Revealing: What ABC Didn’t Show You from the CMA Country Music Fest
by Bruce CarrollThis article is nearly three months in the making. For the second year in a row, my partner John and I attended the Country Music Association (CMA) Music Fest in Nashville, TN in early June. As a side note, if you ever get the opportunity – GO! It is a weeklong celebration of great country music and the great American city of Nashville.
But this isn’t a tourist agency pimping of Music City. Nope, it is a damning indictment of Hollywood’s natural, auto-immune liberal bias. Let me explain.
During the actual CMA Music Fest in June there is a massive concert each of four nights at LP Field where the Tennessee Titans play football in the fall. The good old American Broadcasting Company takes four nights of country music and compresses it into three hours. That edited program was shown last evening on ABC for all to see.
As I sat in LP Field in June and saw each night’s great entertainment unfold, I knew with confidence that two notable events would NOT be aired last night on ABC. I was right.
In fact, I tweeted “live” from the floor of the concert when one of them occurred. Unfortunately, as usual, Twitter’s status history is malfunctioning. When viewers saw Tim McGraw sing “Southern Voice” last night on ABC, there was an important moment that the network cleverly edited out and actively hid from America. Why? Because it was inflammatory and would have exposed McGraw, a passionate Democrat activist, to extreme ridicule today.
In what looked like a throwback to the Black Power days of the 1960s, but in reverse, McGraw raised his fist during the chorus of “Southern Voice.” The first time he did it, I was surprised. The second time I was prepared:
—–
Not that I would make a big deal out of it, but imagine, if you will, if this was a known conservative singer who had raised his or her fist in the air while singing a song called “Southern Voice.” But where’s the outrage? Nowhere. McGraw actively campaigned for Barack Obama in 2008 (which makes the “white power” fist action even more surreal). In fact, McGraw lent his vocal talents in January 2010 to a soundtrack compilation, ‘By the People: For the People,’ inspired by the film, ‘By the People: The Election of Barack Obama.’ McGraw joined other notable left-wing artists such as Bruce Springsteen, Dave Matthews, the Dixie Chicks and Sheryl Crow on the album paying homage to President Obama.
I’d like to ask the ABC producers of the CMA broadcast last night why they chose to do a tight shot of McGraw during the white power fist move. And if he thought it was an okay move to make, why they felt they had to shelter him with their clever close-up and editing job.
The second item left on the ABC cutting room floor that America did not see last night was one of the most memorable moments of the entire week at the CMA Music Fest. Carrie Underwood, the reigning Queen of Country Music, based on her recent CMA awards alone, hasn’t hidden her Christian beliefs dating back to her days on American Idol in 2005. After all, her first mega-hit was titled “Jesus, Take The Wheel.”
Last evening, during the ABC edited telecast, Underwood’s highlighted songs were “Cowboy Casanova” (a sexy slam at ex-boyfriends) and “Undo It” (a similar, rock-pop-country song expressing regrets about an ex-boyfriend). Both are peppy dance numbers that don’t do justice to Carrie Underwood’s singing abilities.
As I mentioned, Underwood did make one of THE moments of CMA Music Fest and ABC chose to ignore it. Underwood took her “Jesus, Take The Wheel” hit and morphed it into the gospel anthem “How Great Thou Art.” In fact, she first sang the religious song on the stage of the Ryman Auditorium during the taping of a multi-artist gospel album. Since then Underwood has performed the Wheel-Thou Art mash-up at all of her concerts.
The CMA Music Fest performance was no exception and it was powerful. I was far from the only one in the 60,000 person crowd who had tears streaming from my eyes. When she was finished, the crowd roared to a decibel level not heard for the rest of the week – with the possible exception of another religious-themed song belted out by Martina McBride (also not shown by ABC).
It is a shame that the ABC audience missed the most memorable performance of the CMA Music Fest, while the network instead chose to find time to showcase pop-pixie Taylor Swift in a day-in-the-life segment. Luckily for all of us, fans like me had brought their cameras and one other stadium goer had the good sense to film Carrie Underwood’s finest hour. I strongly recommend watching the next four minutes, tell your friends about this performance, and ask yourself why ABC chose to ignore it.
—–
The answer of course to my silly question is that ABC, like most of Hollywood, actively and aggressively demotes the importance of Christianity – and God – in American society and pop culture. Sex, drugs, murder, anger and corruption are all highlighted by TV and movies in America to a much more frequent degree than religion. It is a shame that the producers at ABC probably looked at each other, rolled their eyes, and shook their heads “no” when the saw the Underwood performance. They have deprived millions of Americans of a wonderful gift from God. Luckily we can share it through the empowering media of the Internet.
I knew immediately when I witnessed these two moments “live” in Nashville in June that ABC would do their best to ignore or edit them out of the September 1st broadcast. I emailed Big Hollywood editor John Nolte earlier this week and told him about these two performances and my prediction of how ABC would handle them. Unfortunately, political correctness and anti-Christian bigotry is too easy to predict these days.
Not incidentally there was a third performance missing from the ABC broadcast. And it was missing from the entire week at CMA Music Fest in June. And it was not seen in Nashville at all since that city was devastated by a thousand-year flood this past May.
What would that be, you naturally ask? The fact is that President Obama has never visited Middle Tennessee and never properly acknowledged the devastation faced by its residents. Even Justin Bieber did his part.
If you would like to donate to the flood victims still suffering in Middle Tennessee and Nashville, please consider contributing to The Community Foundation of Middle Tennessee.






Subscribe via RSS
Got a Tip?
116 Comments
Ah, you're just a nutbag! They didn't do it on purpose! People make editing decisions all the time! This is nothing more than an editor's choice.
I'm just getting you ready for the response from any liberal that reads your article. Thanks for the heads up.
Know McGraw would never say it, not with the warmth of the President's posterior still warm upon his lips, but really would have been nice to have that "Southern Voice" fist accompanied by a Kanye-esque, "President Obama hates white people."
I don't know about McGraw but I do know that his wife Faith Hill was a Conservative until she married him and moved to CA. Yeah, there are liberals in Country Music but not that many. Yet. I've always like Carrie Underwood's songs. This doesn't surpise me at all that CBS(See B.S.) is censoring people. As much as I love Country Music, I'm not sure if I'm gonna watch CMA on CBS this year.
Meh, I don't know how to read Tim McGraw. Is he just jumping from one side of the bandwagon to the other?
So what you're saying is……..
Tim McGraw is a fraud……
and Tim is really a closet liberal………
and only acts this way…..WHITE POWER FIST and CONSERVATIVE…..ie COUNTRY MUSIC…….
to sell records and make his money from the "country bumpkins"?
I didn't know Tim McGraw is a dem activist. maybe he won't be for long, traitor. it is becoming apparent Obama and the dems are marxist/socialists with Sharia law leanings. Just great….
You're not suggesting that ABC consored those two events under the guise of editing, are you? Maybe they didn't have enough time for the high-paying sponsors, a typical capitalistic pig big corporation move. /
"They didn't do it on purpose! People make editing decisions all the time! This is nothing more than an editor's choice."
….and even I would believe that a few years ago. But not anymore… not anymore
I think you're off base on this and trying to make something out of nothing. Even after watching the clip, I would never have equated that to any sort of "power" move. Raising your fist during a performance is not unique and just because it came during Southern Voice does not mean anything.
As to what songs were aired and not aired, let's keep it simple. If I'm a producer, I'm going to put on what I think it going to get me higher ratings. If that's performances that are peppy and energetic, then so be it. Let's take it another step though. Did any of the artists have any creative control over what gets aired? Did you see all the footage that was shot by ABC? Was there a producer in all the cameramen's ears telling them to zoom in on Tim so as not to catch his fist in the air? Did you listen to all the audio for all the performances? You don't know what was shot, how it was shot or the quality of the picture and sound.
I'm not going to argue your point about "…Hollywood, actively and aggressively demotes the importance of Christianity – and God – in American society and pop culture." because I agree with you on that. Personally i think you might just be somewhat upset that you didn't get to see the performances that you wanted to see last night.
For the record I am a Conservative.
Wow, she is great. As to being left on the cutting floor, abc like the majority of the alphabet networks doesn't want to anything having to do with religion. That is unless it is associated with islam which they will broadcast in New York minute. BTW, the song, "Jesus, Take the Wheel", is fantastic.
Imagine singing a song called "White Power". I have to say that sounds racist to me and Tim McGraw should know better. It also makes me think is a lefty.
I don't think McGraw meant anything like "white power". I think he just did it because that's what dumb rockers have always done. He's a dem suck-up and I don't think he's smart enough to see the light, but he does pick good songs and his performances are some of the best in country music today. Not that I'm able to afford any of that in the Obama economy he helped to bring us, but I'm just sayin'…
It is really shameful they wouldn't air the Carrie Underwood performance. I hope it goes viral on youtube (although then ABC will demand it be taken off and youtube will say "yup"). Country music has always had spiritual roots. Why would anyone think the majority of the fans wouldn't want to see that?
They definitely should have left the Carrie Underwood performance in. It's powerful, it's exactly what country music fans love, and it's an amazing showcase of one of the top sellers (converting to ratings, yes?) coming out of Nashville today. They made a stupid decision. They could have used short clip of that performance for promotion and it would have been gold for them. They're clueless if they think it would have lost them ratings points.
What a libtard is TIm McGraw
Afraid for his public to see his raised paw
Pretty soon he will rap his rants
Trade his boots or baggy pants
This guy is a bigger joke that Hee-Haw.
Great for Carrie Underwood
A proud American, doing what she should
Praise her country and her Lord
Unlike McGraw; wrapped in Barry's umbilical cord
Undoubtedly country musics biggest peckerwood!
Wow! I'm not even a country music fan, but her performance of "How Great Thou Art" brought a tear even to my jaded eye! I also like the way she connected with her audience, even waving at individual fans several times during a single song. She came across as very approachable and humble. The passion in her performance is palpable and real! You can tell that she feels it with all her soul! Thanks for posting it! What a tragedy that ABC denied it to its viewers! Sad that we live in an era of such overt discrimination against Christians!
I would've loved to have heard Miss Underwood's "Wheel-Thou Art mash-up" (as you eloquently called it). Thank you for sharing it via the Internet.
I also feel somewhat betrayed by McGraw. The lyrics of his songs (at least his older ones) speak of love of country and love of the people in it, but he sucks up to a party that hates both. Unbelievable.
Obviously a Quick Draw McGraw fan did not like me taking exception to this libtards actions. Guess he is not into people being accountable for their actions.
Honestly, I've never heard of a "white power fist." Is that a Southern thing or something? Lots of people pump their fists while singing though, including black singers. I'm not sure that one means anything other than McGraw acknowledging his excitement to the crowd.
I'm completely with you on the rest of the article, however. It's not the least bit surprising that they would edit out religious music from the broadcast, and I agree that it was done deliberately. It's unfortunate, and given their desire for ratings, a little detrimental, but again, not surprising at all.
Those who straddle the fence end up with a stick up…….. you get the picture.
Carrie Underwood's "Undo It" would be the perfect music for a photo/video montage of all the people who have realized 0bama is a complete scam artist & failure- both as a president and as a man.
Taylor Swift is the right kind of person for the MSM … You didn't know that? Ever heard her mother talk lately.
The enablers of Obama, Cloward & Pivens will pay dearly for their hatred and treachery…boycott this progg…for he is clearly deploying Obama… You Go Carrie. God bless the freedom lovers…
The guy raised his fist for 'Southern Voice'. To equate that with "White Power" is to expose your own bias.
Maybe you are the liberal/leftist/progressive.
Aw, as someone who lives in Nashville (no worrys on the flooding thank the Lord), bless your heart for this piece. We didn't need the Bamster anyway. And Tim does that fist thang all the time not just for that song. He's a goober, but he's our goober.
While I still enjoy their music, Tim McGraw and his wife, Faith Hill, jumped on the Bash Bush bandwagon bigtime after Katrina. I've read that Tim wants to become either a TN governor or senator (can't remember which). And if he wins he will have a big D next to his name.
Speaking of country music and libtard nonsense, I have a question: Has anyone noticed that Lady Antebellum is being referred to as "Lady A" now?
The AP story about the CMS awards referred to the group as "LAdy A" in the first reference in the story about the award nominations. I've even seen the group referred to as "Lady A" on tv.
Some places, it may be acceptable for this — like in headlines where space is a consideration, but I sense politically correct mischief here.
I don't see this as a white power fist, I've seen this gesture made by all manner of singers, particularly evangelicals "when the lord takes 'em".
When you make this gesture in a bar,for instance, it means another round please, not the south will rise agin.
Carrie Underwood is amazing. Wouldn't this be a great video to forward to the jihadi practitioners to show them how beautiful and powerful a woman singing praise to God is? I think they could learn something. Fantastic.
Glad to hear your not dead. Anyone NOT moved by that performance would have to be.
It's a power fist…just not sure it isn't the usual I'm rockin' the bar power fist we all do when we're gettin' loud and proud, and that's not white proud, it's American proud…everyone invited. Carrie's song and roll into How Great Thou Art was amazing and it is too bad that it was edited, and that probably isn't a coinicidence that it is religious. I remember when Dolly closed the CMA's with a spiritual and a gospel choir that rocked the house…years ago before all this PC took over. Rickie Scaggs and Vince Gill too, amazing acapella on the awards show years ago. It's good to talk about it. If you hadn't shared this, those of us not there wouldn't even know it existed…and honestly, it made my day to hear her sing and see and hear the crowd respond. Thank you.
If Tim McGraw is a country music singer, I'm a goldfish.
I'll be glad when real country music fans take our Country Music back.
I GUESS TIM STILL REBELLIOUS AND MAD AT HIS ESTRANGED LATE GREAT FATHER TUG MCGRAW WHO WAS A REPUBLICAN.PLUS BEING A NOTHERN MEXICO RESIDENT (CALIFORNIA) I GUESS ITS JUST NATURAL FOR HIM TO BE A LIBERAL TWIT. REMEMBER OLD TIMMY THEY'LL COME FOR YOUR MONEY WHEN THERE DONE WITH WALL STREET
It can't happen sooner, ferris. If the packed crowds at Hank III shows are any indication, we're ready.
With all the legitimate concerns regarding media censorship and bias to focus on, calling Tim McGraw's fist raise a "white power" salute is more than a tad ridiculous. You just got done saying how he's drinking from the Obama Kool Aide and then you'd have us believe he's also making "white power" gestures? What sense is there in that. Raising a fist is a fairly common gesture used in a variety of situations. Unless you've heard him make white power comments, assuming he intended his gesture as supportive of white power is an illogical leap.
As defenders of truth, we as conservatives need to make sure we base our arguments on fact. Not wishful speculation. That's the territory of the other camp.
Goosebumps. How great Thou art, indeed.
the producers acted stupidly!
That didn't seem to be a "white power" fist.. Look, I think Tim is a poseur of the first rank, along with his wife, but that was a simple victory punch or whatever. People do it unthinkingly at ball games when their team scores. Whatev.
Meanwhile, if your kids were in public school today, you'd do well to make them watch Miss Underwood just to decompress their burdened souls.
I'm going to agree with mousiemarie. If they were doing it for ratings – I would say that most country music fans are probably Christian, even if they are not all conservative and probably would have appreciated the song, especially the conservatives.
As for the fist, I think it's either or – it could have been nothing, or it could have had a purpose. I'm not sure.
However, I give kudos to McGraw – didn't he star in The Blind Side? He may be an Obama supporter but he portrayed a conservative man pretty well.
I had no idea at all Tim McGraw was a democratic activist? I’m heartbroken. Well, another day another lesson learned. To think I paid my money to him for 14 or so albums so he can take that money and use it like this? I don’t think those country music lovin folks I have in my address book know this as it would have been brought up by now. Well guess what Mr. McGraw, I love your music but love my country more. You're now a CSINO. Country Singer In Name Only. Hollywood Country huh? C'mon Nashville, drum his arse out of this community pronto. How bout you Charlotte and NASCAR? Well, okay Hollywood Tim? Go ahead and live like your dyin……..but not on my dime.
You can have this goober as your goober. I'm mad as hell.
perhaps she should have sung some muslim song, and abc would have aired that one. they are not afraid of religion, only christian religion.
Speaking as an actual southerner, not a pretend hillbilly for Hollywood pop cultural mass consumption, there is nothing admirable or redeeming about supporting a President who is a communist street agitator thug, rabid political Marxist, iron-handed economic fascist, and black racist poverty/victim industry pimp.
You are exactly right about them and Katrina. That is the reason I said "no thanks" to them and their music. They showed a great lack of understanding about state and federal rights yet continued to run their mouths. If he ever does run for a political office I will be sure to send money to the person running against him.
Several years ago, when Tim and Faith just had one young child, they were on a CHRISTIAN talk-show, talking about their "Christian faith". Tim's Mother is a VERY STRONG Christian woman, and has appeard on MANY Christian talking programs. He may not be a Christian now—but he sure used to be! And he was certainly raised by a strong Christian Mother. "Train up a child in the way he should go, and when he is old, he'll come back to it". In all my six decades of life, I've NEVER seen this verse "proved wrong".
Interesting you say that. I told my country music lovin husband that what we here listening to last night was rock or pop. Every once in awhile they would throw in a fiddle or banjo for a few seconds and think that qualifies it to be country music now,but for the most part it was rock/pop. He pointed out that I shouldn't be surprised because the title of the show was Country Music Rocks Out, or something like that, and that's the reason why folks like George Strait, Alan Jackson, Randy Travis weren't there. Still, it looks like this brand of country music is here to stay.
I doubt it, if history says anything, country music folks will tire of the polished, warmed over 70's rock we hear today and long for the days of good singers, great music, and wonderful stories.
George Jones, Johnny Cash, Ernest Tubb, Lefty Frizzell, Vern Gosdin, etc. etc.
The writer is just being silly about Tim McGraw, IMO. As you say, lots of singers, athletes, and others raise their arms and pump their fists.
It may be that the writer, not knowing anything about the South other than what leftist slanderers have told him, assumes that a song called "Southern Voice" must be a white power anthem! He might try listening to the lyrics, which celebrate MLKing, among others.
Southern patriotism has nothing to do with race. Nothing.
Thank you for the explanation. I didn't think Tim McGraw was a big neo-nazi, but I guess you never know.
I'm going to present a different angle here and feel free to correct me if I'm wrong as I don't follow Carrie Underwood. "Jesus, Take the Wheel" is an old song. People already have that album. Were the songs they aired on her new record? If so, then that's what they've got to sell, hence the decision to go with new stuff.
I think McGraw is just celebrating his gold medal from the Mexico City Olympics. I must admit it's more powerful with white gloves too.
See B.S…….that's awesome! Mind if I use that?
I was also at the CMA Fest with my wife. Watching the show on TV I was hoping that they would close with Carrie Underwood doing Paradise City. That was an impressive performance. The girl can sing.
Carrie Underwood is amazing! Every time she preforms, she knocks it out of the park. She reminds me, a lot, like Shania Twain. Beautiful face, voice, and great girl-power songs!
McGraw…..Meh. Not sure it's that big of a deal, but had no idea he was so to the left.
Tim McGraw and Faith Hill are on the leftie bandwagon when they are in Hollywood with all the nutcases there ,but they know they have to show their country music fans that they are supporting traditional family values etc.Total hypocrites both of them.
RE: underwood: that is the power of music, not religion.
Thanks for posting that touching performance by Carrie. I would have never known it happened – ABCs goal perhaps ?
Country music leftists? Talk about the worst of both worlds.
Sorry, I don't buy a raised fist meaning "white power". Since when??? It can mean a lot of things, but i don't get that at all from this. I can remember the raised fist of black men during the National Anthem in 1968 being interpreted as "black power" but I'm not convinced even that was right. 1968 was very different from today. Lot's of good people — celebrity or not, supported Obama. It doesn't make them bad people. With the campaign lies of Obama, many people were duped.
a fist pump is not a symbol of white power… neither is not broadcasting a particular song when editing down a several day event to a couple of hours "anti-christian"… sheesh…ever think that maybe the producers chose to highlight her recent songs rather than an oldie ? (a song which, btw, got tons of play when it was on the charts) ..somebody is trying WAY too hard to be outraged.
"With the campaign lies of Obama, many people were duped"
Yeah. But it didn't take a lot of research to figure out what BO is all about. You'd have to have been willfully ignorant not to see where he was going to take this country.
"With the campaign lies of Obama, many people were duped"
Yeah. But it didn't take a lot of research to figure out what BO is all about. You'd have to have been willfully ignorant not to see where he was going to take this country.
Well, Tim should win the election, as long as he is bashing Bush. Good thing I deleted Tim's crappy music off my Ipod..
I thought it was ABC?
Oh, yeah – Tim has said he wants to be governor of Tennessee. This isn't going to be his year, though; TN has the son of a former governor (Dem) running against the Mayor of Knoxville.
Uh……yeah……that's pretty much it.
Where was 'ol Toby Keith …..another closet liberal cash'in in on southern patriotism.
Yeah, keep him. We got more than enough liberals in the music industry.
Hey!…Hee haw is a wonderful show!
So true!
And somebody is trying WAY to hard to make excuses for the liberal media…………thanks, but they don't need anymore help.
If she were singing about Capn' Crunch, I don't think it would be having quite the same effect.
As a proud Tennessean, I thank you for your article and for your appeal for people to help out if they can. I live in East Tennessee and we didn't get the devastating floods that Middle TN got, but there are still a lot of people in Nashville and the surrounding areas that need some extra help…and a lot of them don't want that help from the government.
Tim is quite the liberal. I have heard him say on local talk shows here in Nashville that when he gets tired of music he wants to run for Governor of Tennessee or some other political office. At first I thought, well that would be interesting. When he was asked who his political idol was he literally stated " Bill Clinton is the king! " Figures! Anyhow. Carrie has always been awesome to folks around here! CMA Fest is a big deal and I think it is the only festival of its kind where the fans get to literally interact with the artists. The best part about it is that the artists genuinely want to thanks all the fans! That makes it an awesome time to be here in Nashville!
I had no idea there WAS such a thing as a "white power fist".
I could not agree more with your assessment. I think Mr. Carroll is way off base on the "white power" argument, to the point of appearing embarrassingly naive — or worse.
As you so correctly point out, we conservatives need to base our arguments on fact. With the leftists among us hell-bent on providing a fresh daily supply of such facts, we don't need our friends going afar looking for material or seemingly making it up.
@Baywatchboy – have you ever been in a control room, or a tape edit bay, while a production is made? I have. One of two situations is normally happening. Either the "feed" is live or semi-live, and the shot selections are indeed made by a producer talking in the ear of the person running the "switcher". This is where you here commands to "take number 2" (meaning he wants camera two to be seen on the show airing). Or, you see all cameras being recorded and each camera operator is getting orders from the director (or producer…) as to how to frame up shots , or to move to some other angle, etc. Once they get these "genlocked" feeds in the editing bay, they do the same "take number 2" thing with the various video "tracks".
I do not know that I'm as certain as others that McGraw intended one thing or another with his hand. Perhaps others know more about this than I do. I do know that Tim McGraw is a very liberal person, based upon what he has said and upon who he has supported. He would not be the first very liberal person to be, ahem, "confused".
Actually I work in a post production sound facility and I have been in control rooms and tape edit bays. Obviously these performances were not live as, "This article is nearly three months in the making. " This means they had two months to sort through all the footage and see what was worth anything production wise. You're right, cameramen during a performance are getting instructions throughout a performance, but how many cameras were being used and I wonder if a producer was in the control screaming, "Everyone, closeup now!"
ABC had about two months to sort through all the tape to put something together for the CMA's. That is when final decisions would have been made for TV.
Point taken, but I will refer to m_broderick's comment as well.
As someone who TRULY does care, I beg you to consider your lustful temptations and repent from sodomy. It will destroy you and your soul. Everytime we commit acts such as sodomy, fornication, adultery, masturbation, etc. we are sacrificing a little bit of ourselves to the devil, and give him strength.
Gloom! Despair and agony on me …
It's telling that networks will give more time to people and scripts that mock Christianity and Christ than they would ever give to someone supporting both.
It's also telling that the networks give more time to the 5-year anniversary of the Katrina-New Orleans disaster than they ever gave the present-day Nashville flooding.
All this griping about Tim McGraw and "liberal" Hollywood, all because some asshole blogger spots a liberal under every bed. The idea of this show is not to be political. The idea is to SELL country music to people, and the more good feeling to it, the better. All you carping whiners need to consider that Tim McGraw himself recently portrayed a hardcore conservative in the film THE BLIND SIDE, which itself presented a family of conservatives in a very, very positive light. Studios and networks make programs people will watch, and at the same time try to promote what they believe the public will buy. Take the day-in-the-life fluff piece on Taylor Swift, in which the scornful blogger spots an insidious agenda. Swift is HUGE right now. HUGE. She's the Lady Gaga of country music. You can't show everything at the festival, so you have to make editing decisions. Swift is likable, so the studio takes the opportunity to keep her in the public eye. Meanwhile, I happend to watch the part with Carrie Underwood, and they showed her in a very positive light, as a happy, healthy, wholesome woman. It was upbeat and lively.
There's nothing to this. You people just enjoy pissing in your pants and sitting in the puddle that formed in your seat. It was designed as ENTERTAINMENT. And nothing else. No agenda, no big conspiracy. It wasn't intended as any kind of political statement. Jesus.
Don't bet on it. Music changes and evolves, just like rock itself has. The people who like the old stuff will continue to buy it, and some of the next generation will pick it up, but audiences will get smaller as time goes. It'll become a niche market. I like to listen to Tony Bennett, but anyone wishing to simulate his style is not likely to be making hit records. The mainstream is the mainstream and it is what it is. Old country music in its day was the mainstream country music, when the technology for recording and performances had limitations. But now performers aim to pack larger venues, which requires broader musical flourishes, exchanging a sense of intimacy for excitement. Taylor Swift and Carrie Underwood represent what modern country music is. I like it. They've taken a lot of the twang out of it, and the ka-thump-ka-thump rhythm, and they've turned into something energetic and fun. And that's fine by me.
Carroll is not naive. He's one of those conservative blowhards who enjoys being angry, enjoys looking for things to be angry about, and he's pandering to people who share his enthusiasms. And he's preaching to the choir, from the looks of a lot of these comments. They were lapping it up and swallowing it with glee.
Who the hell told you that country music was exclusively conservative? Liberal values are working man's values, and therefore in makes good sense that some of the country singers would be liberal.
WOW. Go Carrie. beautiful song.
You're both idiots. ABC wasn't trying to make it a religious event. Lots of things were left out of that four-day event. You have to go with what you think will appeal to general audiences. "Jesus take the Wheel" is not her best song. Someone without an agenda looking to make for an upbeat evening would bypass that for a lively tune. What was shown was terrific.
Who told you all this nonsense? "Economic fascist"? How? And a racist? Good God, man, step into reality.
There is no "leftie bandwagon," unless there's a rightie bandwagon. People vote what they feel is right for the country, not because it's a bandwagon.
Most of Underwood's songs are pop country. It's as Doowop said, it's about the power of her music, not the theme. I don't give a hoot in hell about religion, and I enjoyed her show the other night. It was thrilling. If she'd gotten all sappy and religious, I wouldn't have liked it as much.
What do you mean? He picked up the mantle of George Bush, pretty much. Same bailout strategy, same wars. I myself much prefer Obama over Bush. Those two wars really did us in.
Apparently you're ignoring the majority of comments, mine included, that don't prove your point. Typical.
It seemed to me that the article meant to primarily criticize the media, rather than McGraw. In the past, in regards to people and performers that have positively identified themselves as conservative, the media has not given them the benefit of the doubt on gestures McGraw made. With regards to conservatives, the media is all too willing to find racists under every bed and small, innocuous gestures such as the one McGraw made would be trotted out as proof of their point. McGraw, a Democrat activist, gets the benefit of the doubt that a conservative activist would not.
I find her music, and pretty much anything country, boring, personally. The only thing that moved me was the message. So to claim that it's just the music that is powerful is false. Maybe for you, that's the way it is. But to tell me and others that the message isn't what we find powerful is nonsense.
Typical of what? I looked at all the comments, and they're all pretty much enjoying the angry feeling they're carrying around (over nothing), and they are in fact reassured how right they are to be so angry about this big liberal-media conspiracy. There are a couple of exceptions that put the "white power fist" in context, but most are gleefully stupid and support the blogger's line of shallow thinking.
You're going to have to be a little more specific than that, which is nothing more than an accusation about the media, as most of this sort of stuff is. There's no proof that McGraw got the benefit of a doubt. What you have is a right-wing blogger spotting something that's done at concerts all the time, and he jumps right on it as something indicative of something the blogger dislikes, and he writes it up to other people who enjoy reading this sort of thing. Who is giving who the benefit of a doubt? And while you're answering that, go ahead and give me a specific example in which a conservative actor made some sort of gesture that was construed as political when it wasn't intended as such.
I'm not telling YOU that for YOU the music itself isn't what's powerful, but for the vast majority of people, it's the melodies and the SOUND that's important. Sure, if there's a good message in it, that's all the better, but the initial draw is the salient features of melody and power. Something has to draw people to the lyrics themselves. Primarily she's an entertainer. I liked her show the other night. I can't even tell you what the words were about. I just know they were general in appeal. When I want message, I read books.
Yeah it's ABC but all the alphabet channels are the same. Another B.S. Channel as I like to call it.
Hey Alric, idiot "this"…….the "general audience" for country music are people who appreciate traditional American values. Religious themed songs and flag waving play well in fly over country. ABC could grow their audience base if they would get that through their thick liberal skulls.
You must be logged in to post a comment.