Waiting for Sim: Christmas Eves With the Definitive Scrooge
by Michael MandavilleWhen growing up in Los Angeles, a singular delight was getting the TV Guide in the Sunday paper and scouring it, pen in hand. My movie search. In the sixties, Los Angeles had the greatest number of TV channels in any city: 2-4-5-7-9-11-13. In trips to San Diego, the Mid-West or anywhere else, you’d be lucky to get two, maybe three channels. And not very good ones.

Some years ago, my daughter asked: “…so in the olden times, Dad, when did you see movies?” Hmmmm. Olden times. As if the wheel, the pen, writing, music, and entertainment were invented with her generation. I explained that there were two places to see movies. Theaters and Television. That was it. No DVD, VHS, iPod, or Hulu.com. My TV Guide search was essential to find the right movies and straighten out my schedule for the week by circling and grading the films. After all, if a movie came on at 11 p.m., you’d be up for two hours to “The End.”
But each week, when I got the TV Guide in my young hands, it was like opening a present. Before the internet, I explained to my daughter, we had this ancient forum called a “library” where you could get books on movies and famous actors.
“Oh,” she said. “You actually go someplace?”
But the TV Guide was a treasure trove. My favorites – “The Great Escape” – A. “Dirty Dozen” – A. “Run Silent, Run Deep” – A. Any film by John Ford. And at least watch anything with Bogart, Flynn, Coooper, Lancaster, Cary Grant, William Powell, Carole Lombard, Katherine Hepburn and others. I was delighted to discover that stunningly beautiful Hedy Lamarr was granted U.S. Patent 2,292,387 in 1942 for an early version of frequency-hopping based upon a piano roll to change between 88 frequencies. It was intended to make radio-guided torpedoes harder for enemies to detect or jam. Beautiful and designs weapons. What a dish!
But around Christmas, the most essential movie was “Scrooge” with Alistair Sim, a Scottish actor who portrayed Ebenezer Scrooge in the 1951 classic based upon Charles Dicken’s beloved “A Christmas Carol.” Nowadays, of course, you can buy the DVD with both color and black and white versions to our delight.

Alistair Sim
During my years of searching the TV Guide, this films was obscure and hardly remembered. As I recall, its television screening would occur only once, on Los Angeles Independent channels of 5, 11, or 13 in the years before conglomerate takeovers.
Once. Only Once. For a year.
The film is now regarded as a classic but, at the time, Alistair Sim had become an obscure footnote in film history. His stern visage and scattered hair perfectly complemented his impentrable dark miserly eyes for the role. It’s hard to believe that, with his harsh features, “in 1950 he was voted the most popular film actor in Britain in a national cinema poll.” His earliest successes as a leading man included the police detective in the thriller Green for Danger (1946); as the headmaster of Nutbourne College, co-starring with Dame Margaret Rutherford, in the comedy The Happiest Days of Your Life (1950); and as a writer of lurid crime fiction in the comedy Laughter in Paradise (1951).
He was the definitive Ebenezer Scrooge, the very personification of a miser in a vicious Humbug spirit that there was no chance of his redemption. And then he was miraculously changed through the Ghosts into a man of such unexpected generosity that the frightened charwoman, played to perfection by Kathleen Harrison, could only flee with fear.
“Scrooge” was screened on near midnight of Christmas Eve. It did not appear earlier in the week nor later. On Demand Media was science fiction. If you wanted to watch Sim and were one of the few people tuned in to his perfect portrayal as the definitive Scrooge, then you were a member of a group of film junkies who prized movie performances, film history, and pitch-perfect classics crystallized in celluloid. There was a commitment one had to make to see the film. If you missed it, you missed it. No second chances. No other way to see the film. It required a decision. Try explaining that to today’s teenager. “All that, for a movie?!
What I remember about those Christmases was the sheer joy of Sim’s transformation. His buoyant burst of generosity with the charwoman. The little boy running across the snow who Scroorge beseeches to wake up the butcher for the prize meat. “You mean, the one as big as me?”
Sim reminded me of the joy of Christmas, its real meaning, and the embrace of the Spirit in our lives to spread kindness and goodwill toward men.
Missing the film was like not seeing an old friend on Christmas Eve. Once a year, I made some time for him. And he spoke to me.






Subscribe via RSS
Got a Tip?
45 Comments
Philadelphia had 3, 6, 10, 12, 17, 23, 29, 48, and 57. We got our first color TV set in 1976 to watch the Rankin Bass "Rudolph's Shiny New Year" no remote control either. Someone was obligated to get up change the channel manually and sometimes adjust the antenna. There was also only one television in the house.
[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Big Hollywood, Michael Chavez and DNC DUDES, Mr. Pink. Mr. Pink said: Waiting for Sim: Christmas Eves With the Definitive Scrooge http://tinyurl.com/ycwo6p6 [...]
We received only one, channel 12 out of Cape Girardeau, Mo and then only after one of us kids would go out and twist the pole on the antenna until Dad screamed to stop.
There is a digitally restored version of this movie, NOT "colorized". The dvd includes both "Scrooge" (UK) and "A Christmas Carol" (North American. It is 86 minutes long, and is a COMPLETE version of the 1951 production. It is produced by
Morningstar Entertainment, Canada, http://www.morningstarent.com
I came across this yesterday at Roger's Video (it was on the Christmas rack).
Missing the Peanuts Halloween or Christmas special was the world's biggest tragedy. No way to watch it again until the following year. My daughter just doesn't understand. To her, having to use an actual dvd instead of being able to get something On Demand is "roughing it."
No answering machines or caller ID, either. Wow. Primitive. How did we ever communicate? How did we survive?
Thanks for the reminder of the TV Guide excitement. I'd forgotten about that.
Old enough to remember the vacuum tubes that powered TVs and radios?
I remember those days all too well. We lived up on a hill, and some times the only way to get a decent picture was some had to hold on to the antenna. Had no idea why it worked at the time, though as a computer/electrical engineer, I do now.
We used to take turns because it got boring and tiring standing there watching other people watch TV.
I do remember the crossword puzzles that came in the back of our issue of TV guide. One off my high lights of the week.
My first TV at my first apartment was my parents 25" Zenith Color Console. Over the years, all the tubes had been replaced with lifetime ones from Radio Shack. I remember going there probably once a year with my Dad to check all the tubes and replace the weak ones.
Remember dad having to go outside and turning the antenna while we had our head out the window telling him when to stop. Man, dad was so glad to get an electric antenna turner. No doubt that Sim is the definative Scrooge by which all others are compared. By the way, the Sim film Green With Danger would make an apt moniker for Cap and Trade.
I have a portable tube tester in my basement. Doubt I'll ever have a need to use it again. But it does bring back memories. My Dad used to bring home old tubes and we'd take them to the Zenith TV sales and repair shop on the corner and they had a free tester there.
I think that's what got me on the road to electrical engineering, which lead me to computers. Not quite sure where I am headed now, other trying to keep my head down to avoid layoffs till I can retire in about a dozen years or so.
I remember all of those things.
What year did Philly have all of those channels?
In the late 1940s, NYC has 2, 4, 5, 7, 9, and 11. Less than a decade later, channel 13 was added.
This version of "A CHRISTMAS CAROL " is my favorite and in my opinion the best one ever made.
I certainly know of them but I was born a bit after vacuum tubes.
I agree with 1red….This is the definitive version of " A Christmas Carol". I like the 38 version with Barrymore, but Alistair is KING! I put it in my VCR-then- DVD player every Christmas, no blue ray yet!
To me his was always the ultimate version of A Christmas Carol. Many a frigid Christmas Eve was spent wrapping presents while the Dakota winds howled around the house, a low fire hissing on the grate, the only illumination in the room came from the tree and the TV, where a weak signal out of Regina Saskatchewan always brought Alistair Sim's Scrooge into our house. It was always a race to finish wrapping the kid's gifts and putting them under the tree so we could sit back with a warm Tom & Jerry before the ghost of Christmas past arrived.
[...] the article here: Waiting for Sim: Christmas Eves With the Definitive Scrooge This entry is filed under America – Blogs, Big Hollywood. You can follow any responses to this [...]
We lived up on a hill near Dayton, Ohio. We got all the Dayton stations (2, 7, 16, 22, and later 45), all the Cincinnati stations (5, 9, 12, 19, 48, and later 64) and some occasional wildcards from Columbus or Richmond.
But if the atmosphere was doing stuff, every once in a while we could get Tennessee or Texas.
And 13 in the 50s and beyond was public television in NYC
I actually was tested on a vacuum tube trainer when I was in A school when I was in the Navy
25 years in video retailing (now retired) has me recommending this restored version of the 1951 Sim "Scrooge".
You get the original and now restored B&W version, plus the colorized version, plus the 1935 British version, plus interviews and extras all on a 2 DVD set for …..$9.49 brand new!
http://www.amazon.com/Christmas-Carol-Ultimate-Collectors-Color/dp/B000SR0DDE
Well, kind of; just not what we call "public broadcasting" today.
It was an "arts" channel and a damned good one, with programs that rivaled anything that came/comes out of England, without the nudity. Mostly, the old channel 13 did old Broadway plays with BIG TIME actors and actresses………………"WALTZ OF THE TOREADORS", "archie and mehitabel", etc.; a different play every week.
I don't remember them having begathons, back then, do you ?
“Oh,” she said. “You actually go someplace?”
Man, I'm only 26 and that makes ME feel old!
We may be recalling two different times in the history of channel 13 in NYC. I remember it as dry as burnt toast with little or no programming that interested me….and certainly no films. It was public TV at it's most primitive and worst. This was in the 50s and 50s. And, no. No begathons or commercials. They prided themselves on that. Now – file that under ancient history.
Hey – added thrill – occasionally pulling the CBS affiliate from Connecticut or WCAU the CBS station in Philadelphia! Though out on the east end of Long Island, even pullingCBS in NYC was a triumph!
My favorite version of Dickens' " A Christmas Carol" is "Scrooge", with Albert Finney. My liberal in-laws laughed at me.
They also preferred the Alastair Sim version.
I remember 13, distinctly, in the late 50s and early '60s.
Please reread my post; I didn't mention films…..I talked about the play of the week. I do think that they did show a few movies, though, because I have a recollection of my father and I discussing Guy de Maupassant's "BOULE DE SUIF", which had been shown on 13. He liked it, but I didn't. I had just read it in the original French, for my French class. And that had to have been in 1959 or '60; '61 at the latest.
I'm not sure how old you are ( and I'm showing my age, now ) , but did you ever watch"LUCKY PUP" as a kid? If the name of the show doesn't ring any bells, maybe the names of the puppets will……………..Fudini and Pinhead.
We never pulled in any other channels, than the ones from NYC; it would have been nice to do so.
Sim IS Ebenezer Scrooge. There is no comparison. George C. Scott borrowed so much from him for his version. I watched it repeatedly when I was young and my family has watched it every year since i found it on VHS some 20 years ago. It would not be Christmas without it.
Michael-
Ahhh……the rituals! Buying the TV Guide as early as possible to see what films were coming up. I would circle what I wanted to see with a blue pen. As the week progressed, I would rip out the used pages of the TV Guide (a habit I inherited from my Dad. I did it at someone's house unconsciously one time and their eyes bugged out of their heads.)
Then – mercy, mercy – setting the alarm clock for the middle of the night in case what you wanted to see was on at 3:00 am, then waking up and fighting with yourself – movie, sleep, movie, sleep. Mortal combat!
Then – waiting for the "television set" – the one with the clunky, orbital tuner – waiting for it to warm up. No remote control. Dealing with rabbit ears antennas and/or with tuners that you had to set midway between channels to pull in the station. Dealing with stations that ran the wrong film. Anger!
And if you dozed off, you woke up in a different movie or with an Indian head or an American flag with the "Star Spangled Banner" playing behind it as the station signed off.
The once a year films were special. And like you said, you miss it, you lose.
I, too, grew up with L.A. TV, and I also remember the "Million Dollar Movie" on Ch. 9, "Ben Hunter's Movie Matinee" on Ch. 11 (Hunter was probably an inspiration for Johnny Carson's Art Fern), and "The Fabulous 52" on Ch. 2. You have to remember, however, that all the movies shown on these programs were interrupted by commercials. Today, I am so used to seeing uninterrupted movies on TCM and on DVD that seeing a classic movie with commercials would be jarring. Times change. While I do agree that the Alastair Sim "Scrooge" is the best, I have a soft spot in my heart for "Mister Magoo's Christmas Carol".
TV Guide just confirmed to me that "Scrooge" was playing on Christmas Eve – I just knew it would be on! It just defined the sprit for me – spent all day yesterday (Christmas Eve) searching for it – no such luck! What is going on? Traditions are going by the wayside – commercials about Christmas start early to sell things, but the joy and spirit of this Holy Season are just ignored – this used to be a universal joy, now things are so non Christmas – but I still say Merry Christmas – cause it is about Christ, and I will always believe that!
Thanks, and Merry Christmas to one and all, especially to our troops – all over the world!
“Oh,” she said. “You actually go someplace?”
I was at a rummage sale a few weeks ago with my 16 year old nephew. There was a nice old wooden library card catelog cabinet for sale. He looked at it pulled open a couple of drawers and asked "What's this for?"
As I've observed before here: I suspect that for at least 90% of Americans (at least those over 30), when they hear the name "Scrooge" it is Alistair Sim's face that comes instantly to mind.
Merry Christmas, everyone!
and one more thing – Christmas has been "looped" in with other holidays – it is like no other holiday – just ask other faiths if they would equate their holiday with Christmas. It is time we say Merry Christmas to all faiths cause it is a holiday worth celebrating; when it's Channukah I will say Happy Channukah to my friends who celebrate it, but when it's Christmas, just saying Happy Holiday doesn't cut it. For goodness sake it is Christmas (birth of Christ) and we have to stop being politically correct about it. Here in Cali I have even noticed commercials saying Merry Christmas – gives me reason to hope and pray that the joy and the reason we celebrate is a good one.
Thanks for letting me vent – Merry Christmas to one and all! (no more making pc excuses)
Don't forget having to actually wait till the bank was open to get money. And the bank was only open M-F about 9-4. If you didn't have cash, you'd write a check, but sometimes if you'd run out of checks you could write a check on a deposit slip. Wow. I'm old.
Ahhhh….what a diffference a few years make.
I was 10 y/o in 1961, so most of the material on channel 13 would have been far too dry for me.
Lucky Pup? no.
Miss Francis and Ding Dong School – yes.
I'm only a year or so younger and I've never even seen a TV Guide.
I have been to a library of course. Once… in college before they had it all online.
I've encountered VHS and cassettes…. briefly. In college again. Before they they had it all online.
OK OK, we did used to have VHS movies when I was younger. Not cassettes though that I can recall.
Obama's White House Tree ornaments featuring Mao and aTransvestite are just another example of a petty, man-child President. Just like the Acorn cookies served in the White House this Christmas. How adolescent!
Back in 1950 when I was only three, Channel 5 was the only station in town. My sister and I always begged to stay up on Christmas Eve to see Laurel and Hardy in "Babes in Toyland". After we went to bed, my Mom and Dad would wrap packages and watch John Wayne in "The Three Godfathers".
I don't recall having a tv guide in those days, with only one channel, it wasn't necessary! I remember being so entranced with the television, I'd watch the test pattern if nothing else was on. Of course, the REAL REASON for the invention of TV was so we could watch HOWDY DOODY!
Oh, that would explain it……………..the age difference is what makes the BIG difference!
And no, you never would have watched LUCKY PUP, THE MAGIC COTTAGE, nor MR. I. MAGINATION; three of the best ever children's programs of the late '40s -early '50s, either.
The terrible thing is, all of the kinescopes, from the early years, were either repeatedly taped over or destroyed; the best shows never ever to be seen again. That is a crime !
[...] [...]
Immigration Lawyers…
[...]just below, are some totally unrelated sites to ours, however, they are definitely worth checking out[...]…
Get your horse tack!…
Not sure if this is the right place (I’m not really good with computers), but left you a trackback for your readers, if they ever need some information about horse tack….
Best Links 2011…
I do agree with all the ideas you have presented in your post. They’re really convincing and will definitely work. Still, the posts are very short for novices. Could you please extend them a little from next time? Thanks for the post….
minecraft skins Thanks erstwhile more for distribution this online. I cherished every bit of it….
Thanks erstwhile more for distribution this online. I cherished every bit of it….
puppy breeders The of these blogging engines and CMS platforms is the deficiency of limitations and repose of touch that allows developers to tasteful proportionality and ‘skin’ the in specified a way that with real minuscule labor one would never me…
The of these blogging engines and CMS platforms is the deficiency of limitations and repose of touch that allows developers to tasteful proportionality and ‘skin’ the in specified a way that with real minuscule labor one would never mention what it is …
You must be logged in to post a comment.