TCM Pick O’ The Day: Tuesday, January 27th
by John Nolte
3pm PST - Trial, The (1963) – In this adaptation of Kafka’s classic, a man in a nameless country stands trial for an unnamed crime. Cast: Anthony Perkins, Jeanne Moreau, Romy Schneider, Elsa Martinelli Dir: Orson Welles BW-120 mins, TV-14
You can decide if you want to see it again, but everyone should see Welles impressive adaptation of Franz Kafka’s classic nightmare at least once, if only for the film’s stunning look and atmosphere. “The Trial” is a challenging film. There’s no real story, a whole lot of slow spots and an overall pace with little respect for the audience. But it is a wonder to look at and fans of the novel are likely to appreciate how close Welles came to filming what was widely believed to be un-filmable (or they might stand by that opinion).
The production was typically chaotic for a Welles picture, much of it self-inflicted by the director himself (which was also typical), but like most of his later films there’s always some genius shining through what you might consider a mess.
Anthony Perkins is Joseph K, an everyday man (that’s the point) who awakes to find himself under arrest and falsely accused for a crime no one can, or will, explain. His dizzying trip through a hellish bureaucracy and judicial system, all set in vast, empty, colorless interiors and exteriors, is photographed to disorient the viewer and create a constant sense of claustrophobia and hostility.
Long takes, gorgeous black and white cinematography, brilliantly conceived sets and locations, and a strong central performance from Perkins make “The Trial” a completely unique experience. Some say it’s a masterpiece, others a self-indulgent disaster. For my money, it’s most certainly flawed, but also unforgettable.







Subscribe via RSS
Got a Tip?
7 Comments
The sense I got from reading the book was that everybody was in or had been through this trial ordeal. The society Kafka described was a crushing place that brutalized everybody.
The movie didn’t see it that way. It was more like 1984 the movie. Winston there and Joseph here are lone insubordinates. I thought The Trial felt more like a home movie
John, Thanks so much for drawing attention to all these deserving, intelligent, pre-CGI films that run the risk of falling onto the celluloid ash heap. “The Trial” is a Perkins flick that, like “On the Beach,” only gets better and better with time – and with a good restoration – boasting the kind of deep, rich, black-and-white cinematography we never see anymore (except as a stunt or an hommage) and a purity of vision that is the result of sheer determination and hard work (as opposed to self-aggrandizing indulgence – Welles figured out how to keep shooting even after the production suddenly went bankrupt, and BTW Perkins was right there with him to the bitter end).
As in “On the Beach” (another timeless flick that holds up remarkably well), Perkins’s performance here also improves with age. Despite his quirky look and mannerisms – so unlike the other leading men of the day – his generosity and individuality on screen sneaks up on you in surprising ways. Who today compares to either Welles or Perkins?
Carolyn: I always recommend for the next day. That gives people plenty of time to DVR it, etc…
So is this movie pro-Guantanamo, or what?
I know that books written in previous decades don’t necessarily apply to current times, but the epxperience of some of the Gitmo people–kidnapped, accused, tortured; all without charge, evidence or trial–is definately Kafkaesque. A whole string of prosecutors quit because they couldn’t stomach the dishonesty of the “trials”! I guess that’s what makes us better than the country in which “The Trial” is set–at least some of our citizens do believe in the rule of law.
A movie only a “film” student could love. By far, this is Welles’s worst directing job, and Perkins acts as though he didn’t get it either. A really bad movie. Let’s have “Citizen Kane” and “Psycho”, and let this one crumble away in the vault.
[...] The Trial, Orson Welles [...]
You must be logged in to post a comment.