's true. I agree the craftsmanship of the music got better as many of these kids started to take what they were doing more seriously. That created the heyday of 1980s alternative music.
As for me, my tastes are much more eclectic now and I don't think "alternative" as I knew it 20 years ago exists anymore anyway. I used to go out of my way to find band t-shirts and stuff imported from London, uphill both ways in the snow. Now these little whippersnappers just head on down to Hot Topic at the mall. Heh heh. Still, I enjoy gothy things. As I'm sure the series of essays will eventually point out, goth is a state of mind, not just a youth subculture or a musical style.
Still one of my all-time favorite bands.
Really liked some mid-end siouxie, and the song "Kiss them for me"
Good point that yep, as mentioned elsewhere, what "goth" is constantly reinvented itself. The whole Marilyn Manson/Korn shtick of the late 90's … meh. I'll throw on the violent femmes again, thank you.
I stil like the basic goth musical style(s) NIN's Pretty hate machine, the Violent Femmes, and Evanescence/Sisters of mercy/Cruxshadows/Nightwish/Within temptation/Dragonforce are a heavy part of my playlist….
Punk appealed to me as a teen as a contrast to all the hippie-dippy overproduced 'rock' of the 70s. And so many of those same hippie-types hated 'Ronnie Ray-gun' (the Beast; 666- each of his names had 6 letters in it, man!) that I got into RWR, first to be contrarian and then because of what he actually stood for!
That story about the Velvet Underground reminds me of the guy who owned this store where I used to buy my comics in Virginia. He told me he'd seen one of the band's first shows somewhere in New York and Andy Warhol was there. He kept coaching the band, "Louder! Play louder!"
Rice seems to have always enjoyed playing on people's perceptions and pushing buttons just to see what the fallout would be… even if it meant being interviews on white supremacist talk shows or trying to give the first lady of the United States a severed lambs head on the spur of the moment. He's what GG Allin could have been if he'd had more than two brain cells to rub together.
"Perhaps the song’s rumored anti-communist message did no go down well in deep-red lower Manhattan."
Wow. Like Lou later sang, "And then my mind split open." Because an anti-communist message is always more alienating than an electric viola drone pattern at deafening volume.
Matt, will you give me the name of your supplier? While you're contemplating the question, do consider purchasing Jim DeRogatis' excellent new VU coffee-table bio, featuring contributions from Greg Kot, Gerard Malanga, Billy Name, Rob O'Connor, myself, and others, all of whom manage to leave their politics out of their appreciations. I think you might dig it, if only for the many heretofore unpublished pictures.
Carolyn:
Perhaps this more familiar selection will put things in a diferent perspective: http://skreemr.com/link.jsp?id=62584A5656546415&a... Velvet Underground&title=Sweet Jane
Honestly I love the irony of the Velvets, punk, and goth, being referenced on a conservative blog. Seriously though who is his supplier?
Thank you, I was just going to suggest that she listen to "Sweet Jane" for an example of why they had fans.
You must be logged in to post a comment.