The Vault: An Exploration of the Gothic
by Matt PattersonPart 1 – Introduction
The bats have left the bell tower, the victims have been bled… - Bauhaus, “Bela Lugosi’s Dead”
Goth is dead.
Well, OK, maybe not. But if it is not dead, exactly, Goth certainly isn’t what it once was. In this, Goth is rather like conservatism – with which it shares much (more on that later) – a glorious 1980’s heyday, followed by a confused 1990’s…and a disastrous 2000’s.
–
True, some elements of Goth limp along in the new millennium, having been cannibalized by, and absorbed into, mainstream culture. In some instances, co-opted bits of Goth have been so deracinated as to seem entirely anomalous – witness the black hair, black eyeliner, and black nail polish of the latest American Idol runner up; like claws on a cow, once dangerous and distinct trappings draped on an entirely neutered and non threatening pop singer.
But this is really an ephemeral sort of existence. If Goth lives now, it is more in the manner of those dearly departed who live on in the habits, mannerisms and memories of the loved ones who survive them, rather than the corporeal beings they once were.
Why? What happened to this strange movement? Where did it come from? For that matter, what the hell is ‘Goth’ anyway?
In this column, we will examine these questions, and attempt to ascertain the causes of both Goth’s origin and its decline. We will analyze the major elements and investigate the major practitioners. We will probe, remember, and lament; we will celebrate and categorize. We will be anthropologists and nostalgists. It will perhaps be a useful endeavor – at the very least, some of us will have something in the way of explanation when our future children discover our old and tattered capes in the back of the closet.
But our investigation will not end there. We will examine and explore the Gothic in all of its permutations, from the tribes who swept down from the Nordic north to shake the mighty Roman Empire, to the architecture of the High Middle Ages which soared to touch the face of God, to the castle-strewn romance novels of early modern Europe. We will try to determine what, if anything, these phenomena have in common besides the not entirely helpful label “Gothic,” and what, if any, connection they have to the modern movement.
For Goth is indeed a many splintered thing. It is an aesthetic. It is a music. It is a style of dress and a manner of speech. Like all subcultures, it is a way for people to organize their lives, a guide to relating to the world and its evanescent and mercurial inhabitants. In this sense, it performs some of the functions of religion, philosophy, and a neighborhood bridge night. It is a coping mechanism, a crutch, and a glorious release.
And yet Goth, and especially the music, has seldom been given the sort of serious attention bequeathed on other genres, in part because so much of it descended into the kind of cheap theatricality which is easily mocked and dismissed. But make no mistake – the best Goth is some of the best music, and we will here give it, as well as its performers and fans, the consideration it deserves.
Because this column will be a labor of love and, therefore (as most such labors) impecunious, it will appear when it will. I will post a chapter weekly when I can; monthly when I must. But I will post, if you will read.
So step this way. Watch your head as we descend this creaky staircase into the dark. Don’t worry. I’ll hold your hand. I’ll lead the way. I’ve been down here before, you see.
Don’t mind the flitter and flutter about your head, the scurry and screeching about your feet. Close your nostrils to the must and dust. Let the cobwebs caress your face, as we approach the first vault, which opens onto Greenwich Village in the mid 1960’s, and a band that is about to be fired for playing a forbidden and luciferous tune…
They call themselves The Velvet Underground.
Next Time: In The Beginning







Subscribe via RSS
Got a Tip?
60 Comments
I was goth in my 20's. Looking forward to reading the installments.
Goth is Nihilism…
The reservoir of the God is Dead crowd, Goth sprang out of the ashes of 70's heavy metal movement, particularly the Satanic overtones, mostly UK or German bands. The Bahaus influence of the 30's is heavy as well- and no one is gloomier than the Germans- and it became a comfortable place for those on the outside edge of society to collect.
Not without it's notable contributions to music and art- all great art comes from great pain, which is why Southen California rock is so insipid- The Cure, Morrisey, and yes, even Depeche Mode. The cinematic aspect is a little more unfortunate, mostly slasher stuff…
But nihilism all the same.
I never understood goth. The only goth person I knew in high school was unnecessarily obnoxious and, when she spoke to me, spoke mostly of her sexual exploits, which I did not find very interesting. I am, however, interested to learn what else the term "goth" encompasses.
Can't wait…I've seen The Cure and Bauhaus in concert several times and have always had an outsider's interest in the Goth subculture
The goth's I have known are poser!goths who do it for the attention not because that's what defines them as a person. I have yet to meet a true goth but I am always opened to meeting new people!
The goths I have known are poser!goths who do it for the attention not because that's what defines them as a person. I have yet to meet a true goth but I am always opened to meeting new people!
I'm really good at being a Goth! I murder Romans with reckless abandon, I smell like hunger and livestock, and I do a really great job of getting my ass handed to me by Huns. Yep, I'm a Goth through and through!
You got me missing Peter Murphy, hadn't thought of Bauhaus in a while although I still have them on vinyl. Look forward to VU they were definitely before their time.
First of all, Bauhaus is trash and I will never forgive them for ruining my NiN concert. However, if you want to see what happened to the first true Goths of yore just go to a Bauhaus concert. They still show up, it's cute.
You can find real Goths in the new generations, if you know where to look. We still have at least one somewhat (in)famous Goth club operating in Detroit (Cityclub!). I stop in from time to time. Goths are my kind of people. I believe they are, at their core, nerds. And so I find in them kindred spirits, even if they do dress funny and dance like they are doing water aerobics.
I'll be waiting!
So, does this count?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZcMuMhN0oRU
If you want great modern Gothic music, check out an L.A. band called The Last Dance. Very few of the accepted trappings of what today's poseurs think "Goth" is supposed to be, just great songs in the vein of Sisters of Mercy and the more commercial side of Bauhaus.
LOL!
I'm a Conservative activist and a Goth (Going to Bar Sin's 11th B'day this weekend). The best Goth song is by Chameleons UK: Swamp Thing. How can you not groove to that?
Also, I highly recommend listening to DJ Amanda jones if you are in LA.
This will, inevitably, lead to an Emo thread. I'm certain of it.
Quit while you're ahead, Matt. Like the man says, sit down, you're a bloody tragedy.
I knew a few goths in high school. They were prone to acts of VANDALism. Can you imagine the GAUL?
…
Sorry…
Oh fuck, really? A discourse on Goth? I'll just watch the original Nosferatu for the 100th time and pretend goths never shit all over an aesthetic that I really love.
Remember Rule Number One:
Pillage, then burn.
October of 2007 I was calling home from Korea. I asked what my daughters want to dress up as for Halloween this year. My middle daughter, who was 7 at the time, yelled “A dead princess!” My immediate response was to tell my wife “Great, we’re raising a goth. Ask her if she helped sack Rome. If she did we don’t need to pay for college.” I don’t think she actually went in that costume. I do plan on saving this story to tell her boyfriends though.
Not as bad as the stealthier ones that just seem to pop in out of nowhere when you finally see them. Hence the term "Invisigoths".
…
Let's see, did I remember charge up the deflector shielding and point defense laser clusters? Ah, good. I did.
I will repeat the question that every Asatruar asks when we see a Goth. If you're Goth, then where were you when we sacked Rome?
How about this?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4m0kjFooODY
(This one is more work friendly. I realized the previous video by this band wasn't.)
Christian Gothic Music:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h0trMR76INk
http://www.myspace.com/weddingparty
http://www.myspace.com/mysecretsin
While not specifically a Christian gothic band, they're often grouped with them and this video by Virgin Black shows what's different about a lot of the Christian gothic music that touches upon dchase's point about nihilism:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KiIvQ9U5qNE
This song ends with the line:
"All is lost but hope"
It's like nihilism without the nihil.
JSF… I was just scrolling down to make a post about the greatest, gloomiest band that nobody's heard of… and then you did. Nice. I would have said Second Skin though, from the Chameleons.
I never got into Goth music much, but I've grown to appreciate Bauhaus and Killing Joke (I know, not really Goth, but Goth-ish) recently.
I am looking forward to this. It hink it is interesting how the label "goth" has been described as so many dissimilar things.
I grew up i the 80's and there was a style of dress that many would call goth that I'm not certain really was. But let me just say the Doc Marten boots with fishnets and a black mini skirt is a look that still does it for me.
I am looking forward to this. It think it is interesting how the label "goth" has been described as so many dissimilar things.
I grew up i the 80's and there was a style of dress that many would call goth that I'm not certain really was. But let me just say the Doc Marten boots with fishnets and a black mini skirt is a look that still does it for me.
Ah, "The Hunger!" Doesn't hold up too well, but quite the flick in its' day! The 80's, gotta love 'em!
Christian goth….oxymoron
I remember Goth girls they were all c!@K teasers. Sadly I never got to make it with one. I will say this they were sexy.
You'd think it's an oxymoron but the there is quite a bit of it out there (see also The Awakening: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0AFd409gWKk ) and like I said, what's interesting and distinct about it is that it's got an upbeat and hopeful vibe running through it that's missing from normal goth music. The one I still can't figure out, though, is Christian black (sometimes called "unblack" or "white") and death metal, which is sung in a voice pretty much designed to sound as evil as possible.
I'm waiting for an exploration of Goth myself. I never got into it that I know of, but we've all seen self-described Goths. It'll be interesting to see where they think they're coming from.
Goth seems to be one of those things that means something slightly different to everyone, even (especially) those in the scene itself. I look forward to reading your take on it.
I was in highschool in the 80s and always thought the goths were kind of pretentious and boring. I was talking with my mother one time about the way they dress and sulk all the time and she told me that they "had goths back in the 60s and 70s too, but back then they were just know as Drama Students."
Some were sexy, some were fat.
The great thing about the goth scene is you could seriously dress up to go clubbing.
I hope this isn't like your last series, M. Patterson, where the ambition and quality of the articles tapered off in a hurry after the introductory post.
goth tribal leader adressing his marauders before their attack on the Roman village begins:
"Allright men; we are going to ride on into that village down yonder, kill the men, rape the women and stampede the cattle. For dark gods' sake let's get it right THIS time!"
"We've just been Goth-served!" ~ South Park
"I am, however, interested to learn what else the term "goth" encompasses."
To be Goth, you must be non-conformist. To be non-conformist, you must conform to dressing in all black, smoking cigarettes behind the school and drinking lots of coffee… ~ South Park Goth kids
Love gothy music, still love gothy things.
Looking forward to this discussion. I must admit I found goth girls very attractive and alluring although I never had the guts to actually talk to one. I find part of the goth aesthetic appealing because some of it is an offshoot to neo-Victorians. The Victorians in terms of the fine arts perhaps could be called the first "goths".
most of them were fat! but every now and then you had the pretentious hot one that was so misguided but still cute. OH I miss those days.
Grunge = I hate myself and I want to die
Punk = I hate you and I wish you were dead
Goth = I hate my life and I wish I were undead
Grunge = I hate myself and I want to die
Punk = I hate you and I wish you were dead
Goth = I hate my life and I wish I were undead
Love the article. Andrew would disagree but many labeled the Sisters "Goth". I guess I could see why. Nonetheless, the Sisters is a favorite band of mine along with The Cult, who got lumped into the genre when they started as the Southern Death Cult. Check out the book, "Inside the Reptile House" by someone named Thompson. (Forget his first name.) Anyways…Goth? You decide:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x6Oh4aaLCFM&fe...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1hsWZO8e2Po&fe...
Goth isn't any more dead than punk is. Which isn't to say that Punk is alive and well – because it isn't – but it's been lingering in a kind of half-life since 1985, to be taken out, dusted off, and paraded around now and again, then returned to it's shelf right next to the old Sinatra albums. Goth isn't dead, though it, too, is on a kind of economic life support. But whereas Punk was pronounced dead by most of it's own creators in 1977, Goth had a vastly longer lifetime (Basically 1977 until now), and it didn't die becuase it's creators got bored with the limited framework. Rather it died because the mainstream itself simply became more and more goth. It lost it's distinctiveness, and hence it's relevance. But of course it's still there, even if you can't quite flense it out of culture anymore.
I was & still am a fan of the Leeds contingent & mid-80's goth… The Sisters of Mercy, March Violets, All About Eve, Skeletal Family/Ghost Dance, Salvation, Fields of the Nephilim &, yes, even the Mission (UK) – all kinds of great stuff there. What's fairly amusing is that the majority of these bands do not embrace the genre & reject being called goth or gothic rock. Ask Andrew Eldritch if he's a goth & you're likely to get slapped in the face…
Any of you folks that want another decent look into the history of Goth rock/lifestyle should check out any books by Mick Mercer, a good deal of research and a lot of sarcastic humor…
Looking forward to future installments of this & seeing how the VU became the influence to a lot of the early bands like Bauhaus (later Tones on Tail & then Love & Rockets) mentioned above & also stuff like Danse Society & Gang of Four.
what the… that video… What the F@^7 was that mess, crawling out of the'80s stew of confusion. Sounded like something I'd hear at a rave. Thrumming beats that go nowhere. With barely understandable "Bowie" voiced styled rumbling near the end so the DJ can cycle it ten minutes later.
I love the SP goth kids!
Something like that was in the player guide for the first Civilization game.
That's so sad….
….okay, so perhaps I have no idea how to act emo while keeping a straight face.
So do I! Especially loved the Goth vs. Vampire story line.
I had alot of friends just like them when I was in California a few years back.
Goth is great and all, but Horrorpunk's where it's at
How many goths does it take to change a lightbulb?
What's a lightbulb?
just wanted to continue with the nice vibe on the forum. plp just usually start criticizing each other and it makes me so sad. but not here. happy goth!
Hmm, anyone who has done any serious reading about the Goth subculture knows that is is always dying. Every ten years or so, people proclaim goth to be dead. In fact, it goes up and down in cycles.
Try and find a genuine new waver, a rude boy, or a mod and you'll be lucky. But plenty of goths around.
[...] Part one of this series can be read here. [...]
[...] have been grateful for all the suggestions and critiques of the previous posts, which can be read here and here. As always, comments and criticisms are welcome at [...]
"I'm a Conservative activist and a Goth."
Holy cow, I thought I was the only one! *tears of joy*
You must be logged in to post a comment.