HBO’s ‘The Pacific’: An Interview with Jon Seda
by Michael BroderickUPDATE: “The Congressional Medal of Honor” is now listed as the ”Medal of Honor” and the “Gladiator” film mentioned is no longer listed as the version directed by Ridley Scott. Thanks to our ever helpful fact-checking commenters.
Ed. Note: Starting Sunday, March 14th, HBO begins its 10-part miniseries “The Pacific,” which follows the United States Marine Corps through WWII in the Pacific Theatre of Operations. This $100 million production re-teams a number of those (including Tom Hanks and Steven Spielberg) involved in HBO’s unforgettable 2001 miniseries, “Band of Brothers,” which many, including myself, consider to be one of the finest productions about WWII made for television or any other medium.
I’ve asked Michael Broderick, an actor, former Marine, and top-notch writer to be Big Hollywood’s point man on this project. He’ll be snagging whatever interviews he can, reviewing many if not all of the episodes, and keeping the Big Hollywood community up to date and informed on what is sure to be a seminal moment in television, a terrific piece of entertainment, and a worthy tribute to our Veterans. — JN

The Pacific: An Interview with Jon Seda
What a long, strange trip it’s been.
I entered the Marine Corps in nineteen eighty *cough* at the tender age of seventeen, secure in the knowledge that upon completion of my four year hitch, I would move to Hollywood and become a popular and sought after actor.
Instead, I fell in lust and, upon leaving the Corps, followed my John Thomas to New York City. That was okay. They have actors in New York, right?
No contacts, no formal training and no idea what I was doing, I ended up in a fantastic little rock and roll band instead. We made a good run of it through the 90s. In fact, I met my wife while I was playing CBGB in 1998.
Flash forward to November 2001. HBO’s “Band of Brothers” had recently aired its final episode and it was beginning to really sink in. “It” being the realization that the United States could be entering another long and bloody war. I came to realize the importance of this series. It honored those who sacrificed on behalf of their countrymen but did not shy away from illustrating the horror of combat.
About two years later, I got word that Spielberg, Hanks and Co. (I would certainly never address them using their last names to their face, it just sounds better) were planning a new series based on the Marines in the Pacific Theater. I had already started shifting priorities in my life (a couple of skyscrapers getting knocked down on a few thousand of your neighbors tends to focus the mind) and decided to have a sit-down with the wife.
My wife, a beautiful, intelligent and tough Italian girl from Jersey (are there any other kind?) is not shy with her opinions. A year earlier, very pregnant with our only child, on a business trip to Los Angeles, she’d said, “I could never live out here” and I was about to drop a bomb on her.
“You want to move where?” We had only recently purchased a cozy Greenwich Village apartment and were settling in.
It took some convincing but my wife has always been one to back her man’s play. We put the apartment up for sale. Within a few months and with family in tow, I was finally coming to Hollywood to become an actor. I was going to get an audition for “The Pacific” if it killed me.
So, how does a greenhorn actor wrangle his way into one of the top casting agencies for a role in, perhaps, the most important project of the new decade?
Well, frankly, I don’t know. I wasn’t able to do it.

Regardless, I’ve been looking forward to the premiere of “The Pacific” for a long time. When John Nolte asked me to cover it for Big Hollywood, I simply couldn’t refuse. So, I’ll be following the series as it progresses and you can keep up with it, right here. If fortune smiles upon me, perhaps Mr. Spielberg or Mr. Hanks will agree to chat with me a bit and I can bring that to you, too. Who knows? I’m still new at this, so I’ll try anything. To quote Captain Dale Dye, “You can do a lot of things people tell you are impossible when you’re blissfully ignorant”.
With that in mind, and on Capt Dye’s recommendation, I contacted the wonderful Mara Mikialian at HBO and she was kind enough to put me in touch with actor Jon Seda who plays GySgt “Manila” John Basilone.
John Basilone is the hero of Raritan, New Jersey. He was awarded the Medal of Honor for his actions at the Battle of Guadalcanal and remains a fixture in Marine Corps history. I won’t go too much into his story, as it will be explored in the series.
Like Basilone, Jon Seda is a New Jersey native and was an amateur boxer, as well. He made his screen debut as a fighter in “Gladiator.” In 1996, Jon received critical acclaim for his role as Blue in “The Sunchaser” opposite Woody Harrelson at the Cannes Film Festival and has enjoyed numerous roles on popular television shows, including “Kevin Hill”, “Ghost Whisperer” and HBO’s “Oz”.
I also reached out to Dale Dye to get his take. Although extremely busy with the roll out of the series, both men made time to answer some questions I had via email. For that, I’m very grateful.
———-
Michael Broderick: HBO’s “Band of Brothers” was a huge success and resonated with people all over the world. It’s inevitable that comparisons will be made. How do you think “The Pacific” stacks up?
Jon Seda: I know it’s inevitable that there will be those who compare “The Pacific” to “Band of Brothers”. For years, the Pacific theater of war was not talked about as much as the European theater, yet it was part of the same War. What was accomplished in “Band of Brothers” was incredible, from the writing and producing to the performances of the actors who honored all those men that fought bravely and gave the ultimate sacrifice for the freedoms we enjoy today. To me, that’s what it’s all about. With “The Pacific”, we’re just trying to do the same thing, continue to honor and make sure the real heroes aren’t forgotten!
MB: You play the part of “Manila” John Basilone, recipient of the Medal of Honor and one of the most famous Marines of all time. Can you tell us a little bit about the role?
JS: Words can’t express how humbled I am in being given the privilege to portray Gunnery Sergeant Basilone! John was born in New York like me and grew up in New Jersey like me. We both had a passion for boxing. John came from a big loving family and was with the Army first…but really found his niche with the Marines. He was a Jersey boy who loved being a Marine…he was tough but also well respected by his men. They all loved him and he never called himself a hero, he would just say he was doing what he was supposed to do. I could only pray that I would have had an ounce of the same courage he had!
MB: Did your boxing experience come into play during the shoot?
JS: I think the boxing training I’ve experienced in the past definitely helped me physically with the role, but if anything, it helped me more mentally, because it gave me the mindset to not quit, to keep fighting when I was tired, to get up if I was knocked down!
Dale Dye: If I had to point to the heart of the training unit for “The Pacific”, it would be Jon. James Badge Dale (Leckie) may be the brain and Joe Mazzello (Sledge) may be the guts, but Jon Seda was definitely the heart of the unit. He was motivated for all the right reasons all the time.
Jon understood the concept of tough, mentally, physically and psychologically. We’d finish one grueling exercise after another and he’d be just standing there sweating and hurting, asking me what’s next. I once told him to slow down and he fired right back at me: “Did those Marines on Guadalcanal and Iwo Jima slow down?” That’s Jon through and through.
MB: Did you find any particular source helpful in your preparation for the role?
JS: In regards to preparation…I mean, how does one prepare to portray someone like Manila John? I did a fair amount of research of facts by watching documentaries and reading books including, “I’m Staying With My Boys,” by Jim Proser, and “Red Blood, Black Sand” by Chuck Tatum. Tatum, a Marine who served on Iwo Jima with Basilone, is portrayed in “The Pacific”, and is someone I was able to meet with. At the end of the day, I stored all that in my head somewhere.
MB: Was there any one thing about the man that really clicked with you?
JS: I just concentrated on the fact that Basilone was a just a guy from Jersey who turned out to be a darn good Marine and who found himself in extraordinary circumstances, did what he trained to do and rose to the occasion!
MB: Captain Dale Dye was on board, once again, as Senior Military Advisor. His “boot camps” are legendary in the industry. What did you take away from that experience?
JS: I would never try to disrespect our men and women Marines by saying that the Boot Camp we endured was equal to theirs! That said, we needed something to give us a foundation to build on and that foundation came from Captain Dale Dye! He assembled a Boot Camp that taught us the ins and outs of the weapons used in WWII, and he had us go through tactical combat scenarios to at least give us a small insight to what it was like for these men.
DD: Seda actually became a technically proficient machine-gunner. He understood the functioning and the employment of those old thirty-caliber guns as well as anyone I’ve ever taught. About midway through training he could do head-space and timing without help and I rarely had to tell him to displace in covering infantry assaults. He knew when the time was right and just did it. He rapidly became a very functional machine gun section leader.
JS: Of course, we could never really know what it was like but if we were going to be the voice for these men we had to have something to draw from. I think the greatest thing we got from the Boot Camp was the camaraderie we developed with each other and we were able to keep this with us throughout the year of filming…hopefully it shows.
MB: What’s the most unexpected thing that you’re taking away from this experience?
JS: I thought I had a pretty good appreciation of everyday life before my experience with “The Pacific”, but I sure do now! I hope that’s what all who watch get out of it!
DD: Probably one of my most impactful moments during training for the Pacific came after our final field exercise, which involved an assault from the sea on a fortified enemy beach. Jon Seda walked up to me and said, “Skipper, you know that thing Semper Fidelis? I understand it now.” And he does. It shows in every scene of his performance.
———-
I’d like to thank Jon Seda, Captain Dale Dye and Mara Mikialian at HBO for their time in helping me kick this off. Thank you, John Nolte, for asking me to take it on. Lastly, thank you for reading. I hope you’ll come along for the ride.
See you back here after the March 14th premiere of HBO’s “The Pacific.”






Subscribe via RSS
Got a Tip?
72 Comments
I've always enjoyed Seda's work, going back to when he was on Homicide and his role as Chris Perez in Selena. Hearing about his background and his attitude, and the praise from Capt. Dale Dye, I like him even more. Really looking forward to "The Pacific."
I am absolutely waiting for this one with a ton of expectations. If it is half as good as "Band" it will be great. I just hope the producers don't inject their politics, however subtle.
Please God I hope this doesn't suck. Hanks latest diarrhea of the mouth worries me. Hopefully he helped with money and personnel and not story.
Looks like a great movie. I'm looking forward to this.
Semper Fi, nac
Look forward to the series, be there or be square!
For the record, Jon Seda did not appear in Ridley Scott's Gladiator. He made his debut in a different film with the same name, released in 1992: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0104346/
"Medal of Honor" not "Congressional Medal of Honor"
Nice catch, JimmyC. Thanks. So much for "top-notch", eh? I'll ask the BH bigwigs to fix it.
Michael
Great way to start your story, I'll be reading everything on here regarding this series. Band of Brothers was just so incredible on every level that if Pacific comes even close it'll be an instant classic.
I do have one question though. In Band of Brothers they inserted interviews with the actual men from Easy Company. Those were the most moving sequences I've ever seen on film. Will Pacific be following this formula?
[...] rest is here: HBO’s ‘The Pacific’: An Interview with Jon Seda This entry is filed under America – Blogs, Big Hollywood. You can follow any responses to this [...]
Thanks, doc.
First to Mr. Nolte, thank you for capitalizing "Veterans." It should be, but I too often see it's not. Thanks Mr. Broderick for a great post, and I look forward to seeing the series. This is such an important piece of history. My husband's grandfather fought in the Pacific. He was at Guadalcanal and has recounted some of the hardships there, including eating nothing but fish heads and coconuts for a month. But he really doesn't talk about his WWII experience much and doesn't want to. It's just too painful. But he says he thinks about it every day. I'm glad we have this tribute to them. If you have never attended the Sunset Parade featuring the Drum and Bugle Corps and Silent Drill Platoon at the Marine Corps War Memorial in D.C., I highly recommend it. It is a very moving experience.
My sister met & later married an Iwo Jima Marine. He passed on this last Fall. A reticent and soft spoken educator outwardly, he was outspoken in his love of his Corps. and those he served with. Truly "Old Breed", when I returned from Korea, it was his "Welcome home, Marine" that made me proud.
The fighting during this time demonstrated that the US had no choice but to firebomb and drop nuclear weapons to force the Imperial Japanese to surrender. Had we invaded it would have cost millions of more lives.
Can. Not. Wait.
Band of Brothers gave a glimpse into what made the WWII generation the last "Great Generation", and I will forever be humbled by the men of that era. Hopefully the Pacific will be just as well-done, and educational as Band of Brothers was.
Homicide was GREAT television!
MB,
Semper Fi from a Marine Corps Dad.
I have it set up already on my DVR.
I highly recommend "With The Old Breed" by Eugene Sledge, one of the characters in the series, IIRC.
One of the grittiest, most moving war stories ever.
very cool thread…
We, too, arevery much looking forward to the USMC getting it's day in the sun. The Pacific campaign was, and is, poorly explained and largely forgotten. When 'Private Ryan' came out and the public got hip to the slaughter that was Omaha Beach, many Marines privately groused that Iwo Jima was even bloodier- more ghastly- than the D-Day event.
Bit that was Roosevelt's great war against Nazism and the rescuing of Europe. Not island hopping across the Pacific because all the battlewagons were sunk at Pearl and required a new form of conquest- the air war with atolls serving more or less as aircraft carriers.
And the Marines bloody sacrifice to take, and hold- not only Guadacanal but Saipan, Leyte Gulf, Tinian, Rabaul-
names no one then- or now- remembered.
That is, except for those who served. May this be a tribute to those…
I'm looking forward to this! It's true, we always think about the European theater, but not as much the Pacific.
Part of the problem, too, is the perception among the public at large that the Nazis were "worse" than the Imperial Japanese, and the European campaign therefore more noble. I would certainly never try to diminish the atrocities of the Third Reich, but the brutality inflicted on their conquered peoples by the Japanese was no less horrific or merciless. And the Japanese, for all their bluster about "honor," fought with virtually none. I recall reading somewhere that the death rate among POWs held by the Germans was around one in twenty-five. By the Japanese…one in four.
If it is HALF as good as BAND of Brothers it will be great TV….. I am paitiently waiting to see this series….
Exactly right. just ask the Chinese and the Australians. Ask any survivor of the Bataan march.
"And the Japanese, for all their bluster about "honor," fought with virtually none"
Well put, this has been my understanding for a long time.
Excellent intro-piece to the coming series. Thank you BH for committing a special feature to this topic, and for selecting a Marine to share insights into the commentary here.
Looking forward to the first episode Sunday.
Any movie with Tom Hanks connected to it I will not watch. I stopped watching HBO yrs ago. Nothing but Liberal trash!!!!!!!!
Hanks sucks and all that worked on this film suck. They can wrap themselves up in the flag they still smell and still suck.
HBO just another Liberal liar AO's!!!!!
I am truly, truly grateful for the actions of the brave men who fought during WWII, make no mistake. I'm quite sure I'm going to Hell for saying this, but…I am totally sick of WWII! You guys were great! Freed the world! I get it! How many times do we have to be reminded? I'm sure it's well made & all, but I will be watching Undercover Boss & Celebrity Apprentice on Sunday nights.
Thanks for the heads-up. I have been waiting to see "The Pacific" but didn't realize it was on soon. I will be alerting my dad, too. I have high hopes for this one.
I hope they do, as well. It added a lot to the series. One problem, though is it is getting late and we are losing many of these brave men to age, every day.
Good point, from what I understand, events such as the Rape of Nanking, and the Pearl Harbor bombing, for example, is either not taught to the Japanese now, or the brutality of their forebearers is minimized.
I hope the same, and looking forward to seeing it, even though I don't have HBO. My dad has the "Band of Brothers" on DVD, so it looks like we'll go this route as well.
slightly off topic, but I caught Andy McKee last week locally. If you haven't yet seen or heard the most recent stuff, here is a nice video of Hunter's Moon
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=II39Y9yrmB0
get back together after break up…
Awesome post love the style…
I will never forget the final interview with Dick Winters on Band of Brothers. He said his grandson asked him if he was a hero in the war. He replied:
"No, but I served in a company of heroes…."
Gets me everytime.
The concept that Guadalcanal, Iwo Jima, Leyte Gulf are unknown or forgotten seems foreign to me, but since military history is an area of huge interest to me, I'll grant I may not be typical and certainly don't reflect the younger generation. No matter what, I expect this series to be great and hope I am not inevitably setting myself up for the disappointment of high expectation.
I'm a combat Veteran myself, having served 13 years in the 101st and being wounded in 2004 just south of Mosul I'm looking forward to this series.
The reality of the combat scenes will interest me,but I will be more interested in the interpersonal relationship of the men. The quality of any war film is how realistic the interaction is between the men. The psychological effect of being in a combat zone are as big an enemy as the enemy itself. The strength of leadership,especially the NCOs (as I was) is key to survival and success.
What separates the Pacific campaign from the European theater is the isolation,elements and a fanatical suicidal barbaric enemy.. The constant heat,malaria,shortage of supplies and a suicidal enemy weigh heavily on the psyche of a soldier. Gunny Basilone is the epitome of leadership. If Seda can portray him accurately the series will be a success.
I will be looking forward to Sundays debut and the postings and reviews.
God Bless our Troops
God Bless our Veterans
God Bless America
Oohrah. Thanks, from one NCO to another.
I highly recommend Strong Men Armed by Robert Leckie, one of the characters in the miniseries. It is the best book of the war from the point of view of Marine riflemen.
"…but since military history is an area of huge interest to me"
Well. there ya go. Most Americans know little of WW2 beyond what they learn in our public schools. Thus they can tell you all about the A-bombs and the internment of Japanese-Americans, but f**k-all about, say, Midway or Okinawa.
Sadly, there is undoubtedly way too much truth in your comment. These kids need to get to know the Duke.
I just read the latest Times article about Tom Hanks and the launching of this HBO series. I recommend reading it, particularly the first few and the last few paragraphs.
Michael, I am not so excited as some are to see this latest installment because, honesty, I don't get a genuine feeling that this is anything more than an ego driven exercise by Hanks and Spielberg. I don't doubt their awe of what these Soldiers have done. My knowledge of show business and show business personalities has left me so jaded, that it it indeed sad. I envision the genesis of this whole WWII exercise as something far afield of "Shoah" or any other slice of history that needed to be told and re-told. As an American of Italian descent, I'm especially proud to know that Sergeant Basilone's contributions will be profiled. My pride bursts as an American, period. But, I don't think I'd be completely honest if I didn't say that the lump in my throat swells just a hint larger when I hear an Italian surname mentioned with such respect. I hate to beat to death Tom Hanks' statements about (the ridiculously inaccurate) similes between the enemies we face today, and the enemies back then. I must point out that not unlike our own Civil War, we had men fighting and killing other men who shared the very same bloodlines. Be it Italian, German, or Japanese. Many of these ethnic soldiers were literally fighting cousins. A point in fact is that my uncle Tony was slapped on the wrist for fraternization with the enemy during the the push up the Italian Peninsula. He snuck off with a few buddies for a Sunday meal at his grandparents' (my great-grandparents) house outside of Naples. Our men were not demonizing or dehumanizing them because of physical or spiritual differences. Any asshole can tell you that whenever the fighting started, the Germans and Italians made the same Sign of The Cross as their American cousins. The Japanese Americans who participated quietly prayed (i confess my ignorance to Eastern deities or ritual) to the same ancestors for guidance that their Nipponese cousins were. This fight was over ugly aggression and fanatical visions of dominance by one group of humans over another. We, the Americans were on the right, just, and very correct side of this struggle. This was never about whatever Tom Hanks' little thesis implied. Never for a moment. Was there ugliness shown to the innocent Japanese here at home as well as on the field of battle? Of course. Was it as wholesale as Tom Hanks purports? Not even close. Were Italian and German nationals treated impolitely, sometimes. Were their civil rights compromised? Indeed, when it seemed the smart thing to do. But smart only in a time of confusion and vertigo. A temporary state till we could find our equilibrium. I can almost guarantee that Sgt. John Basilone's own parents had to forfeit their radios and possibly carry "Enemy Alien" cards. Certainly, it may have been a requirement for his dad. Our family suffered these indignities because they knew these were decisions made with the whole country's security in mind and not simply to single out foreigners for reprisal. Tom Hanks, Steven Spielberg, I know no other way to say this other than with my American grown, Italian topspin. Go And Fuck Yourself. On a side note. My Italian American neighbor, who has since passed, could never get over the fact that Steven Spielberg and Co. found it okay to refer to the fallen Italian-Americans as "guineas". Doubt me? Watch "Private Ryan" again, and listen to the dialogue that follows as one of the soldiers is counting "dog tags" of the fallen. "A lot of guineas are getting it today". Yeah, I can rationalize it as it being "the way guys talked to and about each other back then" but for some strange reason I don't think cinema verite is what he was really going for in that scene. JMHO.
Something comes to mind here when you ask "how many times do we have to be reminded?" Something about history repeating itself if we're not aware?
They were all heroes, weren't they? That is one of the better moments, you quoted in an all around excellent mini-series. We have the box set DVD, and I'll be cranking it in the ole DVD soon to watch yet again. I hope the new one will be half as good.
Because not watching t.v. versions of real events is what's going to turn America fascist? I went to school, I frequent my local library and bookstore. I don't need HBO to remind me of history.
Thank you for your service in the greatest fighting force in the world and your inaugural interview with Mr. Seda and Captain Dye. Although I do not have HBO, I hope that this series is successful, and I plan to buy the DVD set when it becomes available as I did with the Band of Brothers and John Adams series. Also, Naval History magazine, which is published by the U.S. Naval Institute, devoted its entire April 2010 issue to this mini-series. Again, thank you again and I am looking forward to future installments.
Thank you Jed, I enjoyed that. The man has such a wonderful talent. Sweet. Hope you're well.
Michael,
I wouldn't miss goin' on this ride with you for anything. Thanks for all of your hard work and for being such a stand-up guy. Looking forward to 'The Pacific'.
Michael a great article for a great series! I look forward to watching this and reading your series of articles. You rawk!
"Homicide" is my second All-Time favorite series!
Fantastic writing! Fantastic characters! What a pleasure to watch every Friday night.
One thing I enjoyed on the "BoB" DVD is the Dale Dye boot camp "documentary."
What riotous fun! I wonder if there will be a similar one included on the "Pacific" DVD box set.
Reading Mr. Seda's words was really heart warming. I don't know his politics, but at least he has a deep respect for our military and that's a definite plus in my book. I had to cancel my HBO recently for financial reasons, but we'll definitely be picking up the DVD when it comes out. I know Tom Hanks is a dolt, but look at Band of Brothers – despite whatever Hanks might think, it's still a well-honored mini-series. Plus HBO also gave us Taking Chance which was another beautiful military movie which showed deep respect for our troops, not because they were suckered into going to Iraq, but because they are brave wonderful people who put their lives on the line so that we may live in freedom.
Semper Fi (even though my husband's in the Army!
)
Look forward to seeing this when it comes out on DVD. Although Hanks has made a fool of himself via his recent comments, I'm sure Captain Dye kept him and Spielberg on the right track. It would be nice to take Hanks on a good old "Island Hopping" pit tour at Edson Range on Camp Pendleton. An hour of getting "Thrashed" might get Hank's head out of his ass.
Over the years working in ER medicine, I have had the honor of taking care of the of the rare flinty older gent with the faded blue blob on a forearm which to the knowing eye is the faded glory of the venerable "Globe & Anchor."
Careful to show utmost respect with a couple of probing questions, I have on two occasions over the past 6 years been blessed with brief oral histories of places like "Bougainville" and "Tarawa." I could see the eyes brighten, the posture straighten up a bit with the telling, men in their 80"s suddenly and very vibrant if only with the telling, and then the voice trailing off just as quickly, stopping far short of the complete reliving as if …..out of respect to brothers not with them now. Maybe because they can only completely go back there with those who had been there. Thats how I see it and I'm sure, that's how it must be. Still I was lucky to hear what I heard from men who had been there.
I have seen Band of Brothers three times. I think I will now buy the set. Amazing in an era of Blame America First that such a powerful, and I feel heroic, drama would be filmed. You would think Hollywood wood poison this historical presentation. Perhaps this new one, Pacific, will also be un poisoned and we will leave to our children and grand children a different story of what our fathers did.
that was because the media at the time, like FDR, had an established narrative- defeat of nazism/fascism.
And the Left, betrayed by their fellow leftist Hitler with the advent of Babarossa became obsessed with the European campaign.
Conversely, Japan whose Imperialistic designs on the Pacific were more nebulous, as was the conflict-
mostly cutting off sources of oil- was a hard thing to grasp. The code of Bushido- which drove the Japanese war machine- did not allow for anything other than complete victory on the battlefield- and the concept of a 'prisoner' was alien to them, ergo the death rates amongst POW's. So, honor was defined differently, and the war against Japan became racially- and ethnically- exploited.
Perhaps this series can lay uch of that to rest…
The story of brave men putting their lives on the line to protect their buddies and their country (regardless of time period) is TIMELESS!
How many times do we need to be reminded about the stories of these brave individuals? Very, very often, because their stories are not told, with regularity, in the government schools. If the government schools can't or won't do it…it's up to us, including PARENTS, to see that these men and women get the credit for their extraordinary service they so richly deserve.
Wish I had cable.
Two things about the Pacific War. First, Roosevelt decided to treat the European Theater as a priority so the Marines (and Army in the Pacific I believe) got old equipment through 1943, I think.
While the Army in Europe had M1s the Marines still had the WW1 bolt-actioned Springfields.
Second – I like to tell this story about my late uncle. Besides being a "drill corporal" at Perris Island, he was assigned to a cruiser (a light battleship) to be an adjutant to the captain. He was always by the captain at the bridge, and whatever the captain wanted, my uncle got. "I'm a sea-going bellhop", he would say.
During the battle of Okinawa when the Kamikazes were so effective – the Captain of his cruiser sent him for something, he went off the Bridge and a moment later a kamikaze slammed into the bridge.
When my uncle was back in San Diego, he was in line to get his Pacific battle ribbons. He saw a rather grizzled exhausted band of Marines from places like "The Canal", Tarawa and Peleliu for the same ribbons.
My uncle threw his away, not feeling worthy to receive the same awards as those Marines.
Someone near to me was injured during incoming a few miles from North Vietnam. The medic asked if he wanted to proceed with the Purple Heart paperwork, and knowing others who had been gravely wounded, he declined.
Well, maybe not you, but there are enough people who don't read history books from the library or bookstore, heck, not enough people who read, period. As long as HBO or any producer who makes an historically accurate representation of history, with as little bias as possible, I'll be interested in watching it. And if that's where people get educated, then better that way than HuffPo.
My father gave me the old Bill Mauldin book called Up Front, which contains Mauldin's cartoons from WW2. I think the GIs respected Mauldin because he was with them – up front.
Without reopening the book after many years I can tell you 2 cartoons have remained in my memory. One is a caption of a tired Willy and Joe sitting in some French Cafe – freshly liberated – and some soldier close to them is strutting with a belligerent look.
"I call them Garitroopers", Willy said to Joe. Away from the rear but too far back to get shot at".
The other involves a tired medic at the front offering Willy or Joe an aspirin and a purple heart. He takes the aspirin but declines the purple heart, saying that he already had one.
I have no doubt that many have been given out to the undeserving – but then many have been given out to those who paid the ultimate price.
As screwy as my state (California) is they offer for Veterans a special license plate – with documentation – denoting a Purple Heart recipient.
Your friend/relative sounds like he has a lot of character – like my uncle he deserved the award but knew of those hurt worse than him getting the same medal.
Like you I think he should have accepted it but can certainly appreciate the reasons for his decision.
This thing brings to mind something I remember seeing in our PX at Baumholder Germany almost 40 years ago.
Among all the ribbons along a wall for sale (Vietnam, National Defense) was a little blue ribbon with stars – a Medal of Honor Ribbon.
Now of course the military – if they caught someone wearing an unearned ribbon – well, they take a dim view of it. In fact I remember reading some years ago (within 20) a high Naval officer committing suicide because he was caught wearing an unearned ribbon. He was stationed at the Pentagon I think.
But to see that Medal of Honor Ribbon – to think the odds of winning **that** – and surviving – couldn't be more than a few 100 MOH winners in the country today. I think since the Civil War only 3,000-4,000 have ever been awarded.
To see the ribbon for sale at the PX – well, it seemed funny to me – and out of place.
I have read up on The Pacific and it is based on 2 memoirs – one by Eugene Sledge – and based on that knowledge it sounds like ir will be a first class production.
I finished Sledge's book – written by him many years after the war as a cathartic effort – just a few months ago. He was at Cape Gloucestor, Peleliu and Okinawa.
All Hellholes.
I had a neighbor who was a Marine and Pacific veteran. Did he have some stories. He survived Tarawa by walking along the bottom- about 8-10' deep – jumping up for air, and staying under water while wading it.
One thing he told me that always stuck was with the Japanese it was kill without hesitation and they did the same. Very few prisoners were taken. It was just assumed that you had to kill all of them coming at you.
The Japanese would even shoot the medics – and in many battles the medics would stop wearing their crosses on the helmets that drew the "attention".
My hat's off to you; I never had to see any combat. And anyone who knows anything about the military knows that the NCOs are the heart of its success. In fact that is a main reason why the American military is so good – a strong NCO corps.
BTW speaking of the Band of Brothers a 6th grade classmate of mine, Lynn Hester, had a father – Clarence – who ran a roofing company for many years. He never said a thing about his service.
After reading the book I learned that he was the CO of the 1st Battalion, 506th PIR
Your welcome Mr.Broderick ,and thank you for your service,
Trust me, it was my Honor to serve and defend the Greatest country in history.It was a privilege to serve with the Finest people I'll ever know. Ne'er a day goes by that I don't think of the Men I served with, and predictably it ends the same way ,full of Pride,Humility,Respect and Love.
Good luck with your new endeavor with this column and God Bless you and yours.
God Bless our Troops
God Bless our Veterans
God Bless America
,
Thank you Mr.Brandt for your kind words.
You were fortunate to have known two extraordinary gentlemen. Tarawa was hell on earth ,and being a retired MSgt.from the 101st. I'm very familiar with the history of the 506th.
You're right about the risk of being a Medic.Even today they're targeted by the enemy. Medics are some of the most courageous human beings I've ever served with.
I'm looking forward to our dialogue in regards to this series and other subjects.
God Bless you and Yours
God Bless our Troops
God Bless our Veterans
God Bless America
Who's going to be the first to call Hollywood's moral bluff
of turning out anachronistic, ad nauseum, done-to-death
PC WWII retreads —while making BILLIONS upon BILLIONS
unflinchingly outsourcing for cheap labor, and catering to the
franchise slum denial needs of history's –MOST– awesomely
genocidal regime —ACROSS the Pacific?
ESP. galling as millions continue to suffer and die for REAL
on this, the once again 'mysteriously overlooked' 60th Anniversary
of the epically, urgently relevant ——–KOREAN WAR.
AMEN
WHY is no one calling Hollywood's latest anachronistic moral bluff?
FACT IS —having made BILLIONS upon BILLIONS catering to the franchise slum denial needs of history's
–MOST– awesomely genocidal regime –ACROSS the Pacific (70 million exterminated in decades AFTER
WWII in 'peacetime' -unoutted, unanswered for, unmentioned -FACT-) -Hollywood's self-serving moral
alibi of choice remains the done-to-death PC WWII retread —er' we mean 'tribute'.
ESP. gallling as people continue to suffer and die FOR REAL on this, the once again 'mysteriously overlooked'
60th Anniversary of the epically, chillingly relevant, STILL unfolding —KOREAN WAR…
STOP buying into the set-up boys! -it's getting dangerous! —FOR REAL!
Reading some comment's posted here. I think it's kinda sad regarding the veiled political comment's referring to the producer's of this series… What? Someone with liberal politico view's cannot have an appreciation and respect for the service of our armed forces? I myself have left of center politico view's. But my father was in the Navy and I have nothing but the utmost respect for our troop's serving this country in the past and TODAY! It is not unamerican to question our government's decsions. For that is what America is about. I understand our servicemen and women sacrifice alot and I totally respect them for that sacrifice.
[...] BlogThe Final Showdown – Gordon Freeman VS Mario Gamespot’s Best Video Game Hero Part 2Big Hollywood body { background-color: #ffffff; [...]
… [Trackback]…
[...] Find More Informations here: bighollywood.breitbart.com/mbroderick/2010/03/11/hbos-the-pacific-an-interview-with-jon-seda/ [...]…
… [Trackback]…
[...] Read More: bighollywood.breitbart.com/mbroderick/2010/03/11/hbos-the-pacific-an-interview-with-jon-seda/ [...]…
… [Trackback]…
[...] Read More Infos here: bighollywood.breitbart.com/mbroderick/2010/03/11/hbos-the-pacific-an-interview-with-jon-seda/ [...]…
… [Trackback]…
[...] There you will find 74032 more Infos: bighollywood.breitbart.com/mbroderick/2010/03/11/hbos-the-pacific-an-interview-with-jon-seda/ [...]…
You must be logged in to post a comment.